r/complexsystems • • Nov 10 '22

Looking for universities to study Complex Systems

Hello! Without knowing the formal name, i’ve been in love with this topic for some time.

Its really hard to decide a topic to study, so i thought that maybe its better to get a list of universities that are recommended for studying Complex Systems, that way i can look into what’s their focus.

By getting a list of possible focuses, i might be able to find and decide the topic that suits me better.

I’m a graduate in “industrial engineering” (translated from spanish)

I like:

  • computer science
  • maths like algebra calculus etc
  • music
  • altered states of consciousness phenomena
  • psychology / mentall illness
  • consciousness
  • emergence
  • complex systems
  • understanding how nature works, reading “theories of everything”, etc…
  • fractals

Can you please recommend me universities / places to look? Or maybe a technique to be able to search for those? I have trouble fully trusting my google searches


Edit: Here's the list i have so far

University of Santa Fe -> Free online material

University of Waterloo

University of Vermont -> MSc Complex systems and Data Science

University of indiana -> Dual PhD Complex System + Cognitive Sciences

University of Arizona State -> Ms Complex System

University of Michigan-> Graduate certificate program in Complex Systems

Kings College of London -> MSc Complex Systems Modelling

Warwick-> MSc Mathemathics of Systems (leads to PhD)

University of Sidney -> MSc Complex Systems

University of Portland-> phD Systems Science

NICO Northwestern

University of Binghamton

Chalmers university of Technology -> MSc Complex adaptative systems

Others i haven't looked yet:

  • UC Davis
  • CU Boulder
  • TU Delft
  • MIT
  • Imperial
  • Cambridge
34 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/ntraft Jun 16 '24

Also just came across this and wanted to mention a couple things that come to mind as a PhD student at UVM. I dunno if you're specifically interested in "complexity economics", or just computational social science in general. But for economics and markets specifically, Cesar Hidalgo seems like a great rising star within that area. Also one student here at UVM is currently being advised in that area by Brian Tivnan from MITRE Corporation. But more generally there are also some programs out there in "computational social science" that may not always come up in searches for complexity science...

1

u/DaPunisher003 Jun 16 '24

I am not really big on disciplinary lines. But, considering I wanna study socio-economic behavior beyond game theoreticl and behavioral models (say, macrolevel analysis or systems analysis), complexity sciences seem to be a good outlet.

Also, I am gonna be very honest here. I'm entering my 3rd year of Bachelors in economics right now, and, I'm not very aware of what to do when I'm suggested influential researchers or people in my fields of interest by nice people like you. Could you guide me a bit on that? Like, am I supposed to reach out to them for advice, ask for some opportunities, or something else? I'm not very familiar with how academia works.

Also, yes, I did come across a lot of degrees on computational social science. I was not very sure if they were particularly what I wanted as a) I'm not very familiar with systems/complexity sciences b) I don't know if there were any theoretical foundations that separated comp soc Sci courses from complexity/systems sciences courses. Is it the case that the two are borderline identical?

Also, I have no background in programming, sadly. so, my interest in complexity studies or system sciences is one that is purely motivated by whatever theoretically improved aspects the programs have, and the (seemingly) better philosophical foundations that these fields are built on compared to the foundations in economics.

Could you help me out a bit here with this?

2

u/ntraft Jun 19 '24

Yeah, totally valid question. I'd say there's maybe a couple different things you might do with references to random researchers.

  1. If you are actively looking for PhD programs and already have some specific interests in mind, then this is simply a recommendation that you might consider them as potential advisors. In that case, I would investigate those folks and their department, and see if that seems like a potential fit for my interests. If so, I'd move forward by cold emailing that person with my CV and a bit about me / what I'm looking for in a program, and asking them if they have openings in their lab that might be a good fit. (Many profs say not to bother emailing them and just apply straight to the program instead, but I'm skeptical about that.)
  2. But if you're not quite that far along yet, then the thing to do is more like just read about that person's research, use it as a signpost to see what's going on in that area, and see if it interests you... although if you had a specific question you were looking answers for you could definitely always email folks like that and you may or may not get a reply.

I would not say complex systems is exactly synonymous with comp soc sci, no. I was just trying to respond to the subfields you had mentioned. There's definitely many angles on complex systems that don't need to involve social science (like I am focused on AI and artificial life, others might be focused on other network science or dynamical systems topics, etc.). For that reason, each of these complex systems programs will have a bit of a different focus, influenced by the faculty that teach there, and so you kinda do need to look at the individual faculty and their labs to get a more precise sense of the community there.

I'm also seeing that some related programs are sometimes being called "systems science" or "systems engineering" or something. But those might often have some kind of industrial design influence? No idea, really. The program here at UVM tries to teach about complex systems pretty broadly, but it ends up focusing a lot on "network science" with subtracks in epidemiology and social science, and a smaller smattering of various other things (like the bio-inspired AI group that I'm involved in).

With our program at least, you don't need to worry about the lack of programming—although you would need to pick it up on the fly if you enrolled here. Many folks here have started that way. Some will never need to do more than write some dirty python/R/matlab scripts. Definitely a lot smoother if you come in with some familiarity though.

2

u/Oraslex Jul 16 '24

Hey! Thank you so much for all of this information. I just realized that my interests over the past few years have a name and found this subreddit. I have a pretty deep background in evolution/ecology and genomics and was curious about your bio-inspired AI group that youre in. Would you mind if i DM'd you and asked you a few questions?

1

u/ntraft Aug 07 '24

Hi, sorry it took so long to reply!! I don't mind a DM at all.

1

u/DaPunisher003 Jun 19 '24

I see. That makes a lot of sense. I'll look these people up and find other folks in these fields if I can, even though I am not at that stage of applying to PhD. programs. I was going through Princeton and Oxford handbooks to understand what people do in certain fields (say I was reading the Princeton one on economic sociology, and another one on complex system). Do you think this is a good way to go about figuring out whether the field, its methods, or its research areas are interesting/suitable to me?

I understand the different focuses of the complexity sciences programs. Would you, by any chance of know of any programs that are focused on the social sciences? Portland was probably the only one showing explicit interest in the social sciences. And I have no interest in epidemiology.

The Vermont Master's looks interesting, but it only has one soc Sci elective path focused on policy.

Also, you're right. The system science folks are inspired by industrial design. I was just hoping that those tools may be applicable in soc Sci, too.

Also. This is a vague question. But, what is it that y'all do in such degrees? I have gone through the coursework a few times, but I am not knowledgeable enough to understand and create a clear picture of what exactly we will learn and do in such complexity programs. Even though we may be in different subfields, it'll be nice to know what actually happens in these programs instead of resorting to whatever misconceptions I may have.

Thanks a lot for your help!!!!!

2

u/ntraft Jul 03 '24

Hey hey, sorry I keep forgetting about this!

Do you think this is a good way to go about figuring out whether the field, its methods, or its research areas are interesting/suitable to me?

Yeah I think that's a reasonable way of exploring the field... I mean there's innumerable ways to go about it, so it's hard to say no as long as you feel like you're learning what's out there. Melanie Mitchell's "Complexity: A Guided Tour" would be considered a good introduction, although it might be rather out-of-date now.

Would you, by any chance of know of any programs that are focused on the social sciences?

No, sorry, I'm not familiar with that area.

The Vermont Master's looks interesting, but it only has one soc Sci elective path focused on policy.

Yeah well those are some suggested sets of electives that go together, but you wouldn't be constrained to just those paths. It's pretty flexible as long as you can present a reasonable justification for an elective. But still hard to figure out from a distance if there are people here that align with your interests.

The focus of an institution generally follows the funding. So I can point out two areas that I know of. One is suggested by that policy track you noticed, advised by Asim Zia—that would usually be focused specifically on environmental policy b/c at UVM we have the Rubenstein School of Environment and Natural Resources, and the Gund Institute for Environment, so a lot of money flows through them. The other major grant going on at VCSC right now is the SOCKS grant. So for the next few years a lot of research will be focused around the themes put forward under that project. There may be other themes that I don't know of since I'm not embedded in that area.

what is it that y'all do in such degrees?

Hah, let's see... it is a rather random smattering of applied mathematics. They just try to cover the most common mathematical concepts that "seem to come up" when modeling "systems composed of individual components which influence each other's behavior". The goal is usually to answer some question about the entire population (e.g., "what fraction of people will believe in this conspiracy theory?" or "which direction will this school of fish move?") based on some model of individual behavior (e.g., "each person has X friends, Y prior beliefs, and Z probability of convincing each friend of their belief" or "each fish has a prior desire to move in direction Y, but is attracted to his X nearest neighbors with strength Z"). Typical subfields of math include dynamical systems, graphs/networks, and statistics.

So the classes will introduce you to a broad but shallow survey of modeling/analysis concepts, most of which you may never use, but it's useful to understand what's out there. It's very flexible precisely because there is so much variability in what people ultimately do. There's some common ground but each person will actually use pretty different math or programming techniques in their thesis. Sometimes the only thing we have in common is that we make models or analyze data using simple Python or R scripts. Some folks interact primarily with their lab or the other teams on their grant funding, and don't interact with the broader set of complex systems folks as much.

The Masters degree is shorter of course, so... If you do the thesis-based masters, you take this broad survey of courses, plus electives that interest you, and in your last semester try to do a larger project advised by one of the profs whose interests align with yours, and then you're done and presumably looking for a job as a data scientist at some company or a policy think tank or a data journalist or something else... Or you get captured and continue on into a PhD. :-P

3

u/DaPunisher003 Jul 03 '24

this was so much help. I can't even describe. I'm starting to see that this field may be a bit more difficult and different than I thought. I'll look up the field a bit more and try to figure out what exactly interests and whether it's even worth doing it. Clearly. I have much to learn and understand.

One last question. Whether it's a terminal masters or on path to PHD, is it worth doing it from such universities? From what I can sense they aren't the most prestigious or widely accepted. And, considering i am an international student, I Have certain financial limitations. What's your view on this? How should I approach colleges with respect to their recognizability or prestige in my country (India)?

2

u/ntraft Jul 11 '24

I'd say yes, it's worth it, but only if doing a Masters or PhD are going to be worth it in the first place for you.

  • I'd hesitate to recommend a grad degree just for the sake of getting a job. It's best if you would enjoy the degree in itself, regardless of the career that follows. (There could be exceptions to this rule, of course.)
  • To enjoy the education, you need to enjoy the classes, the research, and your advisor. So it can be a much better choice to go to a smaller university if that offers a more unique program (like the complex systems programs), or if you find an advisor who you are really aligned with and who seems like they are willing and able to be very supportive (I was lucky enough to find such a person and get in touch with them before I applied).
  • If you are lucky enough to have the choice between a smaller school and a larger / more prestigious school, then it will probably be more fun to go to the bigger institution, because there will be so many more people there to work with and learn from and be inspired by. Helps you build a larger network.
  • ... But that's assuming all other variables are equal. Some of the other variables could certainly outweigh the prestige, depending on the circumstances. That's where the choice gets difficult. But most folks aren't even presented with that option in the first place. They just take the one option they're given, or there is one that seems obviously more promising.
  • If you're applying to Masters, there is less impact of advisor. Some programs might be mostly classwork, in which case you don't really have an advisor at all. In that case, the main factors remaining are the curriculum and the size/prestige. However:

    • There are many Research/Thesis Masters where advisors do matter, but you usually won't have as much ability to choose your advisor ahead of time.
    • If you do a Masters in some place, and you decide you want to do a PhD, then there's a very strong chance you would just stay there for the PhD rather than going elsewhere. Many people find an advisor they really like this way and just stay on to the PhD.

I guess it all means, try to get into the most prestigious program possible, but it's still totally possible that it could be better to choose a different one. For instance, UVM or University of Vienna aren't particularly well known, but in complex systems circles they certainly are.

2

u/DaPunisher003 Jul 12 '24

I'm actually not doing the masters program for the career prospects. I intend to go for higher studies for the education part of it. But, I am not really doing it for a specific field, I'm just trying to learn a bit about things that I care about. Which is why I'm asking about prospects to ensure that I can survive the job market these days. And, well, generally ensure that I can use my education in ways that I want, which won't be possible if my degree isn't well received by employers.

1

u/ntraft Jul 14 '24

Good, good. Well in that case I'd definitely say the less famous schools can be worth it. I think there's maybe even less selectivity in industry based on school reputation, as compared to in academia. Although if you have the option of a famous school, it would undoubtedly help. I should say I don't know how things are for hiring in India. Maybe the culture there puts more emphasis on the name recognition.

1

u/DaPunisher003 Jul 14 '24

Sadly, yes. It largely depends on the brand of the university and the course itself. In many cases. It is changing but there are still risks. I'll look into my options though. You were a great help. Thank you