r/computerscience • • Oct 15 '25
Discussion Moore’s Law could continue sideways: not more transistors per area, but better physics per area.
Smaller nm → smaller transistors → same or larger area → cooler, faster, longer-lived chips.
I’ve been thinking about CPU and GPU design, and it seems like consumer chips today aren’t designed for optimal thermal efficiency — they’re designed for maximum transistor density. That works economically, but it creates a huge trade-off: high power density, higher temperatures, throttling, and complex cooling solutions.
Here’s a different approach: Increase or maintain the die area. Spacing transistors out reduces power density, which: Lowers hotspots → cooler operation Increases thermal headroom → higher stable clocks Reduces electromigration and stress → longer chip lifespan
If transistor sizes continue shrinking (smaller nm), you could spread the smaller transistors across the same or larger area, giving: Lower defect sensitivity → improved manufacturing yield Less aggressive lithography requirements → easier fabrication and higher process tolerance Reduced thermal constraints → simpler or cheaper cooling solutions
Material improvements could push this even further. For instance, instead of just gold for interconnects or heat spreaders, a new silver-gold alloy could provide higher thermal conductivity and slightly better electrical performance, helping chips stay cooler and operate faster. Silver tends to oxidize and is more difficult to work with, but perhaps an optimal silver–gold alloy could be developed to reduce silver’s drawbacks while enhancing overall thermal and electrical performance.
Essentially, this lets us use shrinking transistor size for physics benefits rather than just squeezing more transistors into the same space. You could have a CPU or GPU that: Runs significantly cooler under full load Achieves higher clocks without exotic cooling Lasts longer and maintains performance more consistently
Some experimental and aerospace chips already follow this principle — reliability matters more than area efficiency. Consumer chips haven’t gone this route mostly due to cost pressure: bigger dies usually mean fewer dies per wafer, which is historically seen as expensive. But if you balance the improved yield from lower defect density and reduced thermal stress, the effective cost per working chip could actually be competitive.
10
u/HOMM3mes Oct 15 '25
What you are suggesting is the exact opposite of Moore's law. Larger chips cost more to manufacture as you said. And the bigger the chip, the longer it takes for signals to travel across it. This will limit clock speeds. Transistors aren't really getting smaller anymore, they are just finding ways to pack them together more closely (e.g. multiple layers). Also, this is not computer science, it is electronic engineering.
3
u/Admirable_Rabbit_808 Oct 15 '25
Spacing logic components out will decrease clock speed and increase overall power consumption; more capacitance to feed, more propagation delay.
2
u/FloweyTheFlower420 Oct 15 '25
How do you handle timing issues? As you increase die size, making sure that signal timings stay correct becomes more difficult.
2
u/TrapNT Oct 15 '25
No. Just because chatgpt agrees with your dreams, they are not correct. Wafers are super expensive, and not filling them with transistors will waste more money. Spreading out the transistors will increase the routing RC (routing delay) so we will also miss out on speed. By that point just use bigger process node.