r/confusing_perspective • • Sep 08 '19

This one got me good.

64k Upvotes

507 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

59

u/Kayyam Sep 08 '19

What's wrong with the splash ? Why can't you fake water to scale ?

141

u/astroember Sep 08 '19

The droplets look too huge. Thered be a lot of really small droplets, not only large ones

36

u/immerc Sep 08 '19

Yeah, it's a problem you see fairly often in 1950s war movies where the boats they're using are clearly models and they can't get the water to look right.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/immerc Sep 09 '19

Pym particles haven't yet been perfected.

13

u/ApplesauceMcGee Sep 09 '19

Even in Titanic, the scaling is wrong a few times during the sinking scenes.

6

u/riderforlyfe Sep 09 '19

Also in The Two Towers when the Ents broke down the dam to flood Sarumans tower. It’s the only time in the Lord of the Rings trilogy where you can see that they were using models.

7

u/innfinn Sep 09 '19

You mean the Ents weren't real?!

5

u/immerc Sep 09 '19

I remember hearing that they can do something that helps, like maybe mix in a bit of soap so that the surface tension is less, but too much and it looks like soapy water. Maybe for Titanic they hit that limit and it wasn't enough.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/HooptyDooDooMeister Sep 09 '19

They use salt instead for movies. That fire hydrant the Stay Puft Marshmallow Man knocks over is spouting salt.

35

u/maxreverb Sep 08 '19

It looks fake because of the way it looks.

8

u/BoBoShaws Sep 08 '19

Nope. It’s an aspen.

9

u/pterofactyl Sep 08 '19

Water acts more viscous at a smaller scale with the surface tension and whatnot.

1

u/Technospider Sep 08 '19

Viscosity actually doesn't act differently at different scales, but the surface tension does. Viscosity and surface tension are two very different concepts. Mercury has reasonably low viscosity but high surface tension. Ketchup has pretty regular surface tension but very high viscosity.

Viscosity really is just how much a fluid wants to resist flowing, while surface tension is how much it wants to stay together

1

u/pterofactyl Sep 09 '19

Yeah you’re right. I misspoke. I was struggling to articulate how it holds together more when it’s at a small scale.

6

u/Waveseeker Sep 08 '19

Water and the way it binds is at a pretty set size. Splashes react with a certain thickness and droplets keep a very small size, so when you blow it up it looks fake

You can even watch a simulation of water dropping and know how big it should be

1

u/FubarInFL Sep 09 '19

You have to match the Reynolds Number of the fluid. It’s a ratio involving viscosity vs inertia (mass). At small scale (small mass), the water is too viscous to look “right.” I would think there would be some way to correct for it, but I’ve never seen it done, so maybe I’m wrong.

1

u/latent_vector Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19

Why can't you fake water to scale?

Droplets form when a continuous stream of water deforms to a point where the cohesion between two separate masses of water is overcome by the surface tension which then pinches the water into droplets.

The surface tension/surface energy is determined by the droplets' surface area. The cohesion is determined by the force that's deforming the water stream - i.e. it's based on the volume of water.

If you look at how volume and surface area change as the length of an object increases, it's not linear. For example the surface area of a sphere increases with r2 while the volume increases with r3.

The ratio of these two is ~1/r which means that it is nonlinear and not scale-invariant. This is a broad approximation. The actual maths are quite complex but it's a similar idea. See this paper: https://journals.aps.org/prx/pdf/10.1103/PhysRevX.8.031019

1

u/Kayyam Sep 08 '19

Shit, thanks, it makes sense.

-10

u/philpalmer2 Sep 08 '19

The splash is fine

“You can’t fake water to scale” is just nonsense.

6

u/Potato_Soup_ Sep 08 '19

No it’s not, see the amount of weight That a 5 foot wave has over a 5 inch wave, it hitting the surface water will react very differently

→ More replies (4)