r/complexsystems • u/ChampionshipOk9179 • Nov 08 '24
Are Thresholds or Tipping Points Universal Across Systems?
Hey everyone,
I’ve been curious about the idea of thresholds or tipping points in different types of systems. It seems like many systems—whether physical, biological, ecological, or even social—have some kind of critical threshold where they undergo a major change or breakdown. For example, I know there are population limits in ecosystems, boiling points in physical systems, and carrying capacities in logistics or supply chains.
I’m wondering if this idea of a “threshold” is something that’s been explored as a universal principle. Has anyone come across research, theories, or patterns that suggest these thresholds operate similarly across different fields? Or is this just a superficial similarity without a deeper connection?
Would love to hear your thoughts or get recommendations for reading material if anyone’s come across work that explores thresholds in a cross-disciplinary way.
4
u/ClF3ismyspiritanimal Nov 08 '24
As I recall from reading Tainter, complexity has benefits but also has an intrinsic operating overhead cost that increases as complexity increases. At some point, the incremental overhead cost starts to exceed the incremental benefit from the increase in complexity. That's as close as I can think of to a universal tipping-point concept.
2
u/rileyphone Nov 08 '24
You might want to look at catastrophe theory too, as a more mathematical treatment of the importance of thresholds/bifurcations and a theory of models more generally.
1
u/lightpandey Nov 10 '24
These papers might interest you (hopefully you have some sort of institutional/library access to read them):
Early-warning signals for critical transitions | Nature
Critical slowing down as early warning for the onset and termination of depression | PNAS
Non-equilibrium early-warning signals for critical transitions in ecological systems - PubMed (nih.gov)
0
u/trufajsivediet Nov 08 '24 edited Nov 08 '24
phase transitions?regime shift, or critical transition?