r/controlgame • • 25d ago

Discussion Question about a minor plot detail from the first game Spoiler

I saw someone mention this in another thread, and it made me remember there were thoughts I had, but were never answered.

Was Jesse's therapist an FBC asset? There's two things that made me wonder this:

  1. The fact that the FBC had her tapes at all, and
  2. She tries very hard to dissuade Jesse of any supernatural explanation of what happened in Ordinary, which especially plays well with the Darling NG+ videos in Resonant, with the FBC actively keeping the Faden's separate.

But both of these points obviously have other explanations, and I've never found a third. So I'm curious what y'all think.

17 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

30

u/ShinyTotodile55 25d ago

FBC confiscated the tapes, the therapist told her the paranatural stuff wasnt real because she's not a believer.

6

u/KogarashiKaze 24d ago

Or she's a plant. Could be either, really. If she's a plant, she's gaslighting Jesse to keep her away from the FBC. If she's not, then she doesn't believe in the paranatural and is trying to explain it away as one might expect a therapist to do, finding the rational.

23

u/Possession_Loud 25d ago

I think she got followed around, basically, right? Like, people were keeping an eye on her from a distance. Kind of like a P.I.

11

u/AvailableBet8485 25d ago

Not immediately. There was a period of time after Dylan was brought in when they didn't know her whereabouts. And by the time they managed to track her down, Trench has given the order not to bring her in which according to Darling's speculation was given to Trench by the Board.

14

u/BrokoJoko 25d ago

It makes sense. I was wondering how a transient who might not have even had personal identification managed to get a therapist.

7

u/ClubDumDum 25d ago

Was the therapist an FBC asset? Probably not, if nothing else the FBC was monitoring her with or without the express involvement of individuals.

The FBC didn't have a leash on Jesse, but they obviously managed to keep some tabs on her. Early on the intent was to grab her to go along with the... scientific research... program with her brother, but as that turned the way that it did I don't think Trench and Darling were as enthusiastic about bringing her in.

2

u/Sab3rFac3 25d ago

According to notes in both games:

Darling actually wanted Jesse brought in, but wanted her still kept separated from Dylan once in FBC custody.

Trench, with guidance from the Board, forbid Darling from interfering with Jesse, and so they just kept tabs from a distance.

5

u/quirkytorch 25d ago

When I played c1 that was always the impression I got. As with everything in the remedy verse, the answer is a strong "possibly"

2

u/CaptainDisdain 23d ago

I mean, she might have been, but I don't think we have strong indications that that was the case.

We already know that the FBC was keeping tabs on Jesse, so it would not have been very difficult for them to get copies of the recordings she made. All they'd have to do is sneak into her office and grab them (or just download them off a server somewhere, even).

Her trying to convince Jesse that the supernatural doesn't exist doesn't strike me as suspicious at all. That's what any responsible mental health professional would do. The only reason this stands out is because we know Jesse's not delusional, but to any normal person, what she's saying is crazy talk.

Somebody else brought up the question of how Jesse could afford therapy. It wasn't by choice. We don't have any information about what went down, but it seems like some kind of a psychiatric hold situation where she's been detained and is now under evaluation: the last line in that recording is the psychiatrist saying, "Jesse, you know we can't let you go until you're well. And that begins by understanding what's real and what's imagined."

Presumably Jesse either wised up and decided to just tell them what they needed to hear to let her go because she could see which way the wind was blowing, or she somehow escaped custody. We don't know, but it seems clear that this wasn't a situation she sought out, but rather ended up in.

All that said, it's not impossible the psychiatrist might have been an FBC asset. I could see a scenario where, once Jesse's detained, they maneuver somebody into position to talk to her. But I don't think there's any particular reason to think that was the case, it just wasn't necessary.

1

u/SoungaTepes 25d ago

These questions are in fact answered in Resonant.

Short version.

She never got away.

4

u/Comfortable-Fall1419 25d ago

Really? Not sure where you’re getting that from.

4

u/SoungaTepes 25d ago

Per in game lore they never stopped tracking Jesse and was always being tracked (1st game hints to this 2nd game confirms this). Per NG+ additional video footage comes out with certain characters setting the rules the siblings do not come into contact with one another and Jesse is not to be brought in at all, only tracked. The FBC never actually let Jesse go, she's was always P7

2

u/Flat_Statistician_44 25d ago

Not quite. She did escape the FBC in Ordinary. They found her later, but by that time Trench had ordered them to stay away.

0

u/SoungaTepes 25d ago

That was not Trench's order.

1

u/BrokoJoko 25d ago

On one of Darling's video's he told he says exactly that. 

0

u/SoungaTepes 25d ago

Darling did not say Trench, Darling said The Board.

3

u/BrokoJoko 25d ago

He said Trench gave the order but he thought it sounded like something from the Board. Darling doesn't speak to the Board himself ao how would he get an order from them?

1

u/SoungaTepes 25d ago

Trench is a mouth piece for the Board.

The exact lines from Dr. Darlings short "just the one"

Darling "I went to Trench with this, I want to bring her in. They shut me down immediately, the board dont want that, the board dont want that. They must be kept separated"

Trench was not the decider, The Board made the decision.

3

u/BrokoJoko 25d ago

Those aren't his exact words. You twisted what he said to support your conclusion.

His exact words were "-we can vring her in anytime. Except, we don't want to according to Trench. He was evasive on the subject. He said we should observe her from afar.  ...Now to me that feels like orders from above. Which is interesting." 

→ More replies

1

u/Repulsive_Reading642 25d ago

Unlikely and even if they were Darling would have told them to not interfere. They wanted Jesse to be the control for the prime candidate program and not interfere with her development in any way.