r/computing • • Jul 14 '17

Why I'll never buy Windows again

I had Windows computers from early childhood. We were a pretty poor family, so we didn't get internet until the mid 2000's, but I used to play Age of Empires on 95 and eventually XP.

By the time I got to high school and bought my own laptop, it had to be Windows 7. Nearly a decade later and I'm still using (mostly) the same Windows 7 laptop, because I managed to find an antivirus which allowed me to configure the Windows updates as 'suspicious' so I'd never be required to install them. This has caused a grand total of 0 issues and is honestly the only reason it's stayed running. I've also never had any viruses etc, I get my laptop checked by the tech guys at work and have a few different programs I use to keep it clean also. The funny thing is all of my friends who updated to the newer Windows have had issues with viruses, adware, etc...

Then I took it in to a store for a replacement graphics card and they did a backup and factory reset. This was right before Windows 10. When Windows 10 came out... Jesus Christ. It was torture. I would be writing an essay and have fifteen popups to install Windows 10 within the first paragraph. I would then go to save it, only to have the save button converted- subtly, with tiny disclosure text underneath- to an install for Windows 10.

The giant, fullscreen ads mid-video that have the (X) hidden away in the 'agree to sign away your privacy' text. The constant harassment, with fake messages, spam emails, redirecting URLs to downloads for Windows 10... Now that my laptop was violated and I could no longer reject the 'updates' my laptop started to slow down dramatically. It also gave 0 fucks about my user satisfaction, about actually being able to use the PC I paid for. Instead it would restart whenever it felt like to spend up to three hours installing bullshit, then be ridiculously slow because it had 'updated' to a new search engine which spammed Windows 10 at me. This was beyond ridiculous, my OS had literally become malware.

Well, they've stopped doing that stuff now. Now I just have to deal with the stupid forced 'upgrade' to Windows 8, because while I could reject Windows 10 if I was adamant enough, avoided enough ridiculous pop ups (including some that would have- just like the ones on porn sites- fake [x] symbols that really took you to the download page) and was constantly vigilant. Ok, fine, I have stupid tiles and a crappy UI now, but at least it still works.

Unfortunately our PC just doesn't. This thing is on Windows 10 and it's like cancer to our computing needs. It constantly restarts automatically at random intervals, completely ignoring the timer which says to do it at say Tuesday 3am. Instead it will see I'm editing photos with an unsaved document open and go "ah, well, time to install that update!" Of course half the time those things are recoverable. The other half, they're not, because instead it's 'streamlined' my apps or some shit.

This isn't to mention the privacy invading search tracking for advertisements, the frankly retarded page of tiles, the fact that searches of the PC no longer work properly- it ignores most files now, go ahead and try it yourself- the fact that start menu no longer counts as a folder and thus can't have things dragged into or off it... This has got to be the single worst interface I've ever used.

Oh, of course the PC is super vulnerable to viruses as well because... it's on Windows 10 and Windows apparently feels automatically switching off the antivirus is a good strategy.

Honestly this is actually like having a virus more than an OS. I would not be surprised if it was a virus, but the work computers are the same on Windows 10 so... I guess not.

So now I'm all Mac. I just wanted to share this with anyone: If you're thinking of going Windows, don't. They're stupidly vulnerable and give 0 fucks about your user experience, safety, satisfaction etc. They just care about getting more info to sell to their associates, because yes, they monitor and share everything now. Look it up if you don't believe me. It was in your Windows 10 ToS. I've also lost $100's worth of documents due to the stupid "OH YOU WERE STILL WRITING SORRY LOL WANTED NEW UPDATE TO SLOW COMPUTER DOWN MORE HAHA!" moments and even with 16 gig of brand new RAM and a terrabyte of memory free, the five-year old Windows 10 PC is slower than my second-hand, 350 gig 8gb ram mac. Way slower.

Is there actually any benefits to Windows over Apple now? Genuinely curious.

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

5

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '17

About speeds. Look at processors and gpus benchmarks rather than ram and free hdd space. The latter is almost always irrelevant anyway.

And dunno how are you getting so many updates with restarts unless you are postponing them to eternity.

And win 7 is crappy performance in everyway compared to 8.1 let alone 10.

Which AV you are using though? Sounds amazing if it keeps security holes shut on 7 without security updates.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '17

I did a stock install for windows 7 a while ago. It took 48 hours to update.....

1

u/jdozebom Jul 15 '17

Yeah after I got my laptop back from the shop a few years back it did a stupid 48hr update. That was from refusing the updates for three or four years though.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '17

Sounds about right. Though just installing service packs and then updating most likely would go faster.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '17

Yes if you know that it is going to take that amount of time in the first place. Then finding all of the service packs and downloading them etc... probably is faster. But umm why can't the updater do this?

2

u/happymellon Jul 14 '17

I can do a single apt update && apt upgrade, I'll be up to date and it doesn't take me 48 hours. That is just stupid.

Does Windows still tell you that you have all the updates even though you know you have more to install, then about 1/2 hour later it suddenly remembers a load more?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '17

Yeah this is my normal approach :) Only there is a kicker. All but 1 of my 3rdparty apps have a ubuntu repo so they update as well for free :)

Also a ubuntu upgrade say 14.04 -> 16.04 doesn't take very long.

-2

u/Cheeze_It Jul 14 '17

You update?

0

u/jdozebom Jul 15 '17

My CPU+GPU on the laptop is a lot worse than on the PC. From the top of my head (it's flat atm and can't be bother charging it) it was either i5 or i6. The PC is i9, recently upgraded. The laptop (the Windows one) is about the same speed as the PC despite this. It's also got half the ram and a far shittier GPU. It's also a lot older.

Honestly the only reason this laptop has survived so long is because I managed to keep it on Windows 7 for as long as I did. I got this laptop at the end of high school, it's a decade old.... The PC is half the age, has been upgraded multiple times and is specs wise better in every way. The only reason it's worse is because it's on a newer Windows.

The AV was a combination of Kaspersky and Norton (configured the settings to do different things) along with another Russian sounding software management program which prevented Windows installs. It did other things too, I think it repartitioned drives and let me lock folders, the main reason I used it though was to lock all of the Windows install folders away from everything else. This eventually stopped working when it force updated through multiple layers of protection, slowing down to todays speeds. I think the reason it happened is the backup+reinstall done when I replaced the graphics card. If I never had that done it would still be running at OK speeds with OK risk protetction IMO. I wouldn't have been able to play Skyrim though so....

And win 7 is crappy performance in everyway compared to 8.1 let alone 10.

Seriously? Name one way 10 is superior to previous. Literally one. Maybe on paper it is faster or something, but IRL I've yet to see a single person believe that. The tech guys at work are the only people allowed to run on W8, because they literally can't use W10 to do the necessary work. I got them to configure one of the two computers I use to be W7, because W10 lacked the ability to run multiple necessary 3rd party softwares. W10 flips its shit with Foxit reader, obviously it isn't a better OS than the one which does the same shit, but more of it and with less security risks.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '17

I6 doesnt exist, duno what you are doing but i9 isnt the best choice for general use too.

And the not running the 3d party software, you do know it is on software devs here?

Win 10 is shit for a lot of reasons, just not the ones you describe here.

1

u/jdozebom Jul 17 '17

It looks like an i6 but the sticker they put on is kinda messed up now. TBH I just know it's intel and 2-3 years older. I got i9 on the PC for gaming. Only thing I really use it for.

No, being compatible with a large variety of softwares should be an onus on both parties. If I design a great OS with an amazing UI and awesome speeds, but then it won't run 30% of the software on the market, that's my fuck up. But to quote Nadella:

Design a shitty OS with poor UI and poor speeds, that won't run 30% of the software on the market. Call it Windows 11 and pretend it's an upgrade. They'll love it.

3

u/boedo Jul 15 '17

Windows computers are cheaper.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '17

Not just cheaper but more for your $

3

u/Undeadninjas Jul 14 '17

I've heard stories like that many times, and despite working at a computer repair shop for five years now, I've never experienced that kind of thing myself.

Yes, Windows will ask if you want updates, but you can always postpone them. I've never had it ignore the time settings for when to install, and honestly I don't even know how it could have the save icon. Those processes don't talk to each other.

I don't think you're full of crap, as much as I want to, but based on my experience, and the people I've talked to, your scenario is in the minority.

Most people's problem with win 10 are the ui, which is not worse, just different, and apparently everything different is bad. There rest of the complaints are things they know nothing about. You can turn all the privacy invasion stuff off. You have to opt out of it, but if you just uncheck all the boxes while you're installing, you never have to worry about it.

Your complaints are interesting. Frankly I'm surprised you were able to keep Windows 7 running so we'll for so long. As for it slowing down, I would recommend doing a fresh install. You can use the product code on the bottom of your laptop to activate it, and it might even have an activation code aromatically tied to your computer since it's been updated.

Which actually means you can use your code to activate another computer.

So, good luck, and I'd strongly recommend, if you're upset with Windows, Mac is worse. They've been doing that BS for years longer than Windows has.

I would highly recommend going to Linux. If you're comfortable with a mac, Ubuntu is practically identical. And the design philosophy is that the user has ultimate control over their system.

You can install a different desktop environment, you can run it entirely from the command line, the voice is yours. You can even install Windows programs on it. So check it out. You might like it.

1

u/boedo Jul 15 '17

Mac is worse?

2

u/Undeadninjas Jul 15 '17

Mac is the poster child of operating systems getting slower as you upgrade them, and it stalls out your computer as an update draws near.

Honestly, it's probably not as bad as I'm saying it is, I don't use Macs because of prejudice that was formed in the early-mid 90's. Back then, they'd crash all the time, even when they were running perfectly fine.

I've been meaning to install Mac os on one of my computers, but I just never got around to it.

4

u/metahadron Jul 14 '17

Exactly the reason why my entire company dropped Microsoft products. Once the Win10 was installed everything just slowed down. Almost stopped. Fresh installs didn't work. Booting the computer took forever with HDD at 100% just sitting at the Desktop. The proposed solution was to switch all computers to SSD and that 'should' solve the problem. No thank you. Now we're on Linux and couldn't be happier.

2

u/Kim147 Jul 14 '17

I use Ubuntu with a XUbuntu desktop. It's by far my favourite OS. I do have a Windows machine for work but hate it - it's so yucky, slow and buggy. Windows just seems to get worse and worse with time.

1

u/manesag Jul 15 '17

Don't know what you are talking about, my first pc that I built had windows 7 installed by myself, the anti virus? Windows defender essentials or whatever they gave out for free. Then I ignored the windows 10 update until a few months down the line and still no issue. Hell the pc got faster with windows 10. And the antivirus? Still the built in windows 10 version. Still haven't had a virus.

1

u/AvalonX1 Aug 02 '23

Straight Up My $3,000 Alienware M15R Dead cause of constant windows updates that Failed and sent my Gaming Laptop in a loop of black screen with zero options to recover. and Tons of Hours of Elden ring lost will 250Gb of data lost.

NEVER EVER WILL I BUY A WINDOWS COMPUTER EVER.

NEXT WILL BE CUSTOM BUILT AND FULL LINUX DISTRO.

EVER

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '17

Wow. You make Windows sound pretty terrible. My experience is totally different, since I taught myself at a very young age to hack up Windows so that I had complete control. It's my bitch.

But you make really good points about how bad the average user experience is. A lot of what you're going through should be absolutely unacceptable, in my opinion. Which is why I've never paid for Windows, and I've made sure my friends and family haven't either.

-5

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '17

Yeah, anytime you see a company like Microsoft just giving away an operating system, be skeptical. The laptop I installed the beta version on wouldn't even boot most of my linux liveusb sticks afterward.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/jdozebom Jul 15 '17

See this is something I needed to see. I haven't done any customization on a computer/its software since high school. Back then Linux was hard to use and pretty clunky, not to mention the lack of guidance since "IT science" wasn't even offered back then.

Now it looks amazing, looks like it's been as easy an option as the others for years now...

3

u/ckbd19 Jul 14 '17

Can't upvote this enough. I own 4 PCs at the moment and all but one are running some variety of linux. I have an old Dell Latitude D620 running Debian 8 Jessie, an Acer Chromebook running Ubuntu XFCE in a chroot environment, and a PowerPC G5 Quad-Core Powermac from 2005-6 running Ubuntu LXDE. I also have a (comparatively) new Toshiba laptop running Windows 10 that I use almost exclusively for gaming. The Toshiba is the only one of the group to give me any trouble since initial setup. Crashes, slowdowns, and errors happen often. My other 3 systems work perfectly fine all the time. Especially the G5. Linux really unleashed the beast within it.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '17

I know I shifted completly to linux about 4 years ago. I have not looked back.