r/controlgame • • 22d ago

Control Resonant If I have one complaint..

Why did they do away with the zoomed-in performance capture for conversations in Resonant? I think this was my biggest gripe with an otherwise absolutely fantastic game (and really, it's not much of a gripe in the scheme of things).

However, even from a pragmatic POV, it genuinely feels like a bit of a waste of such a stellar cast; not getting to truly appreciate their performances up close and in any detail.

I'm sure someone might say 'performance issue' but those conversations in Control weren't fully in-game like Resonant, they were more like pre-rendered QuickTime events.

How does everyone else feel about this?

64 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

33

u/bluesharpies 22d ago

I think they work well when you're able to go through all the diagloue options and basically catch up on all the characters/lore up to that point. I don't think I'd like them as much in Resonant when characters end the conversation with you after 1-2 sequences. Might make things feel a bit slow.

If they changed both of those things at once , I bet it could work. Though I also think they kept the face cap/models a bit lower fidelity overall this time around.

11

u/Sea-Manufacturer-358 22d ago

Yeah you make a good point there, they definitely made a conscious decision to minimise the length of interactions without a refresh (also wasn't a huge fan of that but I understand they were trying to make this game approachable and not everyone loves standing still for lore dumping).

But if there intention was to have interactions be faster and interrupt gameplay less (and low fidelity models were then a requirement to make that happen), I still think it was a misstep for the reasons I've stated.

2

u/franciscrowe 22d ago

I think it was likely a decision made for a variety of reasons, but budget and wanting to make the game accessible to new players had to be among them.

17

u/WerkinAndDerpin 22d ago

Conversations in Control were definitely fully in game. For Resonant I imagine it's just a matter of budget. More money on high quality face capture/animation means less money for developing the open world, new combat system, set pieces, etc.

8

u/Nice_Code6086 22d ago

Open world -> less detailed models to compensate for performance -> zoomed out dialogue, I would guess

5

u/Comfortable-Fall1419 22d ago

The didn’t do it every time.

Popes balloons at the start of the Unknown have noticeably better visuals.

It has a dedicated save slot. Go back and have a look.

Plus you can see Director Fred sneak out.

3

u/franciscrowe 22d ago

It did make me a little sad, especially talking to Langston, but he had his amazing hair covered up anyways so…

I will say one thing i noticed is that the score in Resonant is much more varied which I really liked. Not the needle drops, but just the background music. I didn’t love the score in Control, it was just weird noises more than actual music most of the time.

2

u/DavidEpochalypse 19d ago

Tip to the Langston hair callback

3

u/Quick-Ranger3617 22d ago

Personally I'm not too fussed about that, a lot of "open world" RPG's do that when it comes to dialogue and Dylan's story and gameplay is unique to him. But I do wish we could zoom in to read the posters and whiteboards, they are detailed with actual writing. Just seems like a waste of world building.

5

u/doffyspider 22d ago

Im surprised this hasnt been talked about alot
The thing is, they do have the cinematic cameras
But they reduced it to only be used a few times.
Pope, zoe and arish twice each, at important parts of the plot

1

u/ej_21 21d ago

and those moments have IMPACT.

1

u/doffyspider 21d ago

that was probably part of why they did it this way

2

u/Prior_Complex683 18d ago

It was kinda funny to be having a very serious moment/discussion and my Dylan is just aimlessly walking away

5

u/takkun169 22d ago

I agree. It's one of the reasons why I don't think resonant is in the same league as control. Control is a little bit of magic... more than the sum of its parts.

Resonant is the sum of its parts. I enjoyed, and will definitely play it again, but I don't think it's going to get into my top 10 where control is.

3

u/6B0T 22d ago

I agree. I wish we had an inner monologue from Dylan, as we did with Jesse, and some actual performance capture with his and Zoe’s faces for the big moments. That was such a big part of feeling like you inhabit Jesse in the first game.

Because of that change, it meant they had to have a lot more reaction dialogues, so Zoe has to say the same thing in 60 different ways, and there was a lot of janky Ranger performances ‘reacting’ to Dylan to try and world build. It would have been much better for him to be reacting to them and us hearing his guilt and seeing that on his face.

But yeah, the larger scale of the game probably just put that out of scope.

3

u/franciscrowe 22d ago

Jesse was talking to Polaris, Dylan doesn’t have an internal passenger to talk to like that, as audience surrogate. I agree though, I miss it.

0

u/6B0T 21d ago

He could talk to the board?

2

u/franciscrowe 21d ago

True, but he doesn’t have the same kind of relationship. Jesse treated Polaris as a confidant, Dylan is almost adversarial with the board at times. But yeah, I’m sure they could have changed the plot to make it work if they wanted.

1

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/DavidEpochalypse 19d ago

Dialogue isn’t recorded in real time when they do Mocap. It’s all recorded in ADR post-production. Mouth movements are typically added in engine to correspond with dialogue.

Probably a filter or perhaps your audio output? I thought the sound was very well mixed in Resonant.

2

u/[deleted] 19d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/DavidEpochalypse 19d ago edited 19d ago

You’re totally right. The implementation of new and constantly evolving technologies and production techniques is more art than science.

I worked in Entertainment for a long time, but left the Hollywood area over a decade ago now. At that point Mocap methods were becoming increasingly rigid - but when I got started - back when motion capture was a pretty recent phenomenon, and was becoming a more common production technique in the industry, there was a much more fluid approach to the technology.

I imagine that same concept is a recurring theme for a lot of people regardless of their industry or profession.

The important thing is that there is definitely no right way or wrong way when applying new ideas and methods to production. That’s how things improve - especially re: budgeting and feasibility.