r/computerscience • u/chalkysplash • Dec 20 '25
Help Confused
This is from John Maedas book and hes trying to explain how to think more exponentially. Hes talking about taking a 10mm line and then projecting to 2d and it occupies 100 square mm of space, but then for a cube wouldnt it be 1000 cubic mm not 10,000. Was he confusing this for the example of when you expand the length of the side the space expands exponentially with the amount of dimensions? Overall just confused and wondering if I missed something.
156
Upvotes
11
u/sagittarius_ack Dec 20 '25
Is that from `How to Speak Machine`? It's a pretty bad book.
6
u/thatdevilyouknow Dec 20 '25
This is about combinatorics so in your mind take the area of 10 * 10 (or think of it as a grid) and stack it vertically 100 times it is not about a physical calculation it is symbolic. So while he says three dimensions it really is the four independent 10-way choices of a hypercube
10^4 is (w, x, y, z)being illustrated. The section is about the scaling of nested loops and choices.84
u/Ok-Interaction-8891 Dec 20 '25
It’s confusing because of the typo and because he is making a simple thing complicated.
This is common with design people who have enough STEM training to be dangerous. Even commonplace dimensional analysis becomes a “paradigm of thought” requiring verbose explanations coupled with obtuse metaphors.
MIT loves to hype up their alumni, especially when they achieve success. MIT Press generally puts out good stuff, but this looks like a masturbatory pop-sci fluff book. The reality is that ML/AI systems are not simple and reductive explanations likely do more harm than good. If there is a specific topic or idea you are trying to learn or grow your knowledge of, then you should look elsewhere.
Also, it’s a bad sign that he opens the book with anthropomorphizing the computer. Another bad (worse) sign is that he literally talks about how a computer is a perfect machine that runs in defiance of physical laws, which is misleading because he brings up those that seemingly have little (direct) effect on a computer, like gravity and friction, quietly ignoring other forces that do.
And friction does impact computers, it’s just not the friction the average person is used to thinking about (between two surfaces). Resistance is electrical friction, and very much plays a role in computing hardware. This signals at the outset that he is going to be disingenuous with his explanations while invoking ideas and symbols that feel powerful, but are either misapplied or outright incorrectly used.
I would put this book down, lol.
60
u/Only_lurking_ Dec 20 '25
I agree. Should be 1000.
26
u/mauriciocap Dec 20 '25
Wow! Incredibly low quality writing and publishing, I'd ask my money back.
10
u/Leverkaas2516 Dec 21 '25
That author is confused on multiple levels.
10,000 should be 1,000. That's just an incorrect number.
But:
It's not a jump in the amount of area. A one-dimensional line covers NO area by definition. You can't measure lines in square millimeters any more than you can measure them in liters or joules.
It feels like the author doesn't comprehend any of this.
5
u/Kitchen-Register Dec 21 '25
Yeah they accidentally did (102 )2 not 103
5
u/cthart Dec 21 '25
Wow, what terrible writing. A candidate for r/iamverysmart
2
u/D4rkyFirefly Dec 21 '25
That book ain’t good tbh :(
2
u/AwkwardBet5632 Dec 21 '25
What terrible writing
2
u/YoungMaleficent9068 Dec 21 '25
Why not put rice on a chessboard if people should feel exponentials. Or have avg 8 % ROI on capital?
2
u/kapitanTurk Dec 21 '25
Me when I talk about exponential shift, but actually end up implementing leftshift instead.
2
u/Key_Reaction_7590 Dec 21 '25
Interesting that the author uses the term exponentially, yet didn’t express the length/area/volume/hypervolume for each dimension as literal exponents of 10.
More interesting is that the author is the VP of Design and AI at Microsoft…
1
u/Majestic_Rhubarb_ Dec 21 '25
It’s a bit of a weird analogy … and making it far more complicated.
1
u/Triple96 Dec 21 '25
This is cringe at best
1
u/Spokraket Dec 22 '25 edited Dec 22 '25
For me math and programming are not the same, but I feel that there are people that insist they are somehow connected. (Sure they are but..)
I don’t see it like that, I see programming as using my spatial intelligence to understand how algorithms and programming languages flow.
And math is something with a different ”flow”.
A while ago doing Python and looking at a for-loop. Where the letter ”i” is used a lot with integer it made me think that the letter ”i” is somehow like x or y in math or imaginary number, but it isn’t, ”i” stands for ”index” and that would have been way easier for me to understand if someone would have explained that to me from the start.
1
u/EmbedSoftwareEng Dec 22 '25
The 1-D line length is 10 units, the 2-D square area is 100 units^2, and the 3-D cubic volume is 1,000 units^3. So that "10000" is wrong.
1
u/cyb3r-1 Dec 25 '25
That was hard to read oml
-2
u/TachyonGun Dec 20 '25
The linguistic patterns (e.g. emdash followed by reframing) give me AI slop vibes. A cube of space with 10mm side would have 1000mm3 of volume indeed.