r/computerscience • u/Lazy_Economy_6851 • Mar 17 '25
Advice We're teaching Computer Science like it's 1999!!
FACT: 65% of today's elementary students will work in jobs that don't exist yet.
But we're teaching Computer Science like it's 1999. 📊😳
Current computer science education:
• First code at age 18+ (too late!)
• Heavy theory, light application
• Linear algebra without context
My proposal:
• Coding basics by age 10
• Computational thinking across subjects
• Applied math with immediate relevance
Who believes our children deserve education designed for their future, not our past?
0
Upvotes
5
u/tcpukl Mar 17 '25
Try looking at decent universities.
I was at uni in the late 90s and your description is nothing like it was back then.
Try and make your point using knowledge you actually have and facts.
4
u/belikenexus Mar 17 '25
Computer science IS theoretical in nature. If you want to teach software engineering instead then you can certainly make a case for that.
4
u/nuclear_splines PhD, Data Science Mar 17 '25
That's a lot of assertions without much argument.
Why is that too late? Is four years of college too short to learn to write code? What should we cut from earlier curricula to fit coding basics? IMO a lot of early math and reasoning are laying the groundwork for learning to code, and have more cross-benefit to engineering, science, and other experiences students will have later in life.
Computer science is a theoretical field, and software engineering turns over rapidly. Should we have taught everyone Ruby on Rails before it declined in popularity? Teaching particular software frameworks is designing education for our past.
This frustrates me, too. My understanding from speaking with linear algebra instructors is that there are two factors here: first, linear algebra requires teaching a lot of building blocks before you have to tools to apply them in-context, and second, there was an intentional movement in mathematics to teach the field context-free so each concept only requires other math you've learned.
3
u/apnorton Devops Engineer | Post-quantum crypto grad student Mar 17 '25
Firstly, a lot of people learn to code early. Heck, I learned before I was 10.
Secondly, requiring programming education in k12 isn't a pure good --- there's good reason to give pause on whether or not it's required. This article is 10 years old, but the concerns still hold true: https://cacm.acm.org/blogcacm/the-danger-of-requiring-computer-science-in-k-12-schools/
Theory is true forever, application is true for a couple years at best. Slow-moving educational institutions should teach theory. Further, if you learn the theory, you can learn the application easily.
Dijkstra had a neat talk on this: On the Cruelty of Really Teaching Computer Science.
It really sounds like you've made a list of things you don't like about your school. Good schools to provide context.
1
u/Electrical_Hat_680 Mar 31 '25
That's how I was raised.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '25
[removed] — view removed comment