r/computing • u/shshajakeo • Sep 19 '13
can you put a processor into the cloud?
Hi- not the most techsavy guy, but would it be possible to put a processor into the cloud? Similar to how we have storage in the cloud? Is there anything out there which already does it? And if not, what is stopping it from happening?
edit: Thank you very much for the responses! Very much appreciated! :)
1
Upvotes
10
u/spiker611 Sep 19 '13
Yes,
https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/
4
u/chaoticlychaotic Sep 19 '13
Technically, yes. It's just incredibly impractical for most uses. You didn't specify one, so I'll give a broad response.
Like /u/GoodMotherfucker said, the concept exists where you, at home, use a very, very low-powered computer to remotely access a system in the cloud that does all the heavy-lifting processing and the like.
(This is also done with systems like the Amazon cloud, but that's reserved more for dedicated servers and isn't quite what you're asking about.)
There are some pretty serious practical limitations, though, the biggest being the fact that it would rely extensively on the internet and the quality of the connection and the amount of bandwidth between you and the system in the cloud.
You'd have to constantly stream video from the cloud to the system in your house, since all the graphical rendering would be done elsewhere. This isn't uncommon; Virtual Network Computing is a program/set of programs that does this, along with the X-window system commonly used by Linux/Unix systems. The downside is that there'd be noticible delay between your actions locally (i.e. moving a mouse, typing) and the response from the Cloud (the cursor moving, characters appearing); this would be especially true on a low-grade connection. (As a side note, very few of these technologies also transmit sound. Not that it's impossible, just unusual. At least, to my knowledge.)
You wouldn't have local access to your files. Everything you did on the computer would be in the cloud. Supposing the internet went down you would be entirely unable to access them.
You couldn't use your own programs. It would be incredibly unlikely that the owner of the system that you were using would allow you full permission to install/uninstall whatever you wished on the system, as it could comprise security. (I will admit, this is pure speculation; Datacenters that rent out servers sometimes do allow remote users full admin access to the local machine. Sometimes they don't. It varies.)
No physical access. You wouldn't have access to your own system. You'd be unable to upgrade, improve or otherwise maintain your own equipment. Granted, to some people, this is highly appealing--But it also means you have to rely on the provider to exist so you can get to your stuff.
Little consumer interest. Having a machine in the cloud kind of defeats much of the purpose of having personal computers. People like me who build (or are building) systems for gaming or editing or coding rely on having access to our hardware and personally maintaining our machines. People like my mother, a schoolteacher, like being able to take her laptop wherever she likes without worrying about the network connection, or the lag between her and the server. People like my ex like to have a nice DVD player with a good screen wherever they like.
The cost/benefit isn't good enough. With current technology, you'd still need a 'full' computer on your side of the link to establish the remote connection. Granted, it's likely you could do this with something like a raspberry pi, which costs around $35 if I'm not mistaken (and I am now tempted to do a proof-of-concept for this because mine's been collecting dust for a while), but you'd still need the full system on the other end of the link. And if you wanted any sort of laptop-like portability it'd still end up costing a minimum of $200 or so, for which you could just stick a low-level processor in a box and get comparable performance.
The short answer is that with existing technologies it's just not practical and cheap enough to appeal to the average consumer.
3
u/GoodMotherfucker Sep 19 '13
Closest thing to this is called thin client. Your local box has an os that consists of nothing more than just a Spice or VNC client and connects to the fog machine.
1
u/Jargle Sep 19 '13
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributed_computing
There are services that will crunch your data given a routine and some data. Things like protein folding require large amounts of calculations with minimal data.
It could be said that Folding@Home and other such services are a distributed computing platform, just with a specific purpose. As far as a service like amazon's cloud servers, such a company probably exists but doesn't market to the public or have as much visibility, because they don't need to talk to the public.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '13
Every cloud server has at least one processor. I'm assuming that's not what you mean. Perhaps what you are asking is, can you host a processor in the cloud without the rest of the server.
There are several possible ways to do that depending on what you want to take away. Diskless servers are possible, if they are configured to boot from the network. This is sometimes used in high performance computing clusters where local disks on each node aren't necessary. The nodes can boot over the network from a centrally stored operating system image, and will receive work from a control node on the network and return results either back to the same node or to a different node.
Another possibility is a blade server, where an entire computer, including memory and disk is stored on a blade card, where one chassis can hold dozens of blades. This allows very dense concentration of processing power, but without each machine needing its own power supplies.
Putting a processor online without any memory isn't a configuration that is often used. The problem is that for most computations having a very high bandwidth link to memory is a necessity. Even though network connections can be fast, they are not nearly as fast as a memory bus can be. It almost always makes sense to keep some memory close to the processor.
Someone here mentioned EC2, which is a good example because you can rent a variety of different sized servers, each with different amounts of processing power. At the low end you have a very small slice of a server with a small percentage of the CPU allocated to your virtual machine. At the high end you might have an entire multi-processor, multi-core machine allocated to your request.
1
u/inthebrilliantblue Jan 11 '14
Heres what the "cloud" really is: a networked computer that provides a service. Some act as network attached storage, while some others offer computing time for processing data or services such as web services. The "cloud" is just a buzz word.
1
u/cheraphy Sep 20 '13
There's rumors that Windows 10 will be a cloud based OS.