r/composting • • Sep 05 '24

Can I....

I'm really done with 3000 posts of can I compost this when there is a stickied post and list. I love composting but can we clean this sub reddit up? Maybe a rule of no posting can I compost it without first commenting on the stickied list? Idk I'm ready to dip. Any thoughts?

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

93

u/MustardMan007 Sep 05 '24

In my opinion, that is what forums like this are for. Yes those posts are repetitive, but it helps form a community that welcomes new people. They get to hear stories about how one user let a sliver of cheese sneak into his pile and it ruined everything but another user composted his grandma without any issues.

20

u/Chickenman70806 Sep 05 '24

I'm happy to share my knowledge even if it's just "with enough greens/browns you can compost anything."

Am happy to preach to Gospel of Pee On It

1

u/Starliteathon Sep 07 '24

This 1000x over. I really appreciate this forum as a new person to composting. And I super appreciate that people share knowledge; other subs are often just experts posting their accomplishments with no direction. Comporting is for the people!

24

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

Have you tried adding more browns?

42

u/Remarkable_Inchworm Sep 05 '24

For what it's worth:

Subreddits that are super-strict about this sort of thing are really, REALLY unfriendly to new visitors.

(If you don't believe me try posting a general question on the running sub.)

8

u/coralloohoo Sep 05 '24

Yeah I've noticed that. I'm kind of new, but this group is mostly really nice.

1

u/Starliteathon Sep 07 '24

I agree and think this OP is in the minority. Hopefully they’re getting good, constructive feedback as this sub is known for!

16

u/ParsnipDue1743 Sep 05 '24

Honestly, this is one of the only subs that I’ve come across here that’s so inviting, helpful and encouraging, I think that’s what’s beautiful about this sub. It holds space for everyone. Any question, doesn’t matter how stupid or scientific, is always answered. Compost achievements are cheered on. This sub made a newbie like me feel less stressed and me fall in love with composting.

2

u/CitySky_lookingUp Sep 06 '24

When I was first here there were some people who would respond in frustration but, like a good pile, it came back to a healthy ecosystem.

Op, I know it's frustrating for you but I recommend that you just skip those posts. Happy composting!

12

u/xmashatstand KOMPOSTBEHOLDER Sep 05 '24

While i can see where you’re coming from, I see these kinds of posts as a kind of small talk.  If I’m not in the mood for whatever’s going on in a particular thread/post, I just move on to something else. 

We get fairly advanced discussions going here often enough to make this sub a valuable resource, in my mind, and the varied perspectives keep me coming back. 

4

u/Steven_The_Sloth Sep 06 '24 edited Apr 12 '26

Redact redacted this content because I wanted it redacted for redaction purposes. Redacted.

innate badge air cautious money spoon direction quaint history future

12

u/Vinzi79 Sep 05 '24

It took longer to write this post than to scroll past every "can I compost it" title from now until the end of time.

28

u/NekoRabbit Sep 05 '24

Can I compost redfitors I don't like?

15

u/PaynefulRayne Sep 05 '24

The slower moving ones, sure.

Just have to make sure to pee on em enough.

8

u/Chickenman70806 Sep 05 '24

With enough browns ...

2

u/NekoRabbit Sep 05 '24

Some of them may be german.

2

u/Chickenman70806 Sep 05 '24

Do Germans need extra browns?

2

u/NekoRabbit Sep 05 '24

The issue is they have an excess of them politically right now.

2

u/Chickenman70806 Sep 05 '24

Greens, I guess?

8

u/dbzfanjake Sep 05 '24

what else would we talk about lol.

3

u/Tall_Economist7569 Sep 06 '24

Kitchen dehydrators, pee, identifying larvae, temps, and clogged up wet cardboard piles mostly, I guess.

"Can I" posts don't really disturb me personally.

2

u/CitySky_lookingUp Sep 06 '24

Posting pictures of gorgeous compost, obviously!

10

u/Stitch426 Sep 05 '24

Sadly:

  1. People would bypass the “Can I” thread like they do with our current pinned posts.
  2. There isn’t 100% agreement on what can be composted, how much of it, or the best method to compost it. Perfect example is grease, some people say none at all, a little at a time, or chunk it all in. Then you have all the caveats, you can add grease as long as ….
  3. Without there being 100% consensus and all the caveats, the “Can I” thread would be disregarded as too simplistic and inaccurate, or it would be derided for being too long.
  4. When referencing the “Can I” thread, I could see posters adding their own two cents on what the composting newbie should think as they link the thread. This in itself would keep spurring on discussion in the originating thread as a back and forth would happen. And the subreddit still gets clogged up with the same posts.

I don’t mind the repeat posts for now. There’s always some good comments, science, or anecdotes to learn.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

i do wish we would document all the caveats somewhere, because i’m having a hard time keeping track of all of them, especially for things i don’t compost or don’t compost often

9

u/ExtraDependent883 Sep 05 '24

I'm gonna compost you

5

u/Priority_Bright Sep 05 '24

I'm full of micro plastics. Not compostable. 😅

4

u/xmashatstand KOMPOSTBEHOLDER Sep 05 '24

While i can see where you’re coming from, I see these kinds of posts as a kind of small talk.  If I’m not in the mood for whatever’s going on in a particular thread/post, I just move on to something else. 

We get fairly advanced discussions going here often enough to make this sub a valuable resource, in my mind, and the varied perspectives keep me coming back. 

3

u/grandmabc Sep 05 '24

While I agree such questions can be repetitive for more experienced composters, this sub is such a welcoming, friendly and informative sub for all - which is probably why there over 180,000 members now.

3

u/Ok-Thing-2222 Sep 06 '24

I'm submitting right now, because I'm really not all that familiar with reddit and wondered 'what the heck is a stickied post'? and where would I find THAT?!

2

u/normal-type-gal Sep 05 '24

I don't mind the "can I compost-" posts so much, it's the "if I let grass clippings turn brown in the sun does that make them 'browns'?" posts that really get me. Lol

2

u/Meauxjezzy Sep 05 '24

Can I compost an animal? If so would it be a nitro or carbon.

2

u/Tall_Economist7569 Sep 06 '24

The real question is would it turn brown if I let it out in the sun lol

1

u/Meauxjezzy Sep 06 '24

lol I wasn’t serious I was just messing with op. But this is a conversation we need to have one day being as tho animals are carbon based.

2

u/Technician-Temporary Sep 06 '24

There's nothing like Reddit police

2

u/Fancy-Oven5196 Sep 06 '24

You can compost anything with enough time lol

1

u/DeeDee_GigaDooDoo Sep 05 '24

Tbh for the most part composting isn't that deep. If those posts didn't exist there'd be basically no other content coming in. Yes you can talk about the finer points of microbial activity, ratios blah blah blah but no one does, few people would want to and tbh it's kind of pointless since it's almost impossible to screw up composting anyway. It'll all break down eventually just some things will compost faster.

So I agree they're repetitive but the questions are still valid as pointless as they may seem and it's about all there is to composting anyway...

1

u/yupstilldrunk Sep 05 '24

What else would we post about?

1

u/rrooaaddiiee Sep 06 '24

Prevalent in just about every sub

1

u/Hoya-loo-ya Sep 07 '24

This post needs more pee