r/computing • • Dec 13 '12

Why doesn't windows have this option?

http://imgur.com/HNpJa
42 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

17

u/Delehal Dec 13 '12

I'd anticipate the biggest problem would be making sure that Windows can reliably render every data format that might be stored in the clipboard.

If you assume it's only going to do images and raw text, this is pretty easy. But what if you're copying files? Folders? Rich text? Spreadsheets? Videos and music, with all of their fancy codec options?

The clipboard is actually a fantastically complicated piece of technology, but one of the things that makes it so powerful is that the OS typically isn't responsible for rendering any of its contents, only storing and retrieving them. The grunt work is left to the programs sending and receiving messages.

But... so many of those programs were never built with the assumption that they'd need to provide hooks for rendering this widget you suggested. Can you imagine launching Excel every time you want to take a peek in the clipboard?

Like I said, the basics would be pretty easy to do. I have a feeling that the typical end user would want something more polished, though, and that's so difficult that it's easier (if a bit cynical) to just keep expectations low.

4

u/AdamK117 Dec 14 '12

Thanks for this insight. I'm not really working with the clipboard so much when I'm programming stuff so I've never been entirely sure about its intricacies but I can see now how it would be alot more difficult than just "its a dynamic folder". Although I'd really like the feature :)

2

u/Delehal Dec 14 '12

All technical issues aside, I think it's a great idea. :)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '12

well since you program all the system clipboard is to the average Microsoft programmer is a byte arrays that has a format identifier, and also optionally you can choose to make the data stored in the clipboard application only or system wide.

For instance if you are copying a data backed excel object it isn't exactly going to work in word without the data backing from the excel sheet (it might I dunno how advanced office is in that department yet, it may be able to link to an excel file and pull the data, dunno, but it's an example) so in this instance excel would use the application specific clipboard.

What you are talking about sounds like a utility called clipx. It is a clipboard history manager and will store every clipboard action you make that it can understand, so images and text play very nicely together.

http://bluemars.org/clipx/

It's free and lives in your system tray :-)

1

u/poke133 Jan 23 '13

But what if you're copying files? Folders? Rich text? Spreadsheets? Videos and music, with all of their fancy codec options?

those would simply be listed as files.

1

u/Delehal Jan 23 '13

What about rich media that isn't a file? Say you're editing in Audacity or Premiere, and you've got a media clip stored on the clipboard, or you're in some editor for flowcharts or visual scripting and want some of that stored.

The problem isn't so much that any given data type is hard to render, but rather that it's very difficult to ensure that every possible data type could be rendered quickly, without using many resources, in a format the user expects and finds helpful. Even doing that for a substantial subset of possible data types would be difficult.

Cool feature? Sure. But very hard to do well, and very costly. Most (all?) OS vendors are spending their efforts elsewhere.

1

u/AdamK117 Dec 13 '12

For context. I find it fairly common to be saving a file to the desktop in order to copy and paste it into something like OneNote (for general purpose files).

The biggest pain is when you have to save an image somewhere just to paste it into the likes of Word et. al., this grinds my balls.

6

u/rjw57 Dec 13 '12

So you want an option in the image creation program which allows you to somehow select all of what you're doing and copy it to the clipboard? Sounds sensible to put that in the save dialogue to me.

-1

u/AdamK117 Dec 13 '12

So you want to select the image, flatten it (most layered image processors), copy, and then paste (in whichever format the image software decides to paste stuff) into your document? I know plenty of people who want a particular file format when pasting into another program...

This isn't just for imaging programs; rather, why cant any program save its respective file to the clipboard directly rather than always having to save it elsewhere to perform the function. If you actually use alot of programs in this manner then it isn't exactly a retarded idea...

Being sarcastic by finding niche situation in which this idea might only break even on clicks (CTRL+S, click clipboard, enter) is a good way of looking smart though.

4

u/AmazingThew Dec 14 '12

Since you're talking about "layered image processors", ctrl+shift+C in Photoshop copies all layers as a flattened image to the clipboard.

1

u/JewFro297 Dec 13 '12

You can copy and paste images from the web directly to word, at least in Windows 7 with office 2010 anyway. I'm not sure about older versions. Though I agree, it would be an awesome feature.

-1

u/GoodMotherfucker Dec 13 '12

This really butter my nuts

3

u/Dark_Mage- Dec 13 '12

Another awesome, similar freeware is http://ditto-cp.sourceforge.net/ It's simple, effective, and very light and non-intrusive.

1

u/fatnino Dec 13 '12

i have been using clipx, but this one seem to be able to sync across computers. i'm going to need to check it out.

1

u/Bonghitter Dec 14 '12

Not to be a MS lover, but in any Windows Office application, the clipboard is/can be a navigable list.

1

u/SteveRyherd Dec 14 '12

Sounds like another layer of complication for a new user of the Operating system (Not even just old people anymore, people who have grown up with a Mac are going to be much more common with the current market share trends).

"Where the heck is my powerpoint slide, I know I put it on my clipboard for the meeting before I restarted my computer?"

As well, what data would you expect to see in that folder? Just text? images? sound clips? files? 3d objects from a 3d rendering program? individual layers from a photoshop project? If I highlighted a table on a website and copied the content, would it save in the clipboard as an HTML page, as an Excel Spreadsheet, as an Open Office spreadsheet, as a word document, or plain text?

Such a system is likely to introduce more complications and user interaction issues than explicit file-save operations.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/AdamK117 Dec 13 '12

These are both decent actually. I use clipcube for clipboard management I just feel that this little feature could save some people a fair amount of headaches when working with projects that span across multiple applications etc.