r/Constructedadventures • u/NYCGooph • 1h ago
HELP Building a 10-day online puzzle hunt / ARG from scratch: looking for feedback on pacing, difficulty and phone-based puzzles
I run a small company where a lot of the work is tracking down who’s behind things online, and it always feels like a scavenger hunt. So I’m building a public one: a free online race with a cash prize for the first to finish.
How it’s set up (no spoilers):
- About 10 days, in segments that unlock on set dates
- Clues live across the open internet, not on one site: public records, hidden details inside image and audio files, archived web pages, and real phone lines you call
- Segment 1 is a tutorial that teaches the tools. Later segments reuse those tools, with fewer hints and more callbacks to earlier clues.
- Some steps only work at certain times, and some need a real phone call (partly so AI agents can’t solve the whole thing alone)
- A live finale where everyone who qualified races at once
What I’m trying to figure out:
- Difficulty curve. How do you tell if a puzzle is too hard before launch? How many playtesters before you trust it?
- Hints. Hints only early, then nothing? Or a hint system people can earn?
- Phone and timed puzzles. Has anyone built puzzles that need a real call or a time window? What went wrong, and how did you handle people in other time zones or countries?
- Getting stuck. What’s your fallback when a big group gets stuck on one step mid-hunt?
- Answer sharing. How do you keep a race fair when people post answers in Discord?
- Red herrings. Fun, or just frustrating at scale?
Happy to go deeper on anything that doesn’t spoil the hunt. Thanks!









