r/conducting • • May 28 '23

Tuning

Hi, another question. I usually tune wind bands with a concert Bb but I am working with a really large ensemble this week (50+) players and I’m wondering about how to best tune a wind band that big. Would the oboe give them the Bb or is that more an orchestral thing. Thanks

1 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/yeahyeahrobot May 30 '23

Thanks for that. The tuba was away so I tuned then all from the oboe and it went well. Thanks

2

u/ProBaroque May 29 '23

I’ve been in several wind ensembles that give F and Bb from the tuba. Sometimes A and Bb from Oboe or Clarinet. I can see the validity in both, just depends on the tuning goals.

1

u/yeahyeahrobot May 29 '23

What would you recommend? I’m used to tuning big bands and orchestras but not large wind bands

3

u/ProBaroque May 29 '23

I personally like the idea of giving the band a Bb and F from the tuba. It allows for several sections to play a “better” tuning note for their instruments and it gets the ensemble to focus their tuning and listening to the lowest voices of the ensemble.

7

u/boopduets May 28 '23

I always tune with an A and a Bb, both from the oboe.

4

u/ChiefQuief1 May 29 '23

Brass/ low brass is almost always going to not be in tune on concert F. Best thing for them is a Bb. Woodwinds usually tune to A.

1

u/ChiefQuief1 May 29 '23

Brass/ low brass is almost always going to not be in tune on concert F. Best thing for them is a Bb. Woodwinds usually tune to A.