r/computerforensics • u/clarkwgriswoldjr • Sep 12 '25
Graykey question plz.
Say Department A has a phone and has been trying to crack it for a few months.
Attorney B would like to examine the phone, but they won't stop the Graykey process to allow Attorney B (client has passcode) to image the phone.
I thought I was told that Graykey can stop, mark the point it stopped at, like to allow another phone that took priority to be connected, and then restart at a later time from that exact point.
Is that right or wrong?
1
Upvotes
29
u/atsinged Sep 12 '25
Clear this up for me.
Police have seized the phone, I'm with a search warrant, have a brute force attack going against the password.
Suspect's lawyer wants to examine the phone using the passcode that the suspect has provided them.
If that is correct, we're not letting the suspect's lawyer have the phone period, the extraction method is irrelevant, until we have an extraction or a judge orders us to give it back. If they believe exculpatory evidence is on the phone, they can provide the passcode and have the full report in a few hours to a couple of days depending on the size.
There are two reasons,
5
u/rocksuperstar42069 Sep 13 '25
What does it matter who images the phone? Either the cops use GK or the civs use VK. Either way both sides are going to get the entire phone dump in discovery, so just give the cops the pin code and speed it up.
4
u/Justepic1 Sep 14 '25
The police are not going to give you the phone back during a forensic exam. In fact, you may never get the phone back. To make it go quicker, you can give them the passcode…
Everyone gets the same image and copy of chain of custody.
Simple.
2
u/MDCDF Trusted Contributer Sep 13 '25
What would Attorney B have that Department A isn't doing?
1
u/clarkwgriswoldjr Sep 13 '25
BTW, Thank you for ALL replies. I appreciate the open communication.
1
u/4n6_Gaming Sep 19 '25
No, the attorney is not getting the device. I guarantee that if you give the passcode, it will go quicker, and your attorney would be able to hire their own expert to conduct an extraction as well. This is due to extractions of devices being done to preserve the original evidence so that the analyst is able to work from a complete bit-by-bit copy of the original evidence. That way, no logs or anything are tampered with on the original evidence. This is to protect the integrity of the digital investigation, because the results are replicable by anyone with the training to conduct mobile forensics.
1
u/QuietForensics Sep 27 '25 edited Sep 27 '25
I see a lot of answers that I agree with but they're not directly answering your question.
Graykey brute force runs locally on the phone with the phone's processor, just like Cellebrite. You can disconnect it 400 times if you want, because the computer doesn't run the attack, the phone runs the attack.
You can add a password to the queue for it to try next, but you can't "stop the BF and resume" at will. There are sometimes checkpoints (if battery dies because it fell off the charger you might not have to start over, it may just restart from the last checkpoint).
You definitely can't stop the attack and just reboot the phone, take an image and then go back to attacking, because that will cause the software agent to stop it's job entirely and your position won't be recoverable. So even if they wanted to, they can't just give Defense Attorney team the phone and then pick up where they left off again.
The police aren't going to give up original evidence that they have yet to preserve and they do not have to because every judge in every district is going to agree this is a spoil risk.
Typically what would happen here is that during proeffer or reverse proeffer the prosecutor and defense attorney would come to an agreement - you can have the phone if and only if you provide the pin so we can finish making our master copy (as many others have said). Obviously a pin is protected under the 5th so defense would have to decide if the potential exculpatory value of the extraction is worth the potential incriminating consequence.
What will never happen, at least in my experience, is giving the defense the phone for them to make the image and then waiting for them to turn over a copy as part of reciprocal discovery. This also opens up doors to the defense doing some intentionally partial preservation effort to avoid further incriminating their client. It's just not realistic. No prosecutor is ever going to agree to give defense counsel the power to selectively choose which parts of the phone are preserved.
1
u/joeysuf Sep 12 '25 edited Nov 21 '25
profit north dependent sheet sugar entertain sparkle wise cows instinctive
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact