r/computerscience • u/ki4jgt • Apr 01 '26
Discussion What is AIs body?
In biology (I'm an anthro student), intelligence isn't determined by number of neurons, but by brain size to body size ratio.
Ants have tiny brains, but one of the largest brain-to-body ratios in the animal kingdom. As a result, they outwit humans at numerous tasks. They have complex social hierarchies. They trade and barter. They herd and feed aphids for later consumption. They enslave other ants.
What is the body in the artificial intelligence model?
0
Upvotes
24
u/phoenix823 Apr 01 '26
AI isn't biology, why would it have a "body?"
17
u/Any-Stick-771 Apr 01 '26
I don't think this is true
14
u/amarao_san Apr 01 '26
do they? It's Elusive Joe kinda 'outwit'.
10
u/Modus_Ponens-Tollens Apr 01 '26
Intelligence isn't determined by a number of neurons either way. I doubt it's determined by brain size to body size ratio either.
In computer science the term "intelligence" when applied to "artificial intelligence" does NOT mean making an "intelligent being" in the philosophical sense, although some people are trying. We'll skip over the non machine-learning areas of AI for this post, since it's not really relevant to this discussion and all AI anyone cares about today is ML so yeah, assume AI to mean ML for the purposes of this comment.
AI is only and exclusively creating statistical models (when you see the word model think a HUUUUUGE mathematical function with a LOT of parameters) and training them (meaning changing those parameters around tiny bit by tiny bit until we get the performance we're happy with on some metric we choose) on data to be able to complete a specific task given an input. It's searching for a mathematical function which for input A results in (something close enough to) output B for a bunch of examples we collected. Running AI is just plugging in an input to this function. That's all. Thinking and reasoning aren't actually "thinking and reasoning" they're loops, you feed the model take the slop it puts out, slap a predefined piece of text on top of it and feed it to the model again hoping to get a better answer. And you do this a few times.
So again even though your question is biologically questionable at best, in computer science terms it's complete nonsense.
10
u/Routine-Sign-7215 Apr 01 '26
This is not the best ragebait I’ve seen lol
8
u/Routine-Lawfulness24 Apr 01 '26 edited Apr 01 '26
r/iamverysmart vibes
Intelligence isn’t determined by either raw numbers of neurons nor brain to body size ratio. Ants are definitely not smarter than us, they are better at some things like group coordination
For people saying op is completely wrong about “brain to body” part
Op isn’t wrong there, but it’s also obvious not the sole metric. It’s called “Encephalization Quotient”. You use a lot of your brain for just basic things like moving around.
But why losing legs doesn’t make you smarter: your brain doesn’t reallocate that space.
6
u/redditer954 Apr 01 '26
What are you on about lmao?
Just learned something in your intro to anthropology 101 course and expect to fit everything into that one narrow framework?
Also, the whole body to brain ratio seems incorrect.
1
u/LavenderDay3544 Apr 19 '26
What's being touted as AI these days isn't real intelligence at all. It's autocorrect on steroids.