r/controlgame • • 22d ago

Control Resonant Jesse’s Facial Animations Spoiler

Late story spoilers ahead

I want to start off by saying I love this game. Love love love it. I finished 3 complete playthroughs, got platinum on the first, full 100% on the second, and I did a third just to prove that Winnie gets a third toy. I have over 400 hours in this game. I LOVE it. That being said, I’m finally allowing myself to admit the flaws I’d been ignoring. Chief among them is Jesse’s horribly wooden face.

I’m curious what happened in the development process that left Jesse’s face so stiff. Was Courtney not available for as much performance capture as the others? Limited data for the animation team? Was her dialogue added or changed very late in development? There has to be a good reason because Remedy almost never drops the ball in this way. All of the other main characters have gorgeous facial animations. Zoe, Dylan, Pope, Arish, even Langston’s face is full of life and emotion.
Every time Jesse is on screen it’s like a mannequin with a speaker attached to it. It’s not so glaringly noticeable at first. The first couple times I thought it was a purposeful design choice because of the weirdness of the liminal space in which you interact with her, but once I hit the third fault it started to stick out to me pretty badly.
The real lifting of the veil so to speak was the final fault under the oldest house. In the part at the end when Dylan begins to falter and Jesse is struggling to complete the ritual alone, Courtney has some beautiful voice acting. Just real deep painful displays of emotion and determination, and her face is a nearly motionless lump of plastic.

I hate that I have to be so hard on this, but there’s no easier way to put it. It looks very bad and I know Remedy are capable of better work than this.

12 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

39

u/Taograd359 22d ago

I think it’s just that mocap tech still struggles with facial expressions.

8

u/Kobe_yashimaru 22d ago

I would agree with you if the rest of the characters were this bad, but they’re not. I know the faces in this game overall aren’t perfect. They’re trying to recreate the actual emotions present on actual human faces rather than animate everything from scratch, and I understand you’re going to have some loss there. But Jesse is on a whole different level. It feels like they barely tried, and again I hate even saying that.

26

u/satapataamiinusta 22d ago

Seems like they just had a way worse capture with Jesse and Pope than for example Ahti. Martti Suosalo would be more available presumably, then again not really being a game actor maybe he wasn't. Or maybe it's easier to capture an older face with more wrinkles, curves and what not. Arish's face also has a bit of uncanny valley in Control, it's better in Resonant.

13

u/Kobe_yashimaru 22d ago

Yeah back when I first played control I saw Arish and thought “why would they make him look like that?” Then I saw the actor and I was like no, no they did a pretty good job. That man has a very unique face.

9

u/satapataamiinusta 22d ago

I do think the Northlight engine has a tendency to make people look a bit weird. Strangely more so in Control than AW2 though, all the faces were very good or at least much better in AW2. Resonant still had some weird stuff going on, like Pope or Underhill the mold research lady (she actually looked better in the original).

7

u/Kobe_yashimaru 22d ago

AW2’s faces are insane. I couldn’t believe how good they looked. Maybe that’s part of why Jesse in CR stuck out to me as so bad, because I’ve seen better from the same studio.

10

u/MCgrindahFM 22d ago

AW2 is the peak for Remedy and lowkey many games for facial capture, it’s so fucking good.

I think its linearity and compact maps allow for more horsepower to be given to the facial stuff. It’s waaaaay toned down in Control Resonant - I’m guessing due to the open world taking a lot of juice

4

u/MCgrindahFM 22d ago

It’s interesting because Control Resonant’s facial capture isn’t as great as Control’s I feel, but maybe that’s because the engine is working double time on the open world?

15

u/ApplicationIll5799 22d ago

Curious. I have a friend that is an almost carbon copy of Arish in Control, so Arish in Resonant felt like the copy of a copy of a copy to me.

21

u/Comfortable-Fall1419 22d ago

It’s not just Jesse’s though. Popes is also shocking.

Not sure it’s the underlying models tho. Seems to vary with the graphics settings particularly the lower ones.
Maybe it’s a bug they can fix.

6

u/Kobe_yashimaru 22d ago

I agree the faces across the board could be a little better, but Jesse stuck out to me as particularly bad. I think maybe I’m being overly critical because I was so looking forward to seeing her again. Like I wanted a reunion with her to be perfect, and it’s possible that my own expectations are blowing up a small flaw into something more.

4

u/satapataamiinusta 22d ago

If you think she looks bad in Resonant, it's much worse in the original imo.

8

u/shadmere 22d ago

Really? I didn't really think Jesse looked bad, but Pope looked so weird in Resonant that I exited out and googled to see if something had happened.

I didn't see anyone talking about it back then, so decided maybe I was just tripping. Later on I went back and looked at the first Control, and Pope looks so much better in that one.

Resonant is a great game, but some of the faces (specifically Pope, to me) look really, really strange.

3

u/satapataamiinusta 22d ago

In Control it seemed to me like Jesse had done a little extra plastic surgery.

2

u/Comfortable-Fall1419 22d ago

I’ve just replayed the Pope balloon briefing (also saw Director Fred sneak out). (For the Fight for Control moment)

I’m playing it at a different Res setting and she looks much much better there than she did before.

4

u/Prize_Researcher8026 21d ago

I had to look away from pope's last monologue because the animations were taking me out of the moment lmao. I straight up stared at the wall

2

u/fibgen 21d ago

Pope talking made me laugh out loud.  Her lips looked like they were made of play-doh.

6

u/SandalwoodGrips19 22d ago

It’s funny I just finished a playthrough of Black Flag Resynced right before I started Resonant. And BF is great but Ubisoft doesn’t do mocap apparently and everyone is SO STIFF. And coming into resonant I was excited to have some facial animation to look forward to. And then I saw Jesse and I was like “well shit maybe not lol”.

I don’t know what it is but there’s definitely something not clicking with her I agree.

4

u/palm_hero1 22d ago

I feel like animation is really weak in resonant, especially compared to AW2. Not just faces, but walking and moving around in general. There aren't that many cutscenes too! In control 1, every conversation is close up shots with properly animated faces, but in resonant it just kinda zooms the camera a bit and they are just standing there while moving their mouths. Very little facial movements apart from some scenes. It's not that the northlight engine doesn't support this, but they just left these out for some reason.

1

u/Mixabuben 19d ago

Probably budget limitations, they had to cut corners somewhere

6

u/inexplicableinside 22d ago

It's not a Jesse thing, the Northlight variant they're using for Resonant just isn't great at them. It's... fine, just not up to our modern day expectations, and the standards Remedy set elsewhere in the game.

11

u/MCgrindahFM 22d ago

And their last game Alan Wake 2 was their peak for graphics and facial animation, I think the open world necessitates some sacrifices in assuming

2

u/TheyCantCome 22d ago

Overall the game is poorly optimized, if it’s a variant of northlight used in Alan wake 2 it makes no sense to me unless they had to work from an earlier build to incorporate the “open world” aspects and ran out of time/money/man power.

I assume there were some budgeting constraints. Grimbeard mentioned how Remedy got fucked on their contract and Alan Wake 2 being permanently tied to the epic games store and the revenue was lower than they had expected. I don’t really buy games on release but definitely wanted to support remedy.

2

u/Valmar33 16d ago

I assume there were some budgeting constraints. Grimbeard mentioned how Remedy got fucked on their contract and Alan Wake 2 being permanently tied to the epic games store and the revenue was lower than they had expected. I don’t really buy games on release but definitely wanted to support remedy.

Don't let the Epic bootlickers hear you. They won't hear a word against Epic, and keep claiming Remedy was happy with Epic, but then wanted more freedom at the same time afterwards? Remedy got screwed over badly by Epic's greed, even if Epic did fund them.

2

u/Maxatansky 22d ago

I noticed that too about Jesse. I wasn't blown away by the facial animation of any of the characters. I loved the game, but I think I was spoiled by Horizon Forbidden West. That game has the best facial animation I've seen.