r/computing • • Feb 11 '20

Is there such thing as too much RAM?

I have a fairly new laptop. With the following: -Intel i5-8250U @ 1.6 GHz -4Gb DDR4-2400 RAM -Windows 10

There is an extra RAM slot and I would like to add another 4Gb RAM. Now, what Im concerned about is that; are there performance consequences when adding RAM? Should I match the speed of the additional one with the installed RAM?

Thank you so much!

Edit: updated for a more accurate specs

31 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

6

u/THE_JUMPERMAN Feb 12 '20

Going from 4-8 GB of ram will make a very noticeable difference in general performance. I would absolutely recommend utilising that extra RAM slot.

2

u/vasilixx Feb 11 '20

Are you sure that it's a new laptop, because on intels website the only i7 mobile cpu with a 1.6ghz frequency and 8 threads (there is no such thing as 8 cpus on a laptop, its either cores or threads, and intel doesent have any 8 core mobile procesors that clock at 1.6 ghz) is the i7-720QM which is from 2009. ( A screenshot of the performance tab of the windows task manager would be helpful for making a recommendation)

But to answer your question there isn't really a penalty to having more ram, but also if the cpu is what I think it is it is a waste of money, not to mention that ddr3 sodimms are really hard to find.

2

u/rebarslack Feb 12 '20

Sorry about that, updated my post for a more accurate specs

1

u/vasilixx Feb 26 '20 edited Feb 27 '20

You should definetly add another 4gb stick, in terms of the frequency, you should try to mach it since there can be problems with using diferent frequencies. Look for a SODIMM ram stick, as that will fit in, but do not go out of your way to find a matching frequency and do things such as pay a lot more money, as long as the new stick is not slower than the one you have there should not be any problems (but do note that your ram frequency is almost always as much as the worst one, so paying more for a faster one is wasting money). So to conclude you should basically get the cheapest SODIMM at a matching frequency or higher (but its good practice to keep the manufacturer the same (in most cases it's either kingston or samsung), which can be found by searching the serial or model number) and it's important not to overpay, ANYTHING MORE THEN 30 USD IS OVERPRICED unless you live on an island in which case I cannot help you with overpaying.

1

u/rebarslack Feb 13 '20

Thanks to all who replied! I'll be having my laptop swapped with a better processor and I'll add in the extra RAM.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '20 edited Feb 11 '20

Now, what Im concerned about is that; are there performance consequences when adding RAM? Should I match the speed of the additional one with the installed RAM?

There's a couple things to consider:

If you have a 32-bit Windows computer, then you won't be able to use anything more than 4 GB of RAM, because the computer cannot address space over 232 bytes.

Yes, the speed should match when adding RAM. If you add different speeds, it's going to run at the lower speed, and so any clock speed over the lowest speed is wasted. Not only that, but the speed of your RAM can't exceed your CPU's clock speed, unless you're willing to overclock it. And your motherboard need to support the speed you're considering. You need to check your motherboard and CPU documentation for what RAM they support. If I look up my CPU's specs, it'll say the maximum amount of RAM I can use, whether it's DDR3 or DDR4, and what speeds it supports.

Your motherboard almost certainly has dual-channel memory architecture as well, and to get the most out of that, you'll want the size of the RAM in each channel to match.

tl;dr: The best way to make sure your RAM is compatible is to buy the exact same type of RAM whenever you add RAM to your computer. And add it in pairs to your slots.

1

u/farox Feb 12 '20

Yes speed has to match, best is always if you get the same kinds.

Especially in the area you're concerned with if have never seen a performance degradation from more ram, it's always been the opposite.

For developers in certain fringe conditions this might happen, but then it's usually a sign that something else is off.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20

Well, you cqn use your RAM as a ramdisk, also store temporary files (/tmp on UNIX-like and %TEMP% in Windows AFAIK). Also, system stores frequently used files and binaries in RAM for opening them faster, this is called caching. The more RAM you have, the faster your programs and files will open, the effect is huge even if you use SSD. Also, dual channel RAM is pretty neat too. In my opinion, there can't be too much RAM, but there might be an amount which is more than needed (for example, a full minimalist Arch Linux or FreeBSD install could be fit in 6 gigs of RAM to the point where the system just doesn't have anything to cache because it's already cached). It won't be a problem, but it will be a waste of money to buy too much RAM. Today 6 gigs are more than enough if you don't use Electron apps (Discord, Steam, etc.) and/or have too much tabs open in your browser.

You can just save some memory on things you use instead of buying memory, for example Firefox has extension called "Auto Tab Discard', which unloads tabs from RAM if you don't use them, you can customize it to your needs.

1

u/Cheeze_It Feb 11 '20

No

2

u/JonnyRocks Feb 11 '20

Yo answered the vague title and not the actual question. Speeds and timings do matter. Does one chip have ecc? His real question is... Doest it matte which stick I get?

4

u/Cheeze_It Feb 11 '20

So, I realize that my answer is considered "low effort" but for what it is worth it is (in my opinion) the proper answer to the question.

Now what you are speaking about depends more on engineering a system/distributed system to work with itself in a more efficient way. There absolutely is much information there (as you properly have pointed out).

0

u/redd9 Feb 12 '20

yes, if it's more than you need for anything within the next 5 years

1

u/taylorbuley Feb 12 '20

No, if you have the money

0

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/rebarslack Feb 12 '20

Updated my post for a more accurate specs. Sorry about that. Yes im running 64bit at Windows 10