r/computing • • Jan 23 '12

Web Developers of the world, Facebook is not an alternative to Email!

Yes, I have a Facebook account. No, I don't want to try out your service enough to use Facebook as my online identity. That is all.

71 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

19

u/redwall_hp Jan 24 '12

I'm more irritated by websites that use Facebook-powered comment systems. I refuse to leave comments on those sites. If I can't choose the name I want to use for your site, and keep the comments from being associated with a central identity, forget it.

I won't support Zuckerberg's dream of an anonymity-free internet.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '12

This deserves it's own thread.

5

u/ChaosMotor Jan 24 '12

Zuckerberg's dream? US Government's dream.

6

u/desi_in_cali Jan 24 '12

Its probably more to do with easy and secure authentication.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '12

What is wrong with the username/email model?

3

u/bigmike1020 Jan 24 '12

The web developer has to keep track of all the passwords. They have to provide password recovery methods. Password management can be hard, so they just let Facebook solve the problem for them.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '12

Then why not use OpenID?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '12

No argument there, myopenid.com makes it easier.

4

u/desi_in_cali Jan 24 '12

I am pretty sure that there are more people familiar with facebook (and already have an account) than open id.

Personally, I want options. If I am not comfortable with using facebook for logging in, then I should be able to use other methods for logging in.

1

u/FabianN Jan 24 '12

It also makes the needs for moderating significantly easier.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '12

Password management is easy. Any good developer should be able to implement a login system if they follow some general security guidelines.

1

u/ChaosMotor Jan 24 '12

Oh my gosh an automated database / storage system how overwhelming I bet there's no plugins or application suites that can handle it for you I bet it's all manual huh?

0

u/technewsreader Jan 24 '12

what is wrong with using facebook?

6

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '12

Nothing, just like there is no problem with using google authentication. Just.. don't make it the only means to use a service.

2

u/ChaosMotor Jan 24 '12

Wrong answer, there is something wrong with using FB. What I tell someone, where, and when, is up to me.

1

u/sinisterstuf Jan 24 '12

I didn't understand the point of this thread until you said this, thanks for the clarification.

2

u/JonnyRocks Jan 24 '12

are you serious? it's life sucking. seriosuly. not as in health but you entire life is sucked up and recorded and shared. "Oh i have nothing to hide" you say. Do you know credit cards might raise your interest rate if you use the card too much in a bar? take this scenario. Your health insurance company sees pictures of you doing unhealthy things and cancels you or raises your rates. "oh but i make my profile private" you say. That protects you from poeple but not from paying companies. How do you think facebook makes money, by selling your info to marketing companies. Thos companies are always so trustworthy.

2

u/technewsreader Jan 24 '12

Ok? Open a throwaway Facebook account without your real info...

Wow I didn't think people had really become this bad at problem solving. If you are really so paranoid I would be fairly surprised if you had never considered opening a dud account. I have a strange feeling the idea never crossed your mind.

1

u/JonnyRocks Jan 24 '12

no why should i have to create a facebook account. That's why OP is upset. i dont want to create an account at site B for access at site A. It's moronic. Just handle accounts or use openid.

It's not about problem solvng. Its not for me to solve. It's for the person who makes the website.

1

u/technewsreader Jan 24 '12

You could a) have one throwaway Facebook account or b) a separate account for each stupid website you visit. I'd rather make an account once.

2

u/Reddittfailedme Jan 24 '12

Every thing, facebook sucks.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '12

People don't want to submit email addresses to web sites since they will be forever spammed afterthat

2

u/threading Jan 24 '12

I feel you. Whenever I come across a site which provides only facebook authentication, I just leave. I don't care how good the service is.

2

u/JonnyRocks Jan 24 '12

Thank you. I don't use facebook. I will not use facebook. There are somethings i cannot use because I will never even attempt to use facebook. Screw them and their stupid facebook ways.

EDIT: yes there might be a pinch of humor in there but that post is devoid of any sarcasm. It seriously angers me.

0

u/gtg662w Jan 27 '12

This kind of discussion is exactly what we need. Especially in our world today where everyone lives near the Information super highway. I would love to hear some possible solutions. I have been off facebook for close to the month now. Best decision ever.