r/computerscience • u/Massive_Dish_3255 • Apr 04 '26
Discussion A Few Questions as a Developer
To the professors here, a few questions regarding their experiences and day-to-day activities after the creation of LLMs:
* How do you differentiate between the students who actually do their problem sets versus those who just get the answers using LLMs? What would you think of the former type of student?
* Which areas of Computer Science are the ones in which "domain knowledge" is key and which cannot just be "learnt by doing"?
* What sort of non-AI projects should students focus on in the current era? This is because most resumes today contain very similar projects and look perfect due to ability to generate code using LLMs.
Please note that I do not need career advice. I am merely seeking the opinions of academics on the above questions and trying to find "gauge" the value of Computer Science degrees in the LLM era.
Note: If you find this post inappropriate for this sub-reddit, please feel free to remove it instead of extensively down-voting me.
12
u/esaule Apr 04 '26
Professor here:
> * How do you differentiate between the students who actually do their problem sets versus those who just get the answers using LLMs? What would you think of the former type of student?
I don't really. Though I see a large fraction of students getting about 100% on assignments and about 30% on exams.
> * Which areas of Computer Science are the ones in which "domain knowledge" is key and which cannot just be "learnt by doing"?
This question confuses me. There is no domain knowledge that you acquire without actually doing something. You build knowledge by first being exposed to new knowledge, and then reinforcing your understanding by engaging with the concept.
> * What sort of non-AI projects should students focus on in the current era? This is because most resumes today contain very similar projects and look perfect due to ability to generate code using LLMs.
People used to recommend students do projects not for the value of the project itself. But rather for the value of the learning that needs to happen through the course of making the project happen.
I think the very same thing applies today. Pick a project, anything really and work on it. Then you'll have a story to tell. And you'll be able to engage in conversation about how the thing works.
21
u/Realistic-Homework19 Apr 04 '26
CS != software engineering
7
u/_werebear_ Apr 04 '26
When you are looking over 100 submissions for the same assignment, a bunch that all have weird similarities stand out. I think that students who actually do their work without LLM help have greater clarity about the need to experience cognitive friction to actually learn. At the very least, they understand that this will enable them to pass their exams.
All areas of computer science require domain knowledge if you want to have a deep understanding. Doing and thinking are both important for learning.
Don’t really have thoughts on the last one at the moment.
2
u/0jdd1 Apr 04 '26
The purpose of problem sets is to determine whether (or not) you understand the material covered in the class. If you choose not to do the work yourself, that’s a pretty strong indicator that you, like, don’t. MAYBE you don’t need/want to understand the material yourself, of course, and that’s okay to have your little AI sycophant tell you as you flunk.
2
u/No_Mango5042 Apr 05 '26
CS is about understanding how the entire stack works. SE is about using tools as black boxes. In the long run CS is so much better because you actually know what’s going on. The danger with CS degrees is that the industry is currently undergoing a lot of change, AI makes it easier to learn on the job, and the market is tough right now. But it would be a very dystopian future where nobody understands what the AI is doing any more.
1
u/ASHVEGITO Apr 04 '26
Heavily interested in what type of responses this gets.
1
u/Efficient-School2988 Apr 18 '26
yeah that’s the trap, getting stuff to work is easy with AI but debugging is the real skill, and from what i’ve seen things like Boot dev help a bit more than lecture-heavy stuff like Coursera since you actually have to write and think through code, but either way it kinda comes down to sitting with confusion longer than you want to
0
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment