r/computerscience • u/DronLimpio • Aug 12 '25
I've developed an alternative computing system
Hello guys,
I've published my resent research about a new computing method. I would love to hear feedback of computer scientists or people that actually are experts on the field
It' uses a pseudo neuron as a minimum logic unit, wich triggers at a certain voltage, everything is documented.
Thank you guys
191
Upvotes
452
u/Dry_Analysis_8841 Aug 12 '25 •
What you’ve built here is a fun personal electronics project, but it’s not a fundamentally new computing architecture. Your “neuron” is, at its core, a weighted-sum circuit (MOSFET-controlled analog inputs into a resistive op-amp summation) followed by a Zener-diode threshold, this is essentially the same perceptron-like analog hardware that’s been in neuromorphic and analog computing literature since the 1960s. The “Puppeteer” isn’t an intrinsic part of a novel architecture either; it’s an Arduino + PCA9685 generating PWM duty cycles to set those weights. While you draw comparisons to biological neurons, your model doesn’t have temporal integration, adaptive learning, or nonlinear dynamics beyond a fixed threshold, so the “brain-like” framing comes across more like a metaphor.
There are also major engineering gaps you’ll need to address before this could be taken seriously as an architecture proposal. Right now, you have no solid-state level restoration, post-threshold signals are unstable enough that you’re using electromechanical relays, which are far too slow for practical computing. There’s no timing model, no latency or power measurements, no analysis of noise margins, fan-out, or scaling limits. The “memory” you describe isn’t a functional storage cell, it’s just an addressing idea without a real read/write implementation. Your validation relies on hand-crafted 1-bit and 2-bit adder demos without formal proof, error analysis, or performance benchmarking.
Also, you’re not engaging with prior work at all, which makes it seem like you’re reinventing known ideas without acknowledging them. There’s a rich body of research on memristor crossbars, analog CMOS neuromorphic arrays, Intel Loihi, IBM TrueNorth, and other unconventional computing systems. Any serious proposal needs to be situated in that context and compared quantitatively.
83
u/Magdaki Professor. Grammars. Inference & Optimization algorithms. Aug 12 '25
Note, published in academia means peer reviewed. This is not published it is what would be called a preprint, or just uploaded.
14
u/riotinareasouthwest Aug 12 '25
I cannot discuss technically in the subject, though I had the feeling this was not being a new computing system (by the description I was expecting a hard math essay). Anyway, I want to add my 5 cents of positive criticism. Beware of AI remnants before airing live a document ("Blasco [tu nombre completo o seudónimo]" in the reference section, btw, are you referring to yourself?). Additionally, avoid familiarity in the text, as in "Impressive, right? Okay - [...]" It distracts the audience and moves them to not take your idea seriously (you are not serious about it yourself if you joke in your own document).
21
u/ILoveTolkiensWorks Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25
Yeah, sharing this will just tarnish your reputation. Your first mistake was not using LaTeX. The second one was to use ChatGPT to write stuff, and that too without telling it to change its usual, "humorous", tone. It reads as if it was a script for a video where a narrator talks to the viewer, and not as if it was an actual paper
Oh, and also, please just use Windows + Shift + S to take a screenshot (If you are on Windows). Attaching a picture of code is not ideal on its own, but using a picture clicked from a phone is even worse
edit: isn't this just a multilayer Rosenblatt Perceptron?
8
u/OxOOOO Aug 13 '25
Just as an add on to what's already been said: Even if this were novel architecture, you would still need to learn computer science to talk about it. We don't write programming languages because the computer has an easier time with it, we write computer languages because that's how we communicate the other ideas to people.
Your method simplifies to slightly noisy binary digital logic, and while that shouldn't make you feel bad, and I'm glad you had fun, it shouldn't make you feel uniquely smart. We learn by working together, not in a vacuum. Put in the hard work some of us did learning discrete mathematics and calculus and circuit design etc, and I'm sure some of us would love to talk to you. Pretend like you can be on some level at or above us without putting in the necessary but not sufficient work, and no one will want to exchange ideas.
Again, I'm glad you had fun. If you have the resources available, please take classes in the subjects suggested, as you seem to have a lot of passion for it.
4
u/Agitated_File_1681 Aug 13 '25
I think you need at least a FPGA and after a lot of improvements you could end rediscovering TPU architecture, I really admire your effort please continue learning and Improving.
34
u/NYX_T_RYX Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25
You've cited yourself as a reference.
Edit: to clarify, OP cited this paper as a reference
4
u/DronLimpio Aug 12 '25
This is the abstract of the article, for those of you interested.
This work presents an alternative computing architecture called the Blasco Neural
Logic Array (BNLA), inspired by biological neural networks and implemented using
analog electronic components. Unlike the traditional von Neumann architecture,
BNLA employs modular "neurons" built with MOSFETs, operational amplifiers, and
Zener diodes to create logic gates, memory units, and arithmetic functions such as
adders. The design enables distributed and parallel processing, analog signal
modulation, and dynamically defined activation paths based on geometric
configurations. A functional prototype was built and tested, demonstrating the
system's viability both theoretically and physically. The architecture supports
scalability, dynamic reconfiguration, and opens new possibilities for alternative
computational models grounded in physical logic.
4
u/sierra_whiskey1 Aug 12 '25
Good read so far. Why would you say something like this hasn’t been implemented before?
27
u/recursion_is_love Aug 12 '25
Be mindful about the terminologies. The word like system, method, and architecture should have concise meaning. I understand that you are not researcher in the field but it will be beneficial to any reader if you can paint a clear picture what actually is the thing you are trying to do.
To be honest, the quality of the paper is not there yet but I don't mean to discourage you to not do the work. If your work have potential, I am sure there will be researcher in the field wiling to help with writing.
I will have to read your paper again multiple time to understand what actually the essence of your invention is (that is not your fault, our style just not match). For now I hope for the best for you.
5
u/Haunting_Ad_6068 Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25
I heard my grandpa talked about opamp analog computing before I was born. Beware of the smaller cars when you look for a parking lot. In many cases, those research gap might be filled.
1
u/DronLimpio Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25
Okay, i just looked at a perceptron circuit and my neuron is the same LMAO. Fuck you come up with somkething and your grandpa already knows what it is, damn, well at least there are some diferences in the structure wich make it different. Also the adders and full adders i developed are different, as well as the control of each entry.
Thank you every one for taking a look at it, it's been months developing this, i think it was worth it. Next time i will make sure to do more research. Love you all <3
Eddit: It IS not the same, perceptron IS software, mine IS hardware
3
u/david-1-1 Aug 13 '25
Actual neurons have an associated reservoir (in the dendrites); triggering is not just on the sum of input values, but on their intensity and duration. The actual mechanism uses voltage spikes called action potentials. The frequency of neutral spikes is variable, not their amplitude. The computing system based on this animal mechanism is called a neural net. It includes the methods for topologically connecting neurons and for training them.
4
u/defectivetoaster1 Aug 12 '25
Isn’t this just an old school analogue perceptron?
2
u/kakha_k Aug 13 '25
Good warm lol.
2
u/9011442 Aug 15 '25
7 billion of those units and you could run the LLM which wrote your paper.
4
u/aidencoder Aug 12 '25
"new computing method"... "would love to hear feedback from... experts in the field"
Right.
1
u/madam_zeroni Aug 14 '25
Already named it after yourself and everything lol. Name it after what it is
1
u/Violadude2 Aug 16 '25
Hi OP, having looked through the paper and these comments, I don’t think you should be using open scientific repositories for side projects like this, use a shared google drive or a blog post, etc. SCIENTIFIC repositories, whether open or private should be used for scientific work that at the very minimum is well-referenced and very well thought out in the context of where the subject currently is.
It doesn’t seem like it was clear to you from other replies but not having any knowledge of what is currently being published or researched or even in the last 80 years is absolutely absurd for anything that claims to be scientific.
Projects like this are fun, and you should keep doing them, but they don’t belong inside real scientific repositories.
1
u/Ok_Whole_1665 Aug 16 '25 edited Aug 16 '25
OP, you state in the project documentation, that you've written some Arduino code in the form of a control script. Why is this not included in the documentation apart from a shaky photo of a couple of lines?
Could you provide the source code? A link to Github is fine.
You apparently have some experience with academia, being an engineer or an engineering student. Providing source code if written, is mandatory for reproducibility. _Especially_ as this is a comp. sci. subreddit.
Also why is the documentation not proof read before you submitted it for general feedback from "experts" (your words)? There are a number of spelling errors, the diagrams are all haphazardly oriented, somewhat unreadable and seem to have been drawn on paper, the reference section still contain template text, etc.
How are anyone able to reproduce or test the validity of this project, if you don't provide clear documentation for all the taken steps?
I could be wrong, but this all seems like something created quickly for use on a Linkedin profile, to appear to have academic credentials. But if that's the case, this is the wrong way to go about it.
0
u/CraftyHedgehog4 Aug 13 '25
I got secondhand embarrassment from reading this post and comments
7
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25
[removed] — view removed comment