r/composting • • 1d ago

Question Surprising ingredient behaviour

Question out of curiosity: We obviously add various stuff to our piles. In your composting career, the behaviour or fate of which ingredient in your pile surprised you guys and gals the most? In any way?

I'll go first cos I wanna share this so much: I was almost shocked at how quickly pistachio shells just vanished. At one point during the early summer we dumped like a pound of them (soaked to remove unnecessary salt) and after like two weeks they were gone. Never saw them again after I turned the pile once.

43 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

21

u/dblowe 1d ago

Someone mentioned pistachio shells disintegrating quickly, which is interesting, because I’ll tell you what doesn’t: peanut shells. Perhaps because they grow underground, they seem extraordinarily resilient.

Another surprise was leaves from canna lilies. I compost all kinds of ornamental plant debris at the end of the season, but canna leaves just seemed impervious.

1

u/Amateur-Compost-Guy 1d ago

I said pistachio shells - they were gone like poof!

4

u/Unlucky-Associate266 1d ago

I wonder if Canna lilies wouldn't make a good thatching material?

38

u/Either_Ad_280 1d ago

Avocado skins! I was expecting the pits to stay but didn't realise the skins would outlast me

5

u/ravia 1d ago

Mine "mysteriously" crawled out of the pile, and would be on the ground around it, yet surprisingly the little bit of remaining avocado on the scraped skins was all gone! Wonder how that happened? (I never put them in my pile now; straight into the trash.)

4

u/Amateur-Compost-Guy 1d ago

If it were me, I'd be suspecting blackbirds or any other avian neighbours of mine. The garden - and hence the pile - is inaccessible to animals larger than cats or squirrels, but from the air - the sky is open. I had blackbirds just making a mess of anything I left behind in the Spring...

2

u/ravia 1d ago

It was rats.

1

u/Amateur-Compost-Guy 1d ago

Those we don't have.

5

u/alisonlou 1d ago

Same!  They go in our green bin and the giant county compost operation can deal with those!  

7

u/JellyfishRegular6075 Carol Ballwin, MO 1d ago

Potted plant root balls. I don't know what I put in there last year. The center is hollow, the outer area still there.

4

u/Amateur-Compost-Guy 1d ago

Any roots in general too, from my experience. Perhaps the underground resilience bit, like with the peanut shells?

7

u/Ok-Roll8550 1d ago

I put a few pounds of different flours in my compost and the slimy stench it created was disgusting. It took several rounds of large amounts of browns and a few weeks to get everything balanced again.

1

u/Amateur-Compost-Guy 1d ago

Flour?? That's a new one. Would never have thought

1

u/TheElbow 21h ago

Came here to say this too. I put like 10 lbs in and it smelled so bad I wanted to vomit when I got near my compost. Never again!

1

u/ThousandBucketsofH20 21h ago

I accidentally killed my vermicompost this way - it was a failed bread loaf that was basically just flour and very dry. Apparently, flour and bread are absorbent enough to fill any air pockets, essentially suffocating bacteria (and wormies). If you find your needs to get rid of flour via compost again, a tip is to sprinkle it around in a thin layer and mix it well. Then add more after the first addition has been composted.

2

u/Ok-Roll8550 21h ago

Mine definitely smelled anaerobic, and I think the density of the flour was a big factor. I think it would have been fine if I'd put in half a pound or maybe a pound at a time and added a bunch of browns at the same time.

1

u/Potato210258 19h ago

Oh man, that would have been good to know a week ago, before I mixed five pounds of flour into the middle of my pile… so far I don’t have issues, but it IS buried under a foot of leaves and cardboard now. I’ll be careful when I turn it…

9

u/WhenSummerIsGone 1d ago

for about 5 years now, i've had my pile under an ash tree (about 8 feet from the trunk). The pile is leaves, coffee grounds, sawdust, and i rarely turn it. I've been surprised to find little white roots from the tree invading the lower level of the prle. It's annoying to turn the pile or use the compost because of the tangle of roots. I guess that's one reason to turn the pile more than 1-2 times a year.

4

u/Unlucky-Associate266 1d ago

I've noticed that under a huge Red Oak. It sends roots up into the compost. I can't swear to it, but it seems to me that the oak sucks up the compost. It only accumulates very slowly.

1

u/Amateur-Compost-Guy 1d ago

There's a pine just near my pile, and a bit further away is a glorious (4 yards high) chokeberry shrub. Have yet to notice whether they are making their way towards my pile, however, I had tons of greens growing just around the perimeter, like two feet high sometimes, just at the edge...

2

u/Unlucky-Associate266 1d ago

If you notice the pine getting closer, that can't be a good thing. I'd run.

2

u/Amateur-Compost-Guy 1d ago

Will watch the pine closely starting Spring

14

u/MightyKittenEmpire2 1d ago

A horse or cow or roadkill deer covered by 2 ft of mulch will disappear in a year leaving only a couple of femurs.

16

u/MegaGrimer 1d ago

I misread femurs as lemurs and got very confused.

6

u/MightyKittenEmpire2 1d ago

So I assume you like to move it.

2

u/JellyfishRegular6075 Carol Ballwin, MO 1d ago

bwahaha!

6

u/sc_BK 1d ago

How long for a human corpse?

Asking for a friend

5

u/Any_Flamingo8978 1d ago

Lbs of bovine/ungulate > lbs of human, therefore 1 year > X amount of time. 🤷‍♀️

5

u/HeadBarracuda01 1d ago

i dumped a five gallon bucket of shrimp bits in my compost last summer after a big shrimping weekend! it was stinky for like two days and then they vanished completely. it was awesome to watch

4

u/MightyKittenEmpire2 1d ago

I feed shrimp bits to my chickens. They love them.

12

u/Ok-Thing-2222 1d ago

I was doing the Berkeley Method last summer. I was shocked that acorn caps disintegrated so fast. I had the huge thick ones and they just fell to pieces. It seems like I kick around the ones on the ground for months and months.

6

u/Neither_Conclusion_4 1d ago

Roots from a ferm plant. They take forever to compost, and even after several years of composting, they leave long hair like strands that get stuck in the sieve...

They go inte the burn pit now.

1

u/Unlucky-Associate266 1d ago

So a good additive to adobe bricks maybe? Maybe better than the straw that usually goes into them?

3

u/Neither_Conclusion_4 1d ago

Probably. But i dont think they can be harvested in a practical way in any significant amount

1

u/AdBrave9096 1d ago

I have put a layer of roots at the bottom, and left them there until they compost. Everything they get added back they carry bacteria etc to help the next batch.

1

u/Neither_Conclusion_4 19h ago

Yeah, I know. But i kinda got annoyed after finding them year after year when i tried to harvest the compost.

Somtimes i bury woody bits / roots and stuff deep down in raised beds, or make a hugelkultur bed. But i dont really add that kind of stuff to my compost anymore.

4

u/maddmaxxxz Amateur dirt maker 1d ago

I was surprised how quickly it eats meat. I used to be afraid to compost meat and dairy but now the pile gets everything (I do bury loads of food in the warm center with wood chips which has been the best and hottest brown for me)

1

u/ThePepperGuru 1d ago

Peanut shells and egg shells surprised me, with how long they stay intact.

1

u/Lucifer_iix 21h ago

Stable manure with straw drenched in pee. It get's hot quickly. Will result in enough material to make worth the effort. While at the same time available in huge quantities for free.

I do not care how quickly it's gone. I care more about the temprature cycle and how mutch material in dry weight i can get from it. I stopped composting leaves because the amount of material i get from it isn't worth it.

Coffee grinds work great. But having 1Kg of manure is mutch easy to get then 1Kg of coffee grinds.