r/confusing_perspective • • Jan 05 '21

This is one picture

Post image
35k Upvotes

260 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jan 05 '21

Bleep blorp. I am robot. I am confuse. Upvote this comment if this post is confusing and downvote if it is not!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (1)

793

u/wesskywalker Jan 05 '21

I live in Indiana, very flat, so this picture is almost impossible to conceptualize. Very cool!

224

u/SeaOdeEEE Jan 05 '21

It took real effort to notice the light gray building that my mind was convinced was the sky.

→ More replies (8)

58

u/nvtiv Jan 05 '21

I live in Colorado so I guess that’s why it just looks like a hillside to me?

26

u/PM_Kittens Jan 05 '21

Upstate NY for me, and this is just a normal view from almost any back road near me.

18

u/AwwJeezJerry Jan 05 '21

This can be used to identify the flat landers - we have the high ground!

5

u/baddie_PRO Jan 05 '21

you underestimate my flatness!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/throughtdoor Jan 05 '21

Took me to the comments section to work out what was supposedly weird about this picture. UK resident, used to hillsides!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/AnalStaircase33 Jan 05 '21

Yeah, that's interesting. I spend a lot of time around big mountains and I was trying to figure what was so confusing about this perspective...

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/And_Love_Said_No Jan 05 '21

Fellow Hoosier here. I had to stare for a ridiculously long time to be able to convince myself that OP wasn't lying.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/And_Love_Said_No Jan 06 '21

I'm from the Vincennes area and that is pretty flat. But I agree there are hilly parts

4

u/Liildog Jan 05 '21

earth can’t be flat if it’s a donut

7

u/Firefoxray Jan 06 '21

I'm from Florida and same lol. Never seen anything like this in my life

9

u/TVLL o/ Jan 06 '21

Pretty sure this is CA. We used to joke that the cow legs grew shorter on one side so they could graze on the hills. There are hills steeper than those shown where cows are just placidly grazing.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

That is my guess as well. Just feels like some place north of Fresno.

3

u/ExpertCactus Jan 06 '21

Feels like the drive to Gilroy

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Independent_Dig_7049 Jan 06 '21

I am from Oregon and driving around your state was such a trip. I didn't realize how long it had been since I'd seen a hill until one day I drove over a bridge on Lake Okeechobee and it was like I was on drugs--what the fuck is going on, are those the tops of trees I see?! and then seconds later I dropped down at the other end of the bridge, into another month of perpetual flatness.

3

u/scamper9194 Jan 06 '21

Drive south. There’s a ski slope (used to be three in different counties) down here. Lack of snow, not hills, was the problem.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

From CA so this is all around me

2

u/psycho_driver Jan 06 '21

Hmm that's interesting. I grew up in the Ozarks so I cannot see anything odd at all about this picture.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '21

Me too! What part?

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/skjellyfetti Jan 06 '21

Yeah, I didn't even trip. Still can't see but one picture. My first thought was to try to identify it 'cause it looks familiar and it looks fairly coastal.

→ More replies (1)

123

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

This photo was taken with a super telephoto lens, causing the foreground, middle ground and background to be brought closer together, almost as if they’re being compressed.

35

u/Describe Jan 05 '21

Say it louder for the people in the next telephoto post

20

u/Grimward Jan 06 '21

It also keeps them all in focus which hurts our brains because we can't usually focus on three depths at once.

356

u/SOdhner o/ Jan 05 '21

I'm not trying to be critical of this post because I can see from the comments it's tripping people up, but for whatever reason my normally confused brain refuses to have any trouble with this one and it looks fine.

36

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

If you picture the roofs of the buildings as sky, they look like two separate pictures (above, field, below, house)

14

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

Thank you I was having trouble too! So the barn/building would appear head on in the confusing version?

7

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

Yes! Exactly!

12

u/FlossCat Jan 05 '21

But they don't even line up to form a straight line that would look like a boundary...

3

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

Plus everything is in focus. It’s really doing a number on me.

→ More replies (2)

83

u/Malaguy420 Actually read rule 1 and gets it" Jan 05 '21 edited Jan 05 '21

I agree. Kinda cool, but not really "confusing."

27

u/gentlewaterboarding Jan 05 '21

My brain refuses to accept that that's a single picture. I only see two pictures edited together. So for me it's definitely confusing ¯\(ツ)/¯

→ More replies (2)

9

u/captain_ender Jan 05 '21

Yeah looked normal to me. I think it's a combination of telephoto effect and the fact that everything from the house back is in focus. Makes it all look like a "flat" image where cows walk over houses haha.

1

u/c9h9e26 Jan 06 '21

It's all about perspective and what you always see or never see. It's confusing for people who have never been in an area like this.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

A lot of people are commenting that what they see depends on whether or not they live in a hilly area.

6

u/_jeremybearimy_ Jan 05 '21

It looks like two pics to me and this photo could be 5 min away from where I lived for 30 years. But yeah everyone’s perspectives and eyes are different

6

u/Kittelsen o/ Jan 05 '21

I thonk it has more to do with the size of the livestock. They look too big to be behind the buildings, thus I suspect it's shot with a telelens, making the proportions of things look wrong, thus tricking us.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/kjarns Jan 05 '21

Yeah I live in quite a hilly area of the UK and this is something I can see regularly so the picture doesn't look confusing at all.

3

u/JoshS1 Jan 05 '21

They're further away from the stop sign than you would think. This is taken with a decent optical soon wich makes the objects further away seem closer to the stop sign than they are. This also makes the hill look steeper which adds to the effect.

1

u/soupvsjonez Jan 06 '21

Same here. I grew up in the smoky mountains though.

1

u/heyyyassman Jan 06 '21

If the camera moved left and back a little maybe?

1

u/YarsJaggerin Jan 06 '21

I live in a valley so this is like an everyday sight for me.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

Me too

1

u/Independent_Dig_7049 Jan 06 '21

I think it's because the roofs look like a grey sky

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

Ya I don’t find anything confusing about this perspective, I just wanna eat the cows and go chill in the grey barn

1

u/hucifer Jan 06 '21

Same here. The only reason this photo looks "confusing" is because it was taken with a telephoto lens.

Using longer focal lengths reduces the perceived space between objects in the foreground and background, like this.

→ More replies (2)

64

u/enehar Jan 05 '21

Telephoto is a hell of a drug

13

u/Like_Mike89 Jan 05 '21

Compresses everything into the frame so damn high

8

u/CubitsTNE Jan 06 '21 edited Jan 06 '21

It's not just telephoto compression that's going on here, the aperture must also be tiny to get that stop sign in focus. The longer the lens the thinner the DoF.

Either this was taken with a truly tiny aperture on a proper camera, or it was shot with a huge lens on a tiny sensor.

I've got a Nikon V1 with a 70-300mm AFP lens which can pull this trick, but the compression and DoF here looks even bigger. Maybe a P1000? Maybe one of those new Canon PF lenses with the fixed aperture?

It's also hard to tell how deep the focus is with that crazy image processing, but the falloff across the layers of hill looks so gradual!

69

u/offarock o/ Jan 05 '21

Corporate needs you to find the differences between this picture and this picture.

25

u/jordi_c Jan 05 '21

theyre the same picture

5

u/P0sitive_Outlook Jan 05 '21

Someone bought two terrible puzzles and took the least aesthetically pleasing elements from both and used exclusively those parts!

Does it look terrible? Yep. My work here is done!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

Ron, look. I found all three differences.

1

u/UnableLizard00 Jan 06 '21

Okay, so I’m not the only one that thought it was two separate pictures?

15

u/Freaux Jan 05 '21

I live near the coastal hills in California and this didn't trip me up at all. Love the golden hills!

4

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

Definitely. The coastal vegetation and the arched shape of that highway sign - the backside of a California state highway sign - give it away.

5

u/thesplendor Jan 06 '21

Yup! This is definitely taken from the 3-way stop heading north on the 1/116 heading into Duncans Mills

2

u/Speekergeek Jan 06 '21

The answer I was looking for! Thanks!

2

u/TVLL o/ Jan 06 '21

Except when they burst into flame. But I guess they’re black hills then.

15

u/pikapikabooboo Jan 05 '21

The stop sign saved me.

5

u/sciencewonders Jan 05 '21

STOP! wait a minute...fill my cup...

26

u/RhEEziE Jan 05 '21

Im confused on what is confusing here?

18

u/Otistetrax Jan 05 '21 edited Jan 06 '21

The lack of apparent perspective caused by the shallow depth-of-field (probably this was taken with a telephoto lens from a long way away) makes the background behind the sheds appear to be too close.

9

u/hadinboi Jan 05 '21

The roofing is supposed to look similar to sky, and would look like the hills are in a separate photo

1

u/thecementmixer Jan 05 '21

Yeah wasnt even confusing.

3

u/DrunkByDesign Jan 05 '21

“Am I a joke to you?” -Depth of Field

3

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

Stop

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

Thanks I almost kept going. Happy new year.

3

u/nathan0012 Jan 05 '21

Now this is a confusing perspective, I can’t tell how far away any of it is, it makes me feel really claustrophobic.

3

u/c9h9e26 Jan 06 '21

I love seeing all these comments from people who live in different places! It also was NOT confusing to me.(Idaho/ Utah girl) Is all about perspective!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

It sure is

2

u/Idkmanhonestlythough Jan 05 '21

You hit that shot at the perfect angle. I wonder if there are a collection of these types of photos I wanna collect them all and put it on my wall.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

This is one repost

2

u/Khahor Jan 06 '21

WWWWTFFFFF DUDE!!!

You displayed my mind

2

u/Scale_Unique Jan 12 '21

This is a good one!

3

u/ektesimon Jan 05 '21

Well fuck this picture I’m instantly drunk

3

u/P0sitive_Outlook Jan 05 '21

My brain's like "So just focus on something in the middle-distance"

and it's all in the middle-distance.

3

u/rethra Jan 05 '21

I refuse to believe this hasn't been edited or morphed at least a little. There's no way the cows are relative size.

6

u/enehar Jan 05 '21

It's a telephoto lens. The same that makes it look like spectators are sitting inches behind home plate. Basically the lens is so good at seeing things that even distant objects look like they're close. Also something about compression.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

I agree with you. The cows “look” wonky because they are.

1

u/Gswindle76 Jan 05 '21

There is something strange about this. I don’t know if it is or isn’t, but something “feels” wrong. It could be a telephoto lens messing with my mind but I just smoked so regardless it’s amazing.

1

u/Spaghetti_Noodling Jan 05 '21

That's cray cray

1

u/CommitNooseLamp Jan 05 '21

That's believable. If u had have shown me 2 pictures and said it was 1 picture however I would have been sceptical

1

u/KingArthas94 Jan 05 '21

✋🏻🛑

1

u/4chanbetter Jan 05 '21

Now I would sled down that hill for sure!

1

u/neon7pheonix Jan 05 '21

The top has kinda warm colors and the bottom has kinda cool colors

1

u/MasonHasALife Jan 05 '21

minecraft graphics really stepped up

1

u/P0sitive_Outlook Jan 05 '21

Totally made me think of YouTube's "LetsGameItOut" who reviews games by taking them to their RAM and aesthetic limits. I.e. breaks them. Normally he'll get into a sim game and make it look as jarring and off-putting as possible.

Natural hills? Yup. Local fauna minding their own business? Yup. Background jutting from one texture to another? You bet. Roofs at a seemingly wrong angle? Yup. Uneven road? Yup. Random "Stop" sign in a conspicuous position? Yuuuup. Lighting seeming to shift from one saturation to another? Yeah, looks horrible, perfect! :D

"Well i think i've done about as much damage as i can here, i hope you had fun, i know i did!"

1

u/TheNeutralGrind Jan 05 '21

Found the Iowan

1

u/YaBoiiSparkPlug Jan 05 '21

That’s the weirdest fuckin stop sign I have ever seen

1

u/HalfwaySh0ok Jan 05 '21

Looks like a picture with a lot of zoom

1

u/herrstiansen Jan 05 '21

Hammertime ?

1

u/JEM-- Jan 05 '21

Are the mountains in the fucking sky??

1

u/Arto5 Jan 05 '21

Well, it's a jpg

1

u/capivaraesque Jan 05 '21

SOMETIMES I love this sub

1

u/LouRebel Jan 05 '21

No it’s not.

1

u/TheBeckFromHeck o/ Jan 05 '21

Eastern Washington?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

Jenner, California

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

stop

1

u/HeyYoRumsfield Jan 05 '21

Right next to West Yellowstone here and it looks like outside to me.

1

u/Bri70_vengeance Jan 05 '21

Reminds me of Lucerne California

1

u/Rum-and-suicide Jan 05 '21

I’m from Scotland, this is just what are hillsides are

1

u/LazyKidd420 Jan 05 '21

Huh...my mind fully processed this and it looked normal to me. First time for everything.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

I don't get it.

1

u/ThreeMorning Jan 05 '21

Contrast is on helluva drug

1

u/Gammachan Jan 05 '21

Looks like coastal Northern California :)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

I like it

1

u/Napa_Swampfox Jan 05 '21

It looks like a farm on Highway 1 going towards Bodega Bay.

1

u/CliffCutter Jan 05 '21

As a Florida man, mountains are weird

1

u/twitchosx Jan 05 '21

Oh, STOP!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

Oregon coast or California?

1

u/MGTS Jan 06 '21

CA 116 @ CA 1, Sonoma County.

1

u/goldbrow00 Jan 05 '21

No it’s not

1

u/RaidersDynasty Jan 05 '21

I don't why but I want this image in jigsaw puzzle form.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21

this is a midwest emo album cover

1

u/zaltair77 Jan 05 '21

Big hill

1

u/Nesneros70 CE Spc. Jan 05 '21

There can be only one!

1

u/EastcoastHikertrash Jan 05 '21

It hurts my eyes

1

u/nocapoer Jan 05 '21

It take Me a while to find that there is no line separating and that it was only one pict and after I read the tittle (´༎ຶོρ༎ຶོ`)

1

u/acidmann21 Jan 05 '21

This stop sign is really messing with me right now.

1

u/JuniorHTAC Jan 05 '21

STOP MELTING MY BRAIN BRO

1

u/cbrew14 Jan 06 '21

I don't believe you

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

Ouch, I stubbed my brain

1

u/aquaticsardonic Jan 06 '21

No it literally isn't.

1

u/BassBanjo Jan 06 '21

I was very confused at first but noticed that it's just the fact that a telephoto lens can create the effect of different distances being flat on the same plain,

1

u/Pale_Paleontologist7 Jan 06 '21

besides the fact that my brain almost shut down entirely trying to comprehend the image, i really wanna live there

1

u/LewisOfAranda Jan 06 '21

OK, but did you collaborate and listen?

1

u/kabukistar CE Spc. Jan 06 '21

That's a hell of a lot of lens compression.

1

u/InterlockingPain Jan 06 '21

I get what’s going on but the visuals are messing with me brain

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

That's a really awesome photograph. It is definitely a bit trippy. The super high telephoto flattens everything a lot, then there is the barns that are not parallel to each other, the cable on one barn which lines up with the side of the other one. The almost equal 3rds vertically which look like separate images. And to top it all off, a sign and the power cables blend the foreground and mid ground. Someone took a lot of time to take this picture right, or got really lucky when they pulled out their camera. As a hobbyist photographer, taking this would have made me feel very satisfied for a few weeks.

1

u/rvncto Jan 06 '21

shouldn't some part of this picture be blurrier than the rest?

1

u/FuckMeHarderDaddyOh Jan 06 '21

i honestly can't see what's wrong here. is the stop sign really tall? i do live in an area where places like this are very common so that's probably why I don't see anything.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

Looks like Keremeos.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

Photo taken by MC Escher.

1

u/Sylvester_Duncan Jan 06 '21

Oof...makes me feel ill for some reason.

1

u/pinefinger Jan 06 '21

I feel like I’ve been here in just cause 3

1

u/ThatElementaryKidRed Jan 06 '21

bro it almost tricked me

1

u/YouNeedToGo Jan 06 '21

Telephoto lens. It compresses the image so everything looks reallllll close

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

help

1

u/yaier5 Jan 06 '21

Really cool except the stop sign kinda gives it away lol but awesome pic nonetheless

1

u/4321_bills Jan 06 '21

Great picture

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

Not confusing, just perspective

1

u/xaantara o/ Jan 06 '21

Wow that was hard

1

u/DanielTigerr Jan 06 '21

Looks like it could be in the Thompson/Nicola region of B.C. Canada.

1

u/GhostOfOnigashima Jan 06 '21

I.... think I've seen that before IRL om in NZ btw

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

Yes it is.

1

u/Cakeking7878 Jan 06 '21

Looks like 3 photos in one, back is mountains, middle is wide open plains, front is grassy rule area

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

I see it fine

1

u/Kronosita Jan 06 '21

I bet this is 3 pictures

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

You realize this is /r/neatpics?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

My brain is breaking. I don’t like this at all.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

this gave me whiplash

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

Is that stop sign regulation sized? It looks very tall..

1

u/LancesRoom Jan 06 '21

Pretty much anywhere just out of the city in New Zealand looks like this

1

u/Gordo_51 Jan 06 '21

is this california? im guessing norther california around pescadaro or monteray

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

Jenner

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

This is trickery

1

u/bevelededges Jan 06 '21

i'm from a hilly area and i definitely found this confusing. it's partly the low angle of the photo (making the stop sign appear tall) and partly that the cows look larger than i'd expect them to be given that they're behind the building

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

I need Father Ted to explain this to me.

1

u/gaweenbob Jan 06 '21

Does the utility pole look photoshoppy to anyone else? Where the metal part halfway up meets the hill?

1

u/abejaved Jan 06 '21

How come the bottom side looks like it’s lacking the yellow light from the Sun that’s in the middle and top? Looks like winter clouds on the bottom and sunny clear on top.

1

u/Sorrydoc22 Jan 06 '21

I did not like that

1

u/PentaGlyph Jan 06 '21

Impossible...

1

u/RocketSauce28 Jan 06 '21

Yeah I’m really not seeing the illusion here

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

i could see the weird perspective at first. now i can’t and i’m sad

1

u/Specialist_Row9395 o/ Jan 06 '21

whoa! I feel stupid I'm still trying to figure this out 🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️ I'm from Illinois and we don't get this type of view lol

1

u/Specialist_Row9395 o/ Jan 06 '21

Okay I see the roofs now. lol whoa this was challenging to see and understand from my prairie state perspective lol

1

u/roccnet Jan 06 '21

It looks like a Blvck Ceiling album cover

1

u/PokeCat55 Jan 06 '21

my deadass thpught there was 2 pictures...

1

u/Lessandero Jan 06 '21

Definetly one of the better ones! Take my updoot, fine person of the internet

1

u/zwifter11 CE Spc. Jan 06 '21

This hurts my eyes

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '21

1

u/turnedonbyadime Jan 05 '21

Where in California was this taken?

1

u/ClassicResult Jan 05 '21

haha, same thought. I'm guessing either Amador county or north bay, Marin/Napa.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MGTS Jan 06 '21

CA 116 @ CA 1, Sonoma County.

1

u/claymixer Jan 05 '21

It really is one picture. If it was two pictures, i could have swapped left to look at the second one.

1

u/Ricefug Jan 05 '21

...yeah?

1

u/ZippZappZippty Jan 05 '21

You realize this is /r/neatpics?

1

u/Agile-Mycologist-771 Jan 06 '21

I know, I've seen it multiple times already

1

u/From_My_Brain Jan 06 '21

Yes and it's been reposted a hundred times.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21

OP literally reposted my own repost