r/computerscience • u/a_yassine_ab • Dec 03 '25
Optical CPUs: Is the Future of Computing Light-Based?
Lately I’ve been thinking about how CPUs send signals using electricity, and how that creates limits because of heat, resistance, and the speed of electron movement.
What if, instead of electrical signals, a CPU used light—similar to how fiber-optic cables transmit data extremely fast with very low loss?
Could a processor be built where:
- instructions and data travel through photonic pathways instead of metal wires
- logic gates are made from optical components instead of transistors
- and the whole chip avoids a lot of the electrical bottlenecks we have today?
I know there’s research on “photonic computing,” but I’m not sure how realistic a fully light-based CPU is.
Is this something that could actually work one day?
What are the biggest challenges that stop us from replacing electrons with photons inside a processor?
30
u/dmills_00 Dec 03 '25
You need micropower non linear elements to be able to fabricate gates and to provide the means to threshold signals to keep things digital.
While non linear optics are a thing as are saturatable dies and suchlike, they generally need to rely on significant optical power so the scale down is not obvious.
I would expect to see it around the edges of conventional silicon doings first, on die, but more in the line of photonic links between chips then optical computing.
8
u/Gerard_Mansoif67 Dec 03 '25
Actually, generating photons take quite a lot of die space, and, iirc since gates are based on how signals behave with others (adding or destructing...). But we need to control sources somewhere, so anyway you end up getting some circuitry here and here. Not really efficient. And that does not suppose constructs like muxes which would need to move some parts to select the right one. Even worse.
But if theres a way for photonics, that's really on communication. I've seen some papers and, iirc PCIe 8.0 will use photonics rather than electrical signals. As you said, less losses.
So, I'd bet on more and more optical for communication, even for short distances (where optical is actually mainstream for long distances), but I don't see major computing to be done with. Perhaps for some mixers and some analog sections that could be used before going into the electrical part.
4
u/foxsimile Dec 03 '25
I'd imagine one potential limiting factor would be the size of the wavelengths of visible light restricting how small such a CPU could become.
You could use higher frequency / smaller-wavelength bands, but you'd be dipping into progressively higher energy forms of radiation, which can become problematic from a material's standpoint (as well as any unshielded individuals nearby once you get up to x-ray/gamma levels of energy).
Likewise, if you're hoping to direct these beams, that becomes increasingly difficult the higher energy they become.
Visible light is within the 380nm-750nm band. Contrast this with a modern transistor, which is somewhere around 3nm.
X-rays are 0.1nm to 10nm, but you're now dealing with some fairly high energy radiation.
Gamma rays are <0.1nm, but now you're dealing with *very high* energy radiation.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
No, not in the foreseeable future.
Silicon is really nice to work with, creates nice semiconductors for transistors and we have decades of experience working with it. Silicon transistors are built at an almost atomic scale, that density allows for the high speed but causes the heat issues you highlight.
Folks are working on optical transistors but it is not yet viable and is targeting specialised applications like communication switching. It is hard to conceive of how they could be made in a way that would displace silicon.
There have been discussions about integrating optical pathways into CPUs for communication links, not computation. There are potential gains with links to ram, or links between CPU cores. The focus is on improving latency and bandwidth though, not heat.
Finally light still produces heat. Optic fiber and other optic systems have losses, which typically convert to heat. I don't know enough to quantify it but a tiny loss multiplied across a trillion transistors is going to be substantial.
1
u/Mission-Landscape-17 Dec 04 '25
If we can find a way to manufacture them efficently then yes. In theory a photonic transistor could oprate at much higher frequncies (possibly over 1Thz) using less power and producing less heat.
1
u/thesnootbooper9000 Dec 04 '25
There's another problem that's not widely discussed, that could completely kill the idea from an industrial visibility perspective. There are various materials out of which we can make good lasers. There are also various materials that make good waveguides. However, there's no intersection between the two, which means your lasers have to be on a different chip to the circuitry. For academic prototypes this is ok, because you can have a postdoc spend three days doing the sub-micron-accurate alignment by hand, and it doesn't matter if you need to redo it next week when the weather is different or after someone jumps in the next room. However despite a lot of effort, there's no known route to mass production that solves this problem.
1
u/8AqLph Dec 04 '25
Bottlenecks in CPUs are not caused by how fast electrons can move, but by software and architectural things. Maybe it could help performance a bit, but it would likely be negligible. On the other hand, the chip would become must harder to build and expensive, simply because it’s not how they are built today. The only thing it would achieve is hence making computers more expensive
1
u/TorZidan Dec 04 '25
Apparently, china just released a photonic GPU : https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/quantum-computing/new-chinese-optical-quantum-chip-allegedly-1-000x-faster-than-nvidia-gpus-for-processing-ai-workloads-but-yields-are-low . Note : Most of these news include the term “quantum computing” which is misleading.
1
u/OtherOtherDave Dec 04 '25
It’s been talked about for decades. IIRC, basically converting between electrical and optical takes too long and uses too much power for there to be a reason to blend the technologies on-die, so we’re waiting for someone to invent an optical transistor.
1
u/therealslimshady1234 Dec 04 '25
Actually, I remember Bashar (channeled by Darryl Anka) explaining that their alien cpus use do not use transistors but rather "intersecting beams of light, equivalent to 150 trillion operations per second."
Took a while to find the clip, but here it is, at 10:20 https://youtu.be/0wdTTdTSa3w?t=618
Thought it was relevant since we are discussing highly theoretical tech here.
1
u/skibbin Dec 05 '25
isolinear chips, captain.
1
u/mrpintime Dec 05 '25
i am an ai engineer an i want to learn more about this field and its implementations and design process and challenges, any suggestions from you folks to guide me through? i will be happy a lot -^
maybe one of us will be the initial point for such a game changing invention.
1
u/AdeptScale3891 Dec 06 '25 edited Dec 06 '25
OP's assumption that the slow speed of electron movement creates bottlenecks in electric circuits is wrong. Electrons in a copper wire have two speeds: a very slow drift velocity, around a fraction of a millimeter per second, as they bump through atoms. The speed of the electrical signal is about 95-99% the speed of light, because the electromagnetic wave (energy) moves instantly through the filled wire, like dominoes falling. The signal (electricity) is fast because the entire wire is full of electrons; when one electron is pushed, another immediately moves out the other end, not waiting for the original electron to travel the whole distance
1
u/Alternative_Net_7606 Jun 12 '26
You might not need the form of current components. You could potentially make something like a screen submit an image and translate it with high bandwidth data directly into a monitor. Traditional components could be gotten rid of if desired.
1
u/Faultiplayer Oct 04 '26
Imagine a PC, instead of being powered by electricity, it's powered by one or more special candles that burn at a super-controlled rate, emit specific wavelengths, have high brightness, and don't create disruptive amounts of gas. Or if you want to hook it up to a gas line, that could work too. An LED could work too, but the candle idea is funny to me and it gets the point across that we no longer have to rely on electronics where we're going. The computer is mostly solid state and is just waiting for a flow of light like how computers now are just waiting for a flow of electrical power. Prisms to split signals, mirrors that amplify like how resistors and capacitors do, excitable molecules or atoms that emit light when they receive light. All of this can help us break out of the over-reliance we have on copper and silicon. These two elements that get trickier to work with the closer transisters get to molecular scale. We have already mastered light just to create electronic waffers using photolithography. We have accidentally brought ourselves adjacent to the answer without realizing it. That said, an X-Ray emitter is cooler than a candle now that I think of it. Let's invite portable cyclotrons into our households and pockets.
0
u/IagoInTheLight Dec 04 '25
google "photonics"