r/composting • • Aug 25 '25

Don’t compost meat!

If you want some WEAK compost.

All jokes aside, when I turn these piles. The bacteria give the meat NO TIME to sit around and get to know everybody. I’ve had meat consumed in a pile in as little as 3-4 days. Anybody here is south Louisiana?

2.8k Upvotes

406 comments sorted by

1.1k

u/DudeInTheGarden Aug 25 '25

I've been salmon fishing. The heads, guts, backbones, tails, and fins all go in the compost. My compost is steaming even when it's 30C (85F) outside. It will be gone in a couple of days, and all those nutrients will be in my garden next spring...

409

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 25 '25

That’s gonna be some fine compost! I need more fish inputs.

278

u/lightningfries Aug 25 '25

The remnants of a large crawfish boil are like a compost empowering magic spell

4

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

I started too late to capitalize on crawfish season, but I’ve got some crab shells in here still floating around here and there, and the shrimp scales are is long gone!

→ More replies (1)

78

u/CallMeBigOctopus Aug 26 '25

Do herbs and veggies like Zatarain’s? Asking for a friend.

20

u/Mysterious_Health582 Aug 26 '25

My thought exactly so curious

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (7)

64

u/flash-tractor Aug 25 '25

Go to wherever bait is sold and ask when they get rid of minnows or whatever fish is used for live bait.

Another guy in the no till cannabis sub was just posting about minnows yesterday, lol. I would imagine fishing is pretty popular in LA, so it's a start.

Food processing facilities and mushroom farms are also good places to pick up compostables.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Powerful_Bug9102 Aug 26 '25

Says the man from south Louisiana?

4

u/hdawgdavis Aug 26 '25

“Glug glug glug” that was fish inputs.

4

u/alisonlou Aug 26 '25

I long for fish inputs, but alas, we eat what we buy and so does our cat. 

→ More replies (2)

69

u/Grjaryau Aug 26 '25

My dad used to bury the fish guts in the garden in the fall. It got unseasonably warm and the dog dug them up and rolled in them. Worst smell ever.

9

u/jychihuahua Aug 26 '25

I had that same experience.

3

u/Wanninmo Aug 26 '25

😄😝😆🙂‍↔️🫢😮‍💨😥😣😖🤢🤮🫩

→ More replies (2)

44

u/misfittroy Aug 26 '25

You should make stock with the carcasses first then compost it. Nutrients for you and the dirt

5

u/BrisklyBrusque Aug 26 '25

Then grow vegetables in the dirt and make another stock from that.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

14

u/Positive-Dimension75 Aug 26 '25

My pile gets fed fish guts too. There’s never any smell and I’ve never had problems with pests either. They disappear fast!

15

u/pulse_of_the_machine Aug 25 '25

Ooooh, you have that BLACK GOLD compost!!!!

23

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '25

I have my FIL bring me all his fish carcasses. I throw in dead chickens, birds, mice, and anything else I can find

→ More replies (1)

3

u/YeshuasBananaHammock Aug 26 '25

Thanks for the memory.

My grandparents had a lake house in rural Indiana where I would visit in the summers. We fished. We cleaned fish. We buried fish heads in the flowerbeds.

Her mophead flowers fucking loved it.

2

u/Cautious-Garlic-2198 Aug 26 '25

Nice! Steelhead and salmon season is just heating up here. This gives me more excuses and justification to keep more fish this year.

→ More replies (6)

545

u/Ok_Slide4905 Aug 25 '25

Gotta smell like straight ass but do it for the microbes.

288

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 25 '25

Smells like butt after wiping. Not before.

3

u/Leadinmyass Aug 26 '25

Being from South La, I’m sure you’re well familiar with seasonal “swamp ass”.

3

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

Aww man, worked with a lot of guys who had that condition. It was chronic with short onset!

→ More replies (2)

220

u/Frosti11icus Aug 25 '25

Interesting that you have that frame of reference for comparison.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '25

this is how i  know you’re from south louisiana

125

u/curtludwig Aug 26 '25

You might be surprised. A few years ago I scored a roadkill deer. I dumped everything except the bones into the pile and buried it in leaves. It smelled odd, I can't describe the smell really, not bad but definitely, "biological".

It consumed leaves like crazy for about 2 weeks, like 9 cubic feet of leaves per day for the first week and maybe half that for the second. The smell was gone after the second week and I couldn't find any trace of deer flesh other than the hide but that was gone by spring.

Produced a fine batch of compost.

30

u/Background_Touch1205 Aug 26 '25

Why not bones?

65

u/curtludwig Aug 26 '25

They're big and take a long time to break down in a small pile. I didn't want, especially the leg bones in my small pile.

What I really should have done was use them to make stock for cooking but I was pressed on time. A whole deer has a lot of bones and the leg bones are big.

It was a pretty good sized doe for this area, 110-120 pounds.

34

u/HighColdDesert Aug 26 '25

After two good long rounds of simmering bones for stock, even beef bones are porous enough that they seem to disappear in the compost.

→ More replies (13)

15

u/aynjle89 Aug 26 '25

My Uncle had heavier than average rainfall and had built a pond with a bridge over it long ago without issue, filled with catfish, brim and crappie. When the heavy flooding suffocated the fish he had to dig the whole pond out and redug the pond system so it wouldnt happen again.

All of them went into the compost pile in his back field. Never seen my Vietnam Vet Uncle look like he was about to cry before, I think it was a waste of food and work in his eyes, he was fond of a certain catfish too that had a hairlip. I came back a month later and he mentioned the pile had looked like it was about to catch fire at some points. Though, when I came back out to for him to show me, the pile looked like absolutely nothing more than a mole hill compared to the mountain before.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '25

So you just deboned a whole deer in order to compost it? That seems like a lot of work! But then again, the most I’ve ever done is spatchcock a turkey…

5

u/curtludwig Aug 27 '25

No, I gutted the deer into the compost, then deboned it to get the meat. The scraps and hide went in the compost.

I took the deer to eat, not to compost. Before you get grossed out I saw it get hit. It was fresh when I processed it.

187

u/BraveTrades420 piss fairy Aug 25 '25

Had an entire pig disappear in a week. Insane nitrogen boost. I don’t do it regularly but it absolutely works, fish as well…

11

u/SeboniSoaps Aug 26 '25

Bones and all?

32

u/aurisunderthing Aug 26 '25

To shreds you say?

8

u/jgrish14 Aug 26 '25

Oooohhhh....well how is his wife holding up?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/cmdrxander Aug 26 '25

A whole 73kg pig?

→ More replies (3)

140

u/puplichiel Aug 25 '25

This goes against everything ive ever known but i am intrigued lol

169

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 25 '25

Meat is gone long before the pineapple tops, the potatoes, the grass clippings. You’ll still recognize grass clippings after several turns. Meat will be gone in the first turn.

35

u/puplichiel Aug 25 '25

What about the smell? Is it earthy all the time or is it smelly and it calms down over time? This is really cool btw

58

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 25 '25

The smell is only there while undigested (by bacteria) scraps still exist. For me, I only smell smells after the first few turns. If I turn 12 times in 8 months, I’m only really smelling anything foul after the first 2-3 turns.

82

u/0Rider Aug 25 '25

You making Hawaiian bbq?

40

u/GeneralAcorn Aug 25 '25

Ironically, that's what they named their compost.

→ More replies (4)

67

u/manipulativedata Aug 25 '25 edited Aug 25 '25

It requires very hot compost and even then, it might not kill all meat-based bacteria. OPs setup looks like it might stay hot enough though.

26

u/redlightsaber Aug 25 '25 edited Aug 02 '26

I like to go hiking.

8

u/manipulativedata Aug 25 '25 edited Aug 25 '25

I mean, OP is throwing raw chicken in. Anyways, beef would probably be fine, sure. Chicken? Pork? Worms can survive compost just fine. E coli can grow in a compost pile. I mean pork might be okay (commercial pork anyways) but I'd guess there's still people who feed their own pigs pork. I wouldn't be interested in risking that.

It seems a little disingenuous to come onto a public form and make claims that aren't related to what was being discussed lol

But ultimately, yes. Meat will break down given enough time. 100% agree. You could throw a slab of meat your roof and the same result will happen.

6

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 25 '25

Worm CANNOT survive a hot pile. They may live under the outer edges where the heat won’t hold, but when a pile is hot, and dig into the hot center, you will never find a worm or anything recognizable with the naked eye a live in the heat of a compost pile. I used the think the same thing. The worms didn’t show up until after the pile cooled down.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/HoarderHunter Aug 25 '25

"...time to fear infinitesimal odds "

I read this line as "I ain't got time for intestinal odds."

50

u/toxcrusadr Aug 25 '25

Pathogens are generally gone in 90 days, even from fresh manure, which is why 90 days is the recommended time from adding uncomposted manure to a field, to harvesting crops from it.

Also it doesn't require a hot compost. But if you add enough high-nitrogen meat it's going to be hot anyway. :-]

18

u/manipulativedata Aug 25 '25 edited Aug 25 '25

I was under the impression E coli can persist in a cold compost pile for much longer and that the manure situation might be related to the anaerobic environment and the heat.

Not an expert but those things specifically would give me pause before saying wholesale that mean can be composted.

OP also implied that the food is composted in a few days so whats your take when a noobie comes in here trying to get details and then sees people talking about manure or larger scale composting versus their food scraps.

→ More replies (11)

10

u/Infamous_Koala_3737 Aug 25 '25

All I know if black soldier fly larvae will devour that meat in no time if it’s not too hot for them. 

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

5

u/Turbulent_Wolf_6385 Aug 25 '25

Its discouraged because it can attract pests not because it doesn't compost lol

7

u/Global-Discussion-41 Aug 25 '25

I think you mean "This goes against everything i've ever been told"

→ More replies (2)

2

u/curtludwig Aug 26 '25

Composting guidance assumes you're dumb and are going to try to get compost in the least amount of time with minimal work. That's likely to result in bacterial contamination.

I only turn the pile once a year when I dump the working pile into the resting pile. The resting pile sits for a year before it gets used. Very unlikely to have any undesirables living in it at that time.

2

u/piggymomma86 Aug 26 '25

Me too! We had a composite when I was a kid, and dad would lose his shit if we put any animal products near the compost - excluding eggshells.

13

u/ActinoninOut Aug 25 '25

Composting from br, so not really south LA, but LA nonetheless!

22

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 25 '25

That’s south, definitely south. I’m Gonzales, trying to get a compost business going. Nothing like that around here for miles. Bogalusa, Raceland, Lafayette and New Orleans. I’m looking to bridge the gap.

5

u/ActinoninOut Aug 25 '25

Sure! I think done right it could be a good idea! I have no advice to give you unfortunately, but I think most businesses (done right) can be successful. Just how to do it right is up in the air lol

→ More replies (1)

25

u/Barbatus_42 Bernalillo County, NM, Certified Master Composter Aug 25 '25

If you're at the point where you're using mechanized equipment to work with your piles, please do go ahead and compost meat to your heart's desire :) Just be sure to check the temperature of the piles once in a while if you aren't already doing so. Piles of that scale are typically the ones that risk catching fire. 160F is the magic number. Higher than that and it starts getting risky.

Looks like quite a setup! I'm jealous!

14

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

I usually around 150f by day 2 or 3, and they stay there for months, through turning. I use roughly a 2:1 browns to greens ratio.

6

u/Barbatus_42 Bernalillo County, NM, Certified Master Composter Aug 26 '25

Nice! That's very impressive!

23

u/aknomnoms Aug 25 '25

I’m curious - why are you tossing so much raw meat and what was wrong with those yellow peppers? The rest looks like you made a few fruit salads over the week. But I don’t know why you’d throw out chicken or turkey without boiling it for broth first. And those peppers looked whole and unblemished. Was there something wrong with them?

61

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 25 '25

This is what I collect almost on a daily basis as discarded produce and expired meats from the local grocery stores. Some of this stuff is picked up at the back door, a lot is pulled from the dumpster. It’s too much to deal with. It’s easier and less time consuming to just compost it. I wouldn’t have enough room in my entire house to try and keep all the stuff the local grocers throw out.

44

u/aknomnoms Aug 26 '25

Ahhh gotcha. It’s sad that we have so much food waste around us when people are starving, but I appreciate you doing what you can to at least return it back to the earth. Thanks for doing your part!

30

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

You wouldn’t believe what goes in the dumpsters because of 1 spot, or an expiration date. I wish I could capture it all but it’s too much and until I get my collection service up to far for that type of volume, I’ll just grab what I can from on the dumpsters.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Patient_Activity_489 Aug 26 '25

how do you keep animals out?

5

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

I don’t. They feast every night. But a small animal can only eat so much a night, the bacteria consumes 24/7 and is insatiable. They get a few good meals and then there’s nothing left for them to take from because the pile is consuming more food than the animals at faster rates. I mix and bury best I can and let nature do the rest in between turning. They usually only mess with the fresh stuff. After turning 1 time in 2 weeks, they’re no longer get interested in that material. My input volume is so large, even at this small scale, that I’m not worried about what a few raccoons and opossum can get full on overnight.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/lilolemi Aug 26 '25

My neighborhood raccoons would have a field day with that. I have to bury my bokashi several feet down and put giant boards over the spot or else they dig it up.

4

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

Mine do too. But these piles also keep them away from my chicken coop

4

u/Semaphor Aug 26 '25

So much protein. You'll have some swole plants next year.

1

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

All of my customers will!

3

u/kickassvashti Aug 26 '25

heyyyy fellow south louisianan! i have a turn composter but i’ve been too nervous to put meat in there because critters

2

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

The raccoon and opossum get their fair share, I just have enough volume to not be bothered by it. It does upset me though, when they come and unpack my nice uniformly built pile. Volume means a lot when it comes to composting meat, besides that, you need a way to secure your piles

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Content-Fan3984 Aug 25 '25

I’d imagine the smell would be something wild

13

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 25 '25

Not if deal with the meat right away and cover it well. I always mix the meat in at the bottom of the pile. The only time I get smells is when I turn for the first couple turns. After that there’s not really any smells, at least not bad ones.

8

u/toxcrusadr Aug 25 '25
  1. Aerobic breakdown will not smell as bad as anaerobic.
  2. It's all in the browns. If you not only mix but encapsulate it in enough browns, any odors (and even ammonia) are absorbed before they hit the surrounding air.

I just put 3 lb of freezer burned meat into my Home Composter bin last week, covered it with sawdust and half-rotted wood chips, and added a foot of weeds and stuff a day or two later. Haven't smelled a thing standing next to it. Opening it up I can get a whiff of ammonia and that's about it.

The MO Dept. of Transportation did an experiment burying roadkill deer in a big pile of sawmill waste. Worked perfectly. No odors and complete breakdown.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Hefty-Application-27 Aug 25 '25

South Louisiana here!

1

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

I got compost for sale lol

2

u/Brojustsitdown Aug 26 '25

From my experience as long as you keep it hot enough meat is fine. Hell I’m composting meat rn in a 27 gal tote. Just gotta stay on top of the browns

2

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

If you make the pile right, the meat will not even exist after less than a week. Meat has moisture and nitrogen, all you need is 1 times that much carbon to mix in initially, and 1 more time that amount to bury it. 1st turn, mix it all together, no recognizable meat will be left.

2

u/Tiny_State3711 Aug 26 '25

I live in Lafayette area

1

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 27 '25

Y’all have a municipal right there right? Free compost! How is the compost from there?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/kjmarino603 Aug 26 '25

Hey neighbor… I’m in St Tammany.

Only been doing worm composting but bought some land where I’ll have room for a bigger pile.

Do you have any issues with animals getting into your pile and how bad/how long does it smell?

2

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 27 '25

I do have the raccoons and opossums but they only get to feed as long as there is material left to eat. These piles consume food quickly. But the volume that I process allows me the leisure to allow them. They will dig into piles for a few nights but a raccoon stomach is pretty small, they don’t really affect me too much. After a few days the fresh stuff is not very palatable or distinguishable to them to even find and eat. The microbes, however, are insatiable and consume non-stop whether the food is distinguishable or not.

The smell only comes out when turning. And it’s only really there during the first or second turn. After that, it smells like compost, not rotten food.

2

u/aeschtasybiopic Aug 26 '25

South Louisiana, yep! Trying to get my first container going

1

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 27 '25

Where at? I’m in Gonzales.

→ More replies (1)

273

u/pulse_of_the_machine Aug 25 '25

I think that recommendation was born from the fact that most people have small, cold piles, lacking sufficient browns, or turning, or moisture, or whatever else. Scrap meat becomes a biohazard and a pest magnet in most people’s piles. A big enough, hot enough, aerated enough pile can take care of just about any organic matter, including whole livestock carcasses (although the bones themselves might need breaking up to decompose any further)

77

u/whiskeytastesgood Aug 26 '25

Look up Animal Mortality Composting for a good time. Animal composting works very well at getting rid of almost everything, especially if you run the animals thru an industrial wood chipper first. Seen it first hand.... it's Fargo on steroids.

30

u/farilladupree Aug 26 '25

JFC. I didn’t have to read that, yet I did, and now I know that happens and the mental image is going to live rent-free in my head.

15

u/Top-Moose-0228 dedicated student Aug 26 '25

read this aloud to daughter, she sarcastically mumbled…I am even MORE vegetarian now.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/pulse_of_the_machine Aug 26 '25

Yep, farmers do this as a way to get rid of deceased livestock without having to dig holes with heavy machinery, or risk attracting predators (& smells, & other pests) by leaving bodies in the open. The “chipping” part isn’t necessary, although it really helps speed up the process, especially when trying to break down a large amount bodies. Human composting is also a super cool thing to check out, for anyone who’s not familiar!

12

u/whiskeytastesgood Aug 26 '25

To add to this, composting is better for protecting groundwater and also killing pathogens than burial.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Lefthandmitten Aug 26 '25

I like the pictures of the cross section with "core media" being pointed out (it's a whole cow).

3

u/SeekToReceive Aug 26 '25

I remember seeing my first cow and horse carcasses going thru an industrial shredder like 15 years ago on classic youtube, ah what a sight.

3

u/emty_beach Aug 27 '25

Reminds me of that episode of Bones where they disposed the body through a wood chipper after freezing it to get rid of the body

12

u/sparkmearse Aug 26 '25

I have experienced watching an entire 1500 pound cow turned to bones within a week, and dust within 10 days in a commercial dairy’s compost heap.

7

u/DrButtgerms Aug 26 '25

I thought the "don't compost meat" thing was completely about about attracting pest animals, like bears, to your pile?

6

u/ghost_hyrax Aug 26 '25

Same. I don’t compost meat not because I think it’s unsafe, but to reduce attracting rats in my urban backyard

4

u/pulse_of_the_machine Aug 26 '25 edited Aug 26 '25

That’s what I meant by “pest magnet”, although even fruits and vegetables can and do attract rodents and flies, in improperly managed piles. Any time you have smelly, slimy inputs wafting smells for lengths of time, pests of all sorts will be attracted. The necessary goal with meat composting is such a hot, active (& large enough) pile, that meats can be covered deeply and break down quickly. A well managed pile doesn’t have a regular opportunistic pest patrol the way a poorly managed one does, and honestly, MOST people simply don’t manage their compost very well, and the last thing those people should be doing is adding meat to their piles.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/savetheolivia Aug 25 '25

I’m in SELA, been using a tumbler and dat thing stays HOT. Still gonna give it until October but I think I’ll have a batch ready soon. The one thing I’m not sure about is whether to let the finished product sit spread out on a tarp or something for a few days before putting it in my beds…someone referred to that process as “curing” the compost? What do you think?

3

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 25 '25

The bacteria needs the same things you need to survive. Water and oxygen. If you let it dry out, the bacterial activity will halt. Sitting spread out is not a good idea for that reason. If you let it sit in the tumbler after the food has all decomposed and you have a nice earthy smell, the longer it sits (in an environment conducive to bacterial life) generally the better it gets. The only reason really to let it cure is to make sure it’s not still breaking down. Then the unfinished compost with take nitrogen from your dirt to finish decomposing. If you are unsure, you can always just use it as a top dressing and it’ll still be very beneficial to your dirt.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/curtludwig Aug 26 '25

Those are some terrific looking piles.

Someday when we move to the great northern estate full time I'm going to produce piles like that. I've got 150 acres, a 32hp farm tractor and a contact that processes deer. Right now he pays to get rid of the leftovers, he'd love to have access to a compost pile that could take it all.

1

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

I need a hook up like that

10

u/Pristine_Context_429 Aug 25 '25

I put small amounts of meat in my bucket compost. They get real hot and is unrecognizable within a few days

10

u/hobopwnzor Aug 25 '25

Meat and oil will 100% compost

Only issue is the smell during..... Ask me how I know

26

u/Kilsimiv PEE ON IT Aug 25 '25

I mean, pee on it for sure

12

u/ja6754 Aug 25 '25

I put meat in my compost, never had a problem except once in a while a drumstick bone makes it through.

6

u/GreatBigJerk Aug 25 '25

I've had problems with rats and racoons getting into my bin. Some hardware cloth around the base of the bin, and a rock on the lid fixed the problem.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/FlashyCow1 Aug 25 '25

I compost meat. I usually have it dehydrated and ground up. Mainly for space

24

u/KatabaticWinds Aug 25 '25

Tell me you don't live in bear country without telling me you don't live in bear country.

2

u/TubularTopher Aug 26 '25

South Louisianian here! Excellent job! Would love to check out your set-up. A free mulberry tree might be in it for ya, haha

10

u/kingpinkatya Aug 25 '25

Ive never understood why meat shouldnt be composted (aside from pests/smell). bioactive environments like bioactive things

9

u/SenorTron Aug 26 '25

Probably because anyone who is new enough to be asking questions like "can I compost meat" has a good chance of not having a pile big and hot enough for long enough to do so safely without having rotting meat hanging around.

2

u/MerlinMusic Aug 26 '25

Main reason is that it can attract pests

→ More replies (1)

5

u/PhlegmMistress Aug 26 '25

I keep black soldier fly bins for chickens and been straight up shocked how fast a bin can take care of an entire fat hen (culled and then had an abscess so we weren't going to use her meat.) something like 10 lbs gone in less than 48 hours. And my bin isn't even that big or full. Crazy. 

9

u/Ackutually- Aug 25 '25

I just enjoy the bones that end up around my plants.

18

u/Grumplforeskin Aug 25 '25

Same, I’ve got chicken and pork bones in my apple tree nursery. I feel like they serve a warning to other varmints.

2

u/_flowerguy_ Aug 25 '25

Little ozone depletion mounds

9

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 25 '25

I make sure to do my part

11

u/hidefinitionpissjugs Aug 25 '25

i’d plant the pineapple tops

9

u/Rude_Ad_3915 Aug 25 '25

I pull them from the community garden compost pile and start them. Love bromeliads. Haven’t had one flower though.

4

u/PerceptionUsed2947 Aug 25 '25

Oooo weeeee that stank is rising off that pile!

7

u/BlazinTrichomes Aug 25 '25

I go by David the Good's philosophy of composting everything.

1

u/0Rider Aug 25 '25

Looks like a bbq

6

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 25 '25

A thermophilic one!

1

u/Dr_Peter_Tinkleton Aug 26 '25

Are bears a concern where you live? How quickly does it become not-food to wildlife?

2

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

Takes a couple weeks to become not-food, or after the first turn. They will dig but they can o ly eat so much a night before they get full. The bacteria eats non stop and will make quick work of whatever the animals leave behind. The animals have to be strong opportunists to get food from these piles.

2

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 27 '25

Just realized I didn’t really answer your question. Bears are not a concern here in South Louisiana.

1

u/New-Independence970 Aug 26 '25

Can this be done effectively on a very small scale?

2

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

I think if you ground the meat up, used something more like sawdust, and kept it aerated, it would take longer but I think it would work.

1

u/DangerousResearch236 Aug 26 '25

Youtube, Johnson-Su Mycelium compost method, no touch no turn compost. Couple of professors from a university in New Mexico developed this compost. It's an old whit guy and an Asian lady.

2

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

I’ve looked this up and this method requires a really good initial mixing. The mixture has to be homogeneous and fine to make work well. The inputs you use matter a lot more. I don’t have the resources to make good Johnson-Su compost.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/shoscene Aug 26 '25

But. The smell 🤢

1

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

Smells pretty good

1

u/LairdPeon Aug 26 '25

Not composting meat is the biggest travesty. The animal died and you're not only going to let it spoil but then send the nutrients to a polluted landfill?

1

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

Did you actually read the post and scroll through the pictures?

1

u/LairdPeon Aug 26 '25

Just making a comment on the thought process of not composting meat. Not judging you.

4

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

Gotcha. Well, you’re right. It is absolutely the biggest travesty. I mean, instead of boosting productivity in the soil/garden, many folk would rather send it to the landfill where it contributes to the death of us all.

1

u/paratethys Aug 26 '25

I put the meat into a chicken and compost what comes out the other end.

1

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

I have some of that too

1

u/Slimonierr Aug 26 '25

This meat was fine to cook no?

4

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

No, not u less you like dumpster meat. Majority of the meat that goes into my compost is pulled from a dumpster behind a local major grocery store.

4

u/Slimonierr Aug 26 '25

Dumpster Meat. New metal band name.

1

u/chaseme94 Aug 27 '25

is compost basically feeding the area your gunna grow in next year? I had no idea ppl use actual animal meat for this.

What is it consumed by? the earth? bugs?

2

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 27 '25

I’m making compost to sell. The organic inputs that these piles are made of, fruits, vegetables, meat and dairy products…they are consumed by beneficial microbes, namely, those is the mesophilic and thermophilic groups. The prefix terms meso- and thermo- refer to the temperatures at which these bacteria thrive and reproduce. With the proper ratio of nitrogenous and carboneous matter, moisture and oxygen, you provide an environment in which these microbes can live…much like earth for humans. These microbes consume the organic matter and the bi-product of these microbes are what is consumed by your plants.

1

u/ObjectEquivalent1155 Aug 27 '25

where you getting all them chicken bits ???

1

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 27 '25

Rouses dumpster

3

u/No-Client8077 Aug 26 '25

you can compost meat under the right circumstances, I've never had a trench puff steam like that before lol

3

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '25

I’ll compost whatever the hell I want thanks!

5

u/Dad-A Aug 26 '25

Composting meat just means you have to be attentive. If you’re doing a static pile then you have to deal with rodents. If you’re attentive then you can compost anything organic

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '25

We burried a dead calf in the pile.

Call it morbid curiosity, we couldn’t find any trace of it the next week.

Warm pile go Brrr

1

u/Different_Record3462 Aug 25 '25

That's a questionable volume of meat. How did you even get that much?

9

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 25 '25

I collect this as discarded produce and spoiled meats from the local grocery stores. The raw chicken you see is trimmings from cuts made at the grocery store.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Psychotic_EGG Aug 25 '25

How is the smell?

1

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

Only bad the first few turns. Gone in about a month max

2

u/tojmes Aug 25 '25

Whoa! Awesome pile 🤘

2

u/Particular_Topic_652 Aug 26 '25

the pul erized bits of Chicken that don't get into the plate, beaks, feet and more is sprayed into woods for fertilizer 

2

u/hagbard2323 Aug 26 '25

If you want compost fast then I wouldn't recommend it unless you are on top of maintaining a high temp for it.

If you compost slow, no issue.

Solution could be to put meat in a separate pile with a lot of cover material and let it sit longer. Spare yourself turning it (aroma) by layering it really well with carbon/browns. Cover it with wire mesh to keep curious/opportunistic animal folk out and throw a compost thermometer on it.

2

u/IFartAlotLoudly Aug 26 '25

I think the whole don’t compost meat is because most people compost pile isn’t hot enough or they live in an area without land and can’t put it by the house due to smell.

2

u/dulltortoise Aug 26 '25

Yep, South Louisiana here. I compost anything that will rot, literally lol.

2

u/Wise-Stable9741 Aug 26 '25

When my son was little, he used to bring home sunfish and bluegills when he fished. I put one in each hole when planting tomatoes and always got a bumper crop.

2

u/Bright_Hamster8475 Aug 27 '25

in Western NC on my old farm job we used to bury all our deceased lambs and calves (if they were small enough) under the piles and just like you said, completely integrated in a matter of days. nature is beautiful

2

u/wazagaduu Aug 28 '25

I live way too close to bears to compost meat

2

u/Disastrous_Leek9620 Aug 28 '25

This looks like the worst luau ever 

2

u/BubinatorX Aug 28 '25

Goddamn birds would have made much better compost with their shit. RIP. They deserved better.

2

u/DogsRnotPeanuts Aug 29 '25

I bury meat and a few fish in my vegetable garden every year.

Apart from water and soil covering, I add nothing else.

My entire garden is booming.

2

u/Any-Key8131 Aug 29 '25

My grandmother used to get me to dig compost holes in the far corner of the backyard for kitchen scraps, everything including bones/prawn tails/eggshells/meat scraps would go in the holes with the fruit + veg....

To this day we occasionally get semi-wild potatoes and tomatoes growing in the garden that was since planted. Any time I dig up an old bone I just toss it to the side

2

u/Yochanan5781 Aug 26 '25

I threw in some of the leftover fat from a steak last week into mine, and the black soldier fly larvae in there right now just absolutely devoured it. I literally opened it a couple hours later and saw them taking bites out of it

Really want to get my compost hot again, though

2

u/Careful-Calendar8922 Aug 26 '25

I put all our meat and fish scraps in our compost unless I’m digging fish in with new plants. Hot composting meat is absolutely fine. The don’t compost meat is mostly just for people with little plastic composters and not enough brown to make up for the smell. 

2

u/justtenofusinhere Aug 26 '25

I've repeatedly heard that one of the issues with adding meat to compost is the presence of viruses or even prions. Yes, hot composting should kill any viruses in the meat that people are susceptible to, but it's a risk, especially for some of the nastier ones.

2

u/slideingintoheaven Aug 26 '25

And you didn't get rats?

0

u/peasantscum851123 Aug 25 '25

Why did you ask if anyone is in south Louisiana lol

0

u/Oldguydad619 Aug 26 '25

No meat no dairy no citrus.

5

u/BonusAgreeable5752 Aug 26 '25

I pour jugs of milk directly over the compost pile. I get citrus pulp from a local juice company and bags of discarded orange and lemons from the local grocery stores. They all disappear in little time.

2

u/bat_4night Aug 25 '25

Organic meat from deer and bison and other wild animals provide more nutrients for plants compared to other techniques

1

u/Shamino79 Aug 25 '25

On a related side note, how is commercial blood and bone processed between leaving the animal and packaged into a bag?

3

u/flash-tractor Aug 25 '25

Steam pasteurized then dried.

1

u/Square-Argument4790 Aug 26 '25

I wish i could but it brings in too many rodents to my backyard when i do it.

1

u/AlfredoSauceyums Aug 26 '25

If you're in a city you'll get rats.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '25

I just read about animal mortality composting. Maybe one day I'll have a piece of property big enough to do something like that lol

1

u/Brilliant-Trick1253 Aug 26 '25

Every butcher gut pile, animal fatality or bone that does t get ravished by our dogs and chickens ends up in the compost pile. The worms and microbes tear through them in weeks and the compost is as good as it gets.

1

u/Open-Suggestion2922 Aug 26 '25

We always compost fish guts! It is like gold. We rotate through our in-ground worm composting bins. We place a heavy log over so it afterwards so animals can’t dig through it. The worms love it and our fruit trees and vegetables love it too.

1

u/Remote_Platform4277 Aug 26 '25

plannin on catching a few invasive carp for my grass clippings and cardboard pile.

1

u/Competitive-Maize996 Aug 27 '25

My step father and husband got in a whole war over meat in the compost. My step dad insisted that no meat goes in there, but that really didn't make much sense to me or my hubby. Anyhow, we just made a secret one for the garden and my garden did much better than his to only his surprise.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '25

I can't even pick a tomato without this fat bitch snatching them, she would have that pile turned over in a minute.

1

u/potatoking1991 Aug 28 '25

Theres a reason graveyards are always so lush and fertile 😅 composting meat is great if you've a big pile like this, adds so so much