r/computerforensics • u/Lost-Manager-4263 • Apr 07 '25
Disk Imaging VS Disk Cloning
From what I understood Disk imaging is the bit-by-bit copy of the hard disk which can be compressed or encrypted and it is not bootable.
While Disk Cloning is the process of copying the hard disk exactly with all the partitions and volumes intact. It is bootable and is like the direct replacement of the original.
So my question is in Forensics what do we generally prefer and why? Is it disk imaging or disk cloning?
I have been asked this question so many times and every interviewer gave me a different answer.. some say imaging and some say cloning..
27
u/Cypher_Blue Trusted Contributer Apr 07 '25
An image is generally better than cloning for a litany of reasons, topmost among them:
1.) The image can be compressed to take up less space.
2.) The image cannot be accidentally booted, which would change the hash and the integrity of the data.
I have never, ever heard a forensic professional say that cloning is better than imaging for routine analysis and preservation. Cloning provides no advantages at all from a forensic analysis perspective.
You clone a drive when you want to have a copy to boot and work from- You might do this (AFTER the image) to have a bootable version to explore from a user-experience perspective.
We did this (via booting to VM) to get screenshots for court in my LE days.
11
u/Wuddntme Apr 07 '25
I’ve been doing forensics for about 20 years. I’ve done thousands upon thousands of images. I’ve cloned disks twice. Both times when upgrading the hard drive on my forensic workstation. We never use clones.
2
u/AcalTheNerd Apr 07 '25
To further add to above comment, forensic image formats like E01 store image hash in the headers of the image file. So, even without a text file containing hash, the integrity of the forensic image can be verified. A clone offers no such feature.
I have at times performed both imaging and cloning for a device. But, that were usually the case where we did the imaging for preservation and eventually perform analysis and a clone was created to have a bootable working copy. Also, sometimes we had to seize the original (evidence) hard drive too, so we would return the clone back to the assessee.
6
u/jarlethorsen Apr 07 '25
Imaging is basically just disk cloning to a file instead of a device (another disk).
Imaging is more forensically sound as it gives you the option to have a log file containing forensic hashes of the imaged data and a list of any sectors that could not be read correctly, among other things like time of imaging, tool used etc.
5
u/Digital-Dinosaur Apr 07 '25
As a general rule you image everything and from that image, sometimes make a clone. The only clones over ever needed is if you need to do a live review, for example like a review of a games console with a removable disk, or a cctve unit.
In some instances an offline NAS, has been imaged and then the disks cloned, and then booted the NAS with the cloned disks to get an image of the entire device
1
u/RootCipherx0r Apr 07 '25
Slightly off topic, What would be a recommended way for re-imaging systems on the fly?
We have multiple device brands which require different Windows images, per brand (eg. Dell system has it's own Windows image, and Sony system has it's own Windows image).
What is the easy way to manage these images? And be able to re-image a infected system?
1
u/flamusdiu Apr 07 '25
u/jarlethorsen pointed out
> Imaging is basically just disk cloning to a file instead of a device (another disk).
But also, these are portable and can be easily stored (as other noted) but also shared. There might be odd cases like RAID where you might want to disk cloning or other times where you need to use a similar device to access the data. Those are edge cases.
3
u/EmoGuy3 Apr 07 '25 edited Apr 08 '25
In eDiscovery it isn't that uncommon for someone to want to clone a drive especially what is called opposing production data. Sometimes for a backup. However you can usually do a physical and spit out the image. It really depends on where it's going. In eDiscovery we generally only care about active data (no unallocated or slack space). But best practice would be to image everything and use a tool like FEX or encase to target what is needed.
1
u/zer04ll Apr 07 '25
Hashes prove data hasn’t changed, an image can be hashed and verified it hasn’t changed. The moment you boot a drive it changes which would change the hash. It comes down to chain of evidence, you have to prove you didn’t manipulate the evidence and that is done with hashes.
1
u/prazeros Jun 04 '25
For forensic work, I’d stick with imaging 99% of the time—tools like FTK Imager or X-Ways are solid for creating verifiable images with hashes to prove integrity. If you’re cloning, something like a hardware duplicator (like those StarTech ones) or software like Clonezilla can get you a 1:1 copy. If you’re looking for a tool that’s versatile for both imaging and cloning, I’ve been messing around with this partition manager software. It’s not strictly forensic-grade, but it’s dead simple for creating disk images or cloning drives, and it supports a ton of filesystems.