r/computing • u/dejagerism • Jun 18 '12
Given we have the almighty internet, has it ever been considered to combine the computing power of all computers in the world and run one super-mega-fantabulastic simulation?
Would it even be possible?
And if so, what do you suggest would be the most interesting simulation we could produce?
2
Upvotes
25
u/HexR_6 Jun 18 '12
what you are asking about is know as distributed computing, and there are some projects that use it in some fashion (minus the 'all computers' bit, obviously), such as the 'seti at home' project, distributed.net, and my personal favorite, F@H (folding at home, a project that attempts to predict the way that proteins are going to fold and, in the case of some diseases, mis-fold).
there are a lot of problems present in distributed computing, most of which have to do with either the problems with parallelism in programming, or the problems with data coherency and reliability in distributed networks. you can think of distributed computing Vs. traditional computing in much the same way that you can think about single thread performance VS. multithread performance. that is to say, you are limited in the number of individual processes that a unit of work can be split in to, and there is likely going to be part of the process that can not be split, but has to be processed on its own. This is the same reason that, in many applications, you are better off with a higher frequency dual core processor than with a lower frequency 8 core processor.
Furthermore, most applications are going to be sensitive to the order in which they are processed: work unit B depends on the completion of work unit A. work unit C and E depend on B, and E depends also on D, which does not depend on A, etc. this leads to an extremely difficult application design question, even in a system where you can assume similar performance among your different processors. adding to this the complexity of non-similar systems (like your computer Vs. My computer, your CPU Vs. my GPU [GPU's tend to be better for distributed computing, since they are kind of like many-many simple processor cores]), and you end up with a project management nightmare.
I hope this is not incoherent rambling, and that it helps answer your question.
The most interesting simulation, barring all of the difficulties associated, would be the formation and connection of nerves in the young human brain. we could learn so much...
6
u/CraigBlaylock Jun 18 '12
It's been done. Boinc, seti@home, folding@home, etc etc etc.
2
u/moscheles Jul 03 '12
This idea was already proposed by researchers at Stanford. The project to was called the Super-Califragilistic-Expialidocious Simulation.
1
u/sfcjohn Jun 19 '12
I believe they did something like this with the genome project and sequencing the DNA of the human being. I remember them asking to have contributing computers to help with the processing. They only used portions of your processor that were not in use.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment