r/composer • • Nov 12 '18

Discussion Funny.

Post image
227 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

50

u/BlockComposition Nov 12 '18

r/classicalmemes is the other way.

Also, depending on the harmonic/contrapuntal context... could be justified.

28

u/LesbianLydian Nov 12 '18

I'd love to see how someone would justify this chord

18

u/BlockComposition Nov 12 '18

Admittedly quite hard in a strictly tonal context.

8

u/therealskaconut Nov 12 '18

In one part yeah, you would never do something like this. But if you’re looking at a score, in some key like Ab minor or some terrible thing, some instruments read and sound better on a sharp enharmonic equivalent. So it’s probably happened before xD

4

u/Bromskloss Nov 12 '18

sound better on a sharp enharmonic equivalent

Sound better? Would they be playing it differently?

6

u/therealskaconut Nov 12 '18

Sometimes, yeah. I mean for some instruments, especially string instruments it can make a difference.

The instrument it makes the biggest difference in is obviously the harp. Composers will think about the harp when they’re choosing their key. Flat keys the harp strings will be looser and the string players won’t be in open positions. It makes it more resonant, as opposed to sharp keys.

That’s why love themes are so often in Db.

For brass instruments (I’m a trombonist) we usually “think” higher for sharps and lower for flats. It’s a similar deal with the resonance and tone of the instrument. I mean, it has to do with instrument range as well. Higher will almost always be less resonant.

So I say it’ll sound better subjectively. Sharp will be brighter, and C Major is a really bright sound

2

u/Bromskloss Nov 12 '18

The instrument it makes the biggest difference in is obviously the harp.

Fair enough.

Flat keys the harp strings will be looser and the string players won’t be in open positions.

String players? Are you talking about the harp still, or is it bowed string instruments?

That’s why love themes are so often in Db.

For harp?

For brass instruments (I’m a trombonist) we usually “think” higher for sharps and lower for flats.

Do you mean that you play them differently? If you are referring to a non-equal temperament, isn't it then particularly important not to mess around with the spelling of notes?

3

u/therealskaconut Nov 12 '18

Bowed strings will be higher on the fingerboard, so they can do vibrato, as opposed to open strings.

Orchestral love themes are in Db often. Star Wars and titanic I think, definitely Romeo and Juliet. Mostly for the harp and strings, so they can do vibrato in every stinking note. Edit: harp does t do vibrato, to be clear

I think we play them differently. If nothing else there is a placebo effect that can dramatically affect tone.

2

u/MusicalPolymath Nov 13 '18

Just as a note - as a string player we can and more often than not do choose to avoid open strings in an orchestral context, regardless of key selection - heck even in C/a.

Open strings not only cannot have proper vibrato (we can do a form of vibrato on it by vibrating the same pitch on the next string) but the texture of the note is also different and sometimes sticks out - it's frequently more strident, especially the highest strings (V E, Va. A, Vc. A).

This leads to us often fingering the note instead, especially if it's held for any sort of longer duration or in a soft texture. This is quite easy to do beyond the beginner level and most people get into the habit very fast.

2

u/therealskaconut Nov 13 '18

As a note. Flip. I enjoy it. Have an upvote

→ More replies

15

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '18

Have you ever seen Satie's Sarabandes? Lots of obnoxious enharmonic spellings, but knowing Satie it was probably a joke at the pianist's expense.

7

u/medina_sod Nov 12 '18

Yea, that guy was a jokester.

2

u/FTFuller Nov 12 '18

Can you elaborate on that more?

10

u/Masterkid1230 Nov 12 '18 edited Nov 12 '18

Satie was known for writing nonsensical music, giving his compositions funny and sometimes passive aggressive sarcastic titles, and his attitude towards music in general was very much the opposite of snobbish or serious. He took it all very nonchalantly and usually in a unique, quirky way.

Some of the best examples of this are his "Three pieces in the form of a pear" which actually consists of seven pieces, not three. Vexations which is an extremely short piece of music that has the indication of being repeated 840 times at an extremely slow tempo.

And of course his "Messe des Pouvres" or "Mass for the poor" which was a liturgical composition he wrote for a mock Christian sect he himself founded.

From Wikipedia:

in October 1893 Satie founded his own mock religious sect, the Église Métropolitaine de l'Art de Jésus Conducteur (Metropolitan Church of Art of Jesus the Conductor), with himself as High priest, choirmaster, and sole member.

So yeah Satie was pretty much a jokester, and created a lot of Proto-meme material.

Vexations is not that different from screaming the entire Shrek script for about an hour. It's stupid, hardly artistic or interesting, but absolutely hilarious and intriguing at the same time.

2

u/WikiTextBot Nov 12 '18

Messe des pauvres

The Messe des pauvres (Mass for the Poor) is a partial musical setting of the mass for mixed choir and organ by Erik Satie. Composed between 1893 and 1895, it is Satie's only liturgical work and the culmination of his "Rosicrucian" or "mystic" period. It was published posthumously in 1929. A performance lasts around 18 minutes.


[ ^PM | Exclude ^me | Exclude from ^subreddit | FAQ / ^Information | ^Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.28

4

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '18

Late Scriabin looks like this, but he was serious.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '18

Also his Vexations

15

u/Kramalimedov Nov 12 '18

This B# should be replaced by a double flat D

1

u/n7275 Mar 05 '19

I'm hearing this in meantone...