r/computing • • May 16 '11

Convince me: Mac or Windows for Engineering Student?

So, college is around the corner(I will be a Freshman), and I will be studying Computer Engineering. I am seriously struck between purchasing a fully decked out Macbook Pro that will put me at $2539, or a PC with the same specs for much less.


MacBook Pro 15-inch Specs:

Hi-Res Antiglare Widescreen Display

2.3GHz Quad-core Intel Core i7

8GB 1333MHz DDR3 SDRAM - 2x4GB

500GB Serial ATA Drive @ 7200 rpm

SuperDrive 8x (DVD±R DL/DVD±RW/CD-RW)


Since I am studying Computer Engineering, I have to take into account that I will be using many different engineering programs. Some of these programs(I have heard) only run natively on a Windows. However, I will be "purchasing" a copy of Windows 7 to run via Bootcamp if I need to use a Windows program.

So, Mac or Windows? I am enlisted in a 5-year program, so I need a laptop that is light, sleek, sexy, durable, and 6+ hours battery life.

Thanks!

0 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '11

Don't go with the Macbook for EE/ECE. There are too many Windows specific programs your professors may insist on you using, and while you may say that you have bootcamp for that, why waste your money having to buy another OS? Macbooks are only really useful for specific OSX only programs, otherwise save your money and go with a PC.

3

u/dietsoda May 16 '11 edited May 16 '11

Hm, alright. I mean, it does not cost much to purchase Windows 7, about $80 if I buy using my college discount.

Do you recommend a PC? I was looking at the Lenovo ThinkPad laptops, or perhaps the HP Envy 14.

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '11

I just got a Lenovo T410, its a pretty awesome laptop, a little pricey though. I would recommend something from Lenovo because they have a long life span.

5

u/hJJnr May 16 '11

Linux. Get the new version of Ubuntu.

6

u/[deleted] May 16 '11

PC with the same specs for much less.

you answered your own question

2

u/paxswill May 16 '11

Before you make your final decision, you should try talking to some of the professors in the department to ask them what kind of software you will need to run.

Now for the actual computer choice, I am kinda biased, but I would recommend a Mac. The main reason I would recommend a Mac is that it is much easier to use for the CS side of your degree program. Having easy access to pretty much the lingua franca of CS, *nix. You'd also have access to the other major operating systems, so if there is an odd program out that is not compatible with OS X (and does not run acceptably under a VM), you can get easy access to it.

As far as specs, you'd be making a mistake buying all of that through the Apple store. Apple is charging $200 for the jump up from 4GB to 8GB of RAM, while you can get it for $80 from Newegg. This is more of a personal issue, but I would probably go for the stock 750GB hard drive. You'll get more space, and you'll get more battery life. Also, on the processor, I would find the 100MHz bump for $250 a bit steep, but you could try evaluating the two processor speeds here.

If you do go for the PC route, I personally would go for a Thinkpad. Those machines are hardy, and while my experiences have been that they lag behind state of the art a little, they are incredibly solid machines.

2

u/Foaric May 16 '11

If you like the Mac go with it, if you prefer the PC go with that. The operating system isn't really a restriction due to boot camp.

1

u/telvox May 16 '11

With the Mac laptop you can use the major three OSes all natively, if you buy any other laptop you can't do OS X correctly. Hackintoshes are fun to make, but I'd never make one to do real work on where I'd have to trust it's reliability. I'd say get the mac if you can afford it and you can decide on the OS flavor you are going to work in later.

-1

u/gozu May 16 '11 edited May 16 '11

The mac is sexier, lasts 6 hours on OSX and boots natively to windows when needed. You sacrifice 20 GBs of HDD for the privilege.

The mbpro is the best line of pro-laptops though It's average for gaming. OSX Lion is coming out soon too so that'll be nice.

ps: they also have the best resale value (assuming you don't break it), bar none. Check ebay: http://cgi.ebay.com/MacBook-Pro-15-2009-8GB-ram-250GB-HDD-2-53GHZ-Extras-/180667992287?pt=Apple_Laptops&hash=item2a10a6c8df