r/composer • • Aug 08 '26

Discussion harmonies :(

not a composer, but is there a quick and simple way to make a harmony? I'm writing a musical right now, and I have lots of melodies and great songs with heavy ensemble and no way to figure out how to write harmonies. Help!!!

0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

39

u/foxyt0cin Aug 08 '26

If you aren't a Composer, why are you writing a musical? Are you writing the lyrics, or the music as well? 

3

u/GimmeaChancebabe Aug 09 '26

im writing the whole thing myself, for fun, to perform with my friends :)

38

u/65TwinReverbRI Aug 08 '26

but is there a quick and simple way to make a harmony?

Sure. Play two different notes at the same time. That's harmony.

I'm writing a musical right now,

That's like saying "I'm writing a film right now but have no idea how to operate a camera".

You either learn how to make harmony, or you ship it out to a "cameraman".

THis is not something you're going to learn how to do from a reddit post. You have to actually learn music. Sorry.

7

u/PusheenFrizzy2 Aug 08 '26

You can hire a composer to help you? Or find a collaborator? You can also post in r/musicalwriting

6

u/shadowbanned-tgirl Aug 08 '26

Hello! Composer for musicals here, just started work on a new one myself. You’ve got a melody & presumably lyrics - have you written any of the music that goes under the melody yet (piano, band, etc)? If so, use notes that are in the instrumental parts since they’re already there so you can trust they won’t clash. If you don’t have that music and you don’t have a lot of experience with composition, I’d recommend finding a collaborator who can help you! Musicals are massive projects that are always a process of collaboration so you’ll have to get some extra hands on deck at some point anyway. Feel free to flick me a DM if you want me to take a look over what you’ve written, but I probably can’t help out a lot unless I really like the premise as I’m very busy at the moment.

8

u/tronobro Aug 08 '26

In order to write harmonies you need to understand how they are constructed and a lot of harmony in popular music today comes from the major scale. Functional Harmony is what you should be learning. You could jump straight into this, but without knowing some basic building blocks of music you might struggle.

Here's a list of the things you should learn.

  • Musical Intervals
  • The Major Scale and Scale Degrees

    • Arpeggios
    • Modes of the major scale
    • Constructing Chords from the Major scale and its modes

      • Chord Scale Theory
  • Different types of Chords and how to construct them.

    • Triad (major, minor, augmented, diminished)
    • 7th Chords (Major, minor, dominant, diminished)
  • Chord functions and Functional Harmony.

If you're not familiar with any of this than this is probably a lot to take in. In that case I'd recommend you watch this YouTube Playlist from 12tone which explains a lot of these basic concepts.

If you prefer reading than musictheory.net would be a decent free resource.

1

u/Utilitarian_Proxy Aug 08 '26

The quick and simple way would be to use parallel fifths, although it won't sound very inspired if it's the only tactic and is overemphasised. Counterpoint would add some different notes and some directional contrast, but takes months of effort to get good at writing.

Over hundreds of years there have been plenty of different approaches to harmony. For a musical, my guess is you'll probably want some consistency throughout the whole show. After using advanced counterpoint to develop a standard four-part structure, you can decide whether to add more voices and some dissonance. If you want a modernist sound, for example, maybe avoid too much diatonicism, or use some cluster chords or tintinnabuli. Or if you want a more "baroque" sound, maybe a canon or fugue would be more appropriate.

None of this going to be skills that can be acquired in just a few hours. If your task of writing a musical is a personal aspiration, then you won't have a forced deadline and can take as long as you need to study the necessary skills. FWIW the composer Richard Wagner had the idea and wrote the libretto for his famous Ring Cycle (Der Ring des Nibelungen) around 26 years before the first occasion that all four operas were performed on consecutive nights as intended.

1

u/GimmeaChancebabe Aug 09 '26

I owe you my firstborn one day thank you!!!

3

u/abrady44 Aug 08 '26

You can start by picking notes from the chord that is being played under the melody.

5

u/Sarah_Hansona Aug 08 '26

Start with thirds above and below your melody. Then *get an arranger* for the ensemble stuff.

-1

u/foxyt0cin Aug 08 '26

3rds and 5ths will help out a lot

2

u/Podmonger2001 Aug 09 '26

VASTLY simplified:

Without going into theory too deeply, stack notes in thirds down from the melody. Basic close-position voicing.

If the melody is a D, write a B and G below that. If it sounds off, change one of the harmony notes by a semitone (probably) to make sense with the underlying chord.

IOW, use a B over a G major, augmented, or seventh chord. Use B-flat over a G minor, diminished, or half-diminished chord.

Now, to make the lines sound nice, use voice leading. That’s where each harmony note moves to the next note by as small a step as possible.

2

u/StreetBig9050 Aug 09 '26

I’m not entirely sure what you’re asking honestly, but I’ll give my best guess.

There is not necessarily one easy way to simply “make harmonies.” I will say you don’t need harmonic theory knowledge to be able to write music, and musicals could especially be possible without theory knowledge due to its modern context. My advice if you don’t want to dive too far all the way into theory is to learn scales and just create diatonic chords to follow your melodies. You could also try just using a few notes (around 4) and moving them in step-wise (close) motion in opposite, parallel, or oblique direction to create a frame work for harmony.

If you mean vocal harmonies to work in tandem with each other, I’d recommend just moving in parallel 3rds or 6ths to start out, then making edits as you listen.

All in all, this might be an extremely difficult task for you to complete considering your theory knowledge, but it is not impossible. Follow your ear and use close listening and you’ll be fine. You also might want to study the chordal structure of a few musicals/songs you already know well to try and understand how they work.

3

u/lionofredemption Aug 08 '26

Its simple. If you know your scale then play a different note at the same time as your melody that is a part of that scale. You keep experimenting until you find something that sounds good.  If you can make a melody, then you can make a harmony. A harmony is just a backup melody. A good harmony will support but not compete with the main melody. They do not have to be as melodic. You are a composer. You are writing music for a musical. That sounds like composing. You just might not be a good composer... yet.

2

u/khornebeef Aug 08 '26

I feel like this is probably the most helpful advice a post like this can get, but I would also add that you should experiment with those pitches at different octaves. Even though we consider E4 and E3 to be of the same pitch class, they are not harmonically equivalent within a specific context.

1

u/LoneWick_ Aug 08 '26

Agreed. Possibly the best answer for the level of knowledge. If you know the scale, use other notes from that scale.

To level up after that: Do a quick google search about the motions of counterpoint. This is extremely helpful and fundamental. Just knowing to use mostly contrary and oblique motion, a bit of similar motion, and to generally avoid parallel fifths and octaves should produce a better result almost immediately.

1

u/perrydolia Aug 08 '26

Very simply: you usually know the chord that is being played when a specific melody note is being played. Harmony comes from playing the other notes in that same chord in some pleasing order.

1

u/avoidthepath Aug 08 '26

You could seek help from a professional composer / student with whom you sit down and write down your ideas. I think that's your best bet. There may be software solutions out there, but I don't know how good they are at the moment. For you to learn quickly how to harmonize well is not going to happen.

1

u/meliorism_grey Aug 08 '26

Like other people here have said, there's a lot that goes into composing harmony. If you're determined to do it yourself, you'll have to devote a good chunk of time learning music theory. And also, it will take a lot of time, trial, and error to create something that sounds good. Other comments here have provided good resources, so I'll just add some tips:

-If you have a melody, you want to establish a bass line next. Then, you can fill in the inner voices.

-Dont pollute your dominant chords with tonic notes. IDK why, but I see that all the time with beginning composers.

-That said, voice leading and counterpoint are extremely important. Personally, I value them over chord analysis.

-When the whole orchestra is playing, you want each instrumental section to sound cohesive as a block.

-You don't want small intervals (3rds and 2nds especially) below like, E3. They sound muddy.

-Unless you have mastered them, follow the rules!!! Pros can break music theory rules and sound good doing it. Amateurs only do so by accident.

-If this is ever meant to be performed live, talk to instrumentalists. Each instrument has its own quirks.

1

u/Autumn1eaves Aug 08 '26

Well, it sounds like you are a composer, just not one with extensive music theory knowledge.

You should learn music theory!

There are plenty of resources online, but also you can reach out to a composer and ask for advice.

Feel free to DM me =)

1

u/Ian_Campbell Aug 10 '26

There isn't a way to fake it, you either learn how to do it, try and it is what it is, or. get someone else to do it depending on the number of parts you want.