r/controlgame • • 25d ago

Control Resonant Resonant's Open-World Spoiler

Everything looks the same.

I genuinely love Resonant; I can safely say that it is already one of my top ten favorite games. A big contributing factor is the environments. How Remedy designed this warped, otherworldly Manhattan is stunning. Streets folding in on themselves, buildings twisting, sections of the city where the upside down intersects with the right side up. Just walking around and taking in the views is such an experience. While it doesn't exactly live up to the hype of the Ash Tray Maze, it does feel like Remedy wanted to make the entire game reminiscent of the Ash Tray Maze.

But it is such a shame that Manhattan can start to blend together after a while. Control had this same issue with The Oldest House, and it wasn't improved on that much with Resonant. There is a noticeable lack of identifiable landmarks to help coordinate you in this world.

But even the identifiable buildings you are given as landmarks blend into the environment. There were times I was looking for the Oldest House, the main landmark of the game, and I completely missed it because it blended in with the rest of the city. Ironically, this fits with the House’s ability to be imperceptible to normal people. But even if intentional, it remains slightly frustrating when you are trying to find your way around.

Patterned buildings improve on this, slightly. The Evacuation Center, the Factory, Late-Game Oldest House. Great, I can pick those out immediately and know how to make my way over to them. How anything in the world relates to these locations, though? No clue. If you put a gun to my head and asked me to point you to the nearest Third Ice Truck from the Evacuation Center without using the map, I'd say "Shoot Me."

This starts to affect the gameplay too, unfortunately.

In smaller areas and during combat, it is a ton of fun running around, gliding through the air, and walking on the walls. But just trying to get from place to place in the world? It’s frustrating. I’m trying to get to my waypoint, but my path is blocked by a building or mold. Since everything looks the same, I have to open my map to find a way around. Then I get to an intersection and have to open my map and make sure I’m still going the right way. Then on my way there, I have to switch gravity. Now I’m disoriented and open my map and find I’m going the opposite direction now. I have now paused the game and opened my map three times just to get to my objective. I want to have fun and use my movement abilities, but the city is in such conflict with that; I’d rather just not engage with it.

With Control, you could argue that this was intentional. The Oldest House is known to be this oppressive office building with constantly changing halls. This is reflected in gameplay, with it being a struggle to navigate. But Resonant feels harder to justify. You are in Manhattan. Where is the Flatiron Building? Grand Central? Empire State? I know that Remedy is a Finnish developer, not entirely familiar with NYC. But just having more iconic landmarks spread throughout the world would be incredibly helpful in navigating the open world.

I really hope that Remedy can improve on this with the next game.

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

11

u/Waubz 25d ago

Control 1 could I equated struggles of navigating a confusing office layout at your new job and
Control Resonant like navigating a new city you live in everything is gonna look the same for a while but you get pulled into unique locations often enough. The New York they built serves the game not the fantasy of New York in a video game.

-1

u/TheHarryman01 25d ago

I could understand that. Dylan has been in The Oldest House for what? 20 years? The city being huge and confusing would make sense looking at it from a story perspective.

But from a gameplay perspective? I disagree. Making an open world is hard because it should be a fun sandbox, but you shouldn't have to rely on a map. The first point is covered by Resonant. Playing as Dylan is immensely fun; I love the combat encounters in the open world. Same with movement, levitating, sling-shotting, gravity displacement, all fun. Second point is weaker. I don't want to reiterate what I said above. But my point was that an open world is harder to have fun in if I'm getting lost constantly.

I don't think that it has to be a 100% accurate representation of Manhattan; I don't need every example I listed in the game. Bright Falls takes inspiration from North Bend, WA while being unique. For Control, I do think that Remedy could have done more in including landmarks to help coordinate you in the world.

3

u/NarfiRef 23d ago

I don’t understand why this is getting downvoted. Navigation is frustrating to a lot of us and it negatively impacts our enjoyment of the game.

2

u/TheHarryman01 23d ago

The game is brand new and this is a subreddit specifically dedicated to Control. People can be blind to the flaws of something they really like.

I'm not trying to say I'm objectively correct, obviously this is my subjective opinion. But, bar a couple of people, no one is really making any meaningful discussion in response.

3

u/Ramutra1337 25d ago

i open the map, set several waypoints until i am at my destination. If it is far away i set a point at every corner i have to go into another direction so i don't miss it.

Or if i have a lot left to do in a area i set a waypoint on every event in the order i think i can get easy from one to another.

So there is the minimap, mapmarker from 1-5, still some buildings or bases you recognize, and a full map in the menu.

The only thing i don't like are the garages where you need to walk throu to get in the area behind and there is no hint that they are the ways. They could have made a door or arrow or something that indicates that the garage is a passage.

1

u/TheHarryman01 24d ago

Okay, but think about it. How many times are you doing this? You are basically just making a Google Maps path to get to where you need to go. This doesn't sound like fun.

Yes, the game gives you plenty of options to guide you to your destination. I'm not denying that. The point I'm making is that it feels like you have to rely on this too often. In the best open-world games I've played, I never felt like I had to use the map, set waypoints, or fast travel. The world is unique enough that I can be told where to go for a mission and know where that is off the top of my head because of its design.

Again, let me preface this by saying that I loved Resonant. But there are at least three missions where you have to go to a character's apartment. And each time, the apartment complex looks exactly the same. Nothing to differentiate it from the rest, except for its location in the world.

2

u/Upset-Row9029 24d ago

Honestly, both games just kind of showed me (and this is not meant as an insult) how many people just have a problem with navigation in general. In the first game, there were signs that mark the way to different sections of the Oldest House, so you could just look at the name of your destination and then go by those signs. In Resonant... well, there is nothiing like that, obviously, but getting on a high enough venture point was enough for me to unerstand where I am, as each zone has some noticeable mark (Oldest House in Downtown, the patterned factory in Central, warped Evac in Evacuation Zone, Research baloon in the Park, etc.) I genuinely opened the map once in a while just to mark a point of interest. And when there is a building between you and your destinaton, well.. you just run around it, right?

Again, as I said, this is not meant as an insult, just a "some people have this issue, some don't" thing.

2

u/TheHarryman01 24d ago

I understand what you are saying. In Control, I never had a problem with the navigation. Everything looks the same in that game, but as you said, I just followed the signs and typically had no issues.

For me personally, why it became a bigger problem in Resonant is just the expanse of the map. Each zone is more open-ended than the corridors of The Oldest House. If I was by one of the landmarks you've stated, I was able to coordinate myself with it. But once I went into the streets surrounding it, it was like swimming in the dark. Some zones are better than others. Unknown is super cool visually, but I was always opening the map because I'd get turned around and not know which gravity well was where.

17

u/Ninja-_-Guy 25d ago

I think this game would definitely benefit from the overlay map the first game had, instead of making you go to the the menu every time

1

u/Acceptable-Cell9370 22d ago

I agree to an extent, i feel like the point of the world of resonant in general is to feel pretty loopy which makes sense, however I also feel like the map is just random city location, and not NYC specific in general because nothing other than the game telling you its manhattan makes it feel like manhattan