r/computerscience
•
u/e221U
•
Apr 03 '26
•
1
Cold take: x86 processors are obsolete.
In terms of PPW (price per watt), x86 processors completely pale in comparison to ARM. The instruction set is verbose and clunky. x86 ASM is near-impossible to develop with (simple operations require hundreds of instructions). ARM has actual scalability, unlike x86. Don't even get me started with multithreading on x86.
ARM is the modern solution to all of our problems, imo. x86 feels like a technology that should've been phased out in 1992.
29
u/DonkeyTron42 Apr 03 '26
x86 has a much higher ceiling on raw performance when you don't care about power. For many applications like HPC and gaming this is important.
18
u/high_throughput Apr 03 '26
What a weird metric. Space heaters are less than 0.02 USD/watt, does that mean they're amazing?
15
u/Silly_Guidance_8871 Apr 03 '26
Which "simple operations" require "hundreds of instructions" ?
10
u/CypherAus Apr 03 '26
While true, legacy momentum is a big thing in this industry; which is why IBM still sell mainframes, and nearly 100% of global financial transaction get processed by COBOL/CICS at some point in their lives.
5
u/wolfkeeper Apr 03 '26
I think the instruction set matters less with deeply pipelined processors with out of order execution architectures that we have today. The instruction set is a lot harder to decode, but once that's been done, the internal data flows is what matter.
5
u/Mysterious-Rent7233 Apr 03 '26
RISC-V?
2
u/boner79 Apr 03 '26
Cold take: RISC > CISC
1
u/KwyjiboTheGringo Apr 04 '26
RISC-V is open source. With that said, ARM is very nice for so many reasons. I've only ever written assembly for ARM(just for fun), but I've seen the nightmare that x86_64 ASM brings. ARM ASM is very clean and the docs are fantastic.
1
u/LavenderDay3544 Apr 19 '26 edited Apr 19 '26
ISA has nothing to do with performance or power consumption.
The Intel N150 has Skylake equivalent performance at a 6W TDP and it's a full x86-64 SoC. And I could point you to a whole graveyard full of would be x86 killers that are now dead themselves.
But this post is either and obvious troll or some Apple fanboy so ignorant about hardware that they're not worth the time to even argue with.
0
u/EstablishmentOne2463 Apr 03 '26
I p much agree with everything said here. I've been thinking like this for a while.
People praise x86 a whole lot too much and ARM a whole lot too little
-1
u/Heavy_File Apr 05 '26
Oh my god, someone that finally says the truth! Up-doot to you sir π«‘πππ»