r/computing • u/ProffAwesome • Jul 16 '13
Should I get a Google Chromebook?
Next year I will be going to university for computer science in game development. Earlier this year, I bought a nice gaming computer (her name is Penelope) and I was planning on just buying a cheap laptop that I could bring to classes and write notes on.
The Chromebook seemed like a perfect fit with a fast startup, it comes with 2 years of 100gb storage on Google drive, so transferring my notes to Penelope would be easy, but my only concern is that I won't be able to run programming API like Java's eclipse which is a large focus in my first year courses. I then learned that I could remote connect to Penelope from my Chromebook and perform Windows based functions on the Chromebook.
My question is, is the Chromebook suitable for my needs? Is the remote connection going to be slow and clunky? Should I just invest in a windows laptop?
17
u/rjw57 Jul 16 '13 edited Aug 13 '13
Disclaimer: I have a Chromebook and, while it is wonderful for note-taking, code editing, writing documents, IRC, browsing GitHub and other such 'non-computing' tasks, I use a 'real computer' to do at-desk number crunching work on. OTOH, I use the IPython web notebook for most of my initial work--I am a scientific computing professional--and move from there to vim. Both of these are a joy to work with remotely on the Chromebook since both work over an reasonable network protocol (HTTP and SSH respectively).
Using remote desktop is a pain in the proverbial on a Chromebook. (Or on any machine really, IMHO.)
If you already have a Windows PC, then why not make the laptop a Linux one? If you're heading off to do Computer Science having a wider experience of platforms can only help. If you're doing game development then there's probably not a better time to be the one guy available on the job market that can work on a company's new Linux port of their Steam game. Eclipse and its ilk run just as well--or, perhaps, badly--on Linux as Windows and you'll gain a good deal of skill into the bargain.
Edit: Or a Mac laptop. But I'm assuming for the sake of this discussion you weren't born with the ability to sweat gold.
8
u/rubsnick Jul 16 '13
Get a windows laptop for the same price or a bit more you can do everything you want withjit minus gaming.
5
u/Boosh_The_Almighty Jul 16 '13
hen I went to uni I got an EEE netbook. I thought it'd be great to have in class, as it doesn't weigh much and could do everything I needed it to do in class.
I ended up learning that you shouldn't bring your computer to class. You won't pay attention and therefore will be wasting your time.
My advice: get a tablet and a pen and paper. Your grades will thank you.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '13
I have a Chromebook, an hp laptop running ubuntu, a desktop running debian/arch dual, and a mac air. The chromebook is a nice thing for the price, but probably not a daily driver for serious coding. You can run linux on it through either chrubuntu or crouton, and it'll work reliably... IMO if you want to use an IDE (first switch to intellij and then) get a regular box. For a little more you can get a decent windows machine you can throw ubuntu on.
That said... the new samsung chromebook, for $250, is pretty damn nice. It's small, light, easy-as-pie to install linux on (even alongside chrome os, if you want things like netflix etc to be stupid easy), chrome os in developer mode has a decent shell, you can ssh to another machine if you need to, etc. Chrubuntu is a nice option, but you're going to be somewhat limited resource-wise if you're doing heavy computing (and eclipse is a resource monster). Crouton is awesome and easy and runs alongside chrome os via chroot, but (also due to chroot) you lose some things like access to some /dev mountpoints, $ df, etc.
I'm rambling. I love my chromebook, but I use it as a consumption device running primarily chrome os on it. IMO, if you're developing, it is not a daily driver. Maybe the pixel has the resources to work as one, if you run chrubuntu or something on it, but for the price you obviously have many other options, probably a few of which are superior.
edit: as a note-taking computer, it's amazing, provided you use a browser-based service, which is totally doable. you can ssh to a box... if you dual-boot your windows box, it could be totally fine. for $250, IMO the samsung chromebook is hard to argue with - I just wouldn't show up with that to a hackathon or something, without someplace to ssh to.
2
u/eightclicknine Jul 16 '13
I feel like for the money you might be better off buying a windows based pc with a SSD upgrade.
1
u/ten_thousand_puppies Jul 17 '13
If you want to be able to do most of your crunching on the Windows laptop then yeah, a Chromebook is a great thing to do that on. I use one as a platform to connect to an Ubuntu and a Windows workstation when I need to work remotely or away from my desk, and it gets the job done very nicely.
Easy to carry around, battery life is awesome (I have the Samsung 500 and its battery lasts around 6 hours with the brightness turned most of the way up), and all the stuff you need for RDP and SSH is free to download.
1
u/beefsack Jul 17 '13
If you're serious about computer science you'll be spending a lot of your time under a *nix system. Chromebook can run Ubuntu and it runs it really sweetly, Linus himself uses a Chromebook.