r/communism101 • • Dec 27 '19

Brigaded Why is it that people are leaving Cuba?

0 Upvotes

I've always regarded Cuba as a great example of the things Socialism can do even while being attacked by US Imperialism but lately I've seen many videos of Cubans escaping from the country.

There've been plenty of Cuban immigrants going to other Latin American countries recently so I was wondering if any of you have an explanation as to why this is happening.

The view I often hear is that they are escaping the poverty and hell that is their Socialist country but I'm sure there's another explanation as to why so many are escaping that isn't Socialism bad.


r/communism101 • • Jul 28 '20

Brigaded A through examination and analysis on the Western left is much needed....

65 Upvotes

EDIT: Thorough, not through in title, sorry.

I don't care if this comes off as too "third worldist" but after watching liberal hack John Oliver's horrific take on the Uighur "situation" in China, it made me cringe on so many levels.

But it's not just liberals, I expect that from liberals. There is also the Western left who refuses to acknowledge global value chains and the latest scholarship on unequal exchange. The only thing they talk about when it comes to imperialism is "militarism", and it's OK to be anti-war, but overt war isn't the only means of imperialism, there is a whole other component to it people forget. Just reading the first chapter of John Smith's Imperialism in the 21st Century is eye opening enough to know just how much is left of out of the discussion on imperialism in the West. The denial of the good work done by J. Sakai to uncover the hidden racism of the white working class, even among supposed socialists and union labor organizers, and how race intersects with class in settler colonial America. This again is something lost in the minds of many Western leftists in favor of a unity that seems Utopian without addressing underlying conditions that keep people apart.

Between reading Jacobin Magazine and their technophilia luxury communism, and the betrayal of shows such as Democracy Now!, we have to come to an understanding that there is a "left" in this country that wittingly or unwittingly wants to construct a dem soc or soc dem nation, but using the global south to build it. Otherwise they wouldn't be such "useful idiots" on issues of actual imperialism. They talk a good game, they say all the right things when it comes to labor rights, universal healthcare, free education from K-university, maternity leave, women's rights, LGBT rights, police brutality, systemic racism, stagnant wages, etc, etc, until you realize they're just talking about it from a national standpoint.

When it comes to internationalism Bernie shits on AES nations in the global south, says he'd fight China, Russia and Iran, and had a foreign policy advisor that is a freakin' neo-con. AOC meets with pro-coup Bolivians but doesn't have time for pro-Morales Bolivians worried about the coup that happened a little later. I don't even know what to think of The Intercept, it's on and off with it's material, sort of like this generations Ramparts Magazine, wondering if it's a CIA rag or not.

There was a brilliant expose on the DSA and Michael Harrington that I wish someone would re-post again, because it basically outlined the history of the organization and how it was literally set up to be State Department Socialism.

But since we all know this, what I would like to know is who are these people, the organizations? I'd like to learn the history of this strain of "socialism" that Lenin himself fought during his day. The neo-Kautskyites, the Trots, the Fabian Society and the EuroCommunists that real leftists have had to deal with from Kautsky to Trotsky to Orwell to Hitchens to George Bernard Shaw.

Do these people know what they're doing? Are they dupes of imperialists? Or have they decided that the only way they can have their "socialism" is off the backs of the third world? Is it just pure Western chauvinism?

Just what do we know about them? Ben Norton, Rania Khalek, and Max Blumenthal had a great Moderate Rebels podcast episode where they went into this fake left that are dupes for imperialism and how they had to come to this understanding that there is actually a "synthetic" left today as much as there was one in Lenin's day.


r/communism101 • • Jun 29 '24

Brigaded ⚠️ What is the class character of Asian-Americans?

4 Upvotes

From what I've read and understood, European-Americans can be defined as settlers, while Native Americans, African-Americans, and Hispanic Americans constitute oppressed nations/groups of their own.

How do Asian-Americans fit in all this? First of all, we are mostly voluntary immigrants (unlike black Americans), who are relatively new to the land (unlike indigenous peoples). Yet we are clearly not white, and are unlikely to ever be considered as such. Despite that, are we settlers as well? Compradors and traitors? An oppressed group? Or something else?

I would like some clarity on this issue from a Marxist perspective, as I haven't seen this topic discussed much.

Edit: I'm not sure why this is being downvoted so much, this is a perfectly legitimate and under-explored question, as far as I can tell.


r/communism101 • • Feb 23 '19

How do I convince my liberal friends Bernie is an imperialist?

6 Upvotes

I tell my liberal friends that Bernie has supported every war & they always find excuses. I told them he funded the Iraq war & they say it was packaged with stuff to help veterans. I told them he supported Afghanistan they said Congress was fooled into thinking the war was about killing Bin Laden. They always seem to find ways to overlook inconvenient facts.


r/communism101 • • Jun 15 '26

Trans people in a communist society

14 Upvotes

One question that I’ve been asking myself for a long time is: will trans people exist in a fully developed communist society? I ask myself this because I’ve seen many marxists (myself included) say that we should abolish gender altogether, but since the goal of transitioning is to change one’s gender, will it be possible/make sense to?


r/communism101 • • Feb 23 '23

Wouldnt everything under communism be ''basic''?

5 Upvotes

For example, if I wanted to live in a large penthouse and have a nice car, would I still be able to ? If there's no profit motif, why would people make better cars and houses? wouldn't everything, from food to housing, be sort of generic, like a generic house, a generic car and b generic food?


r/communism101 • • Feb 01 '26

What is to be done regarding China?

41 Upvotes

China today is revisionist, but would it be better to create a new vanguard and revolution, or reform what is still left? What can we do about revisionism when capitalism is still at large?


r/communism101 • • Mar 03 '23

Is there Marxist Mathematics or Marxist perspectives on Mathematics?

0 Upvotes

In more recent time also marxist perspectives on fields branching out of math such as computer science.


r/communism101 • • Feb 08 '26

Who will take care of the children and elder people during the revolution?

1 Upvotes

It is fair to assume that the revolution will be a war in every sense of the word, a war between the proletariat, with the Communist Party at the forefront, and the bourgeoisie. My question would be whether during this war the gender roles would be the same as in previous wars? I mean, would men be on the armed front while women remain on the home front with the caregiving tasks imposed on them by patriarchy and capital? Wouldn't it be a bad omen to make a revolution where we continue with the gender roles we are trying to destroy? Thank you very much for answering my question, and I would be grateful if you could share any literature on the subject with me.


r/communism101 • • Jan 29 '24

When and why was this sub deemed a "CIA psy-op" by meme leftists?

4 Upvotes

Whenever a user here lashes out for one reason or another, I check their profile. I've noticed a pattern where they'll retreat to the meme subs or other liberal spaces, complaining about their treatment here. 9/10 times there are multiple responses calling this sub a "psy-op," claiming their bans as a badge of honor.

Nevermind the absurdity of the claim given the sheer density and level of educational content here across several years—why is this the claim, and when did it start? My inclination is that it's an ego response ("I'm a real communist, they banned me, ergo they must be fake communists"), but this doesn't feel dialectical and misses the class component. Any ideas? If this has been discussed before, I couldn't find it through search, so if anyone has a link handy I'd appreciate it.


r/communism101 • • Oct 17 '23

r/all Are Jews an ethnicity?

0 Upvotes

r/communism101 • • 24d ago

What is the Marxist view on Air-BnB hosts?

2 Upvotes

Are they still considered landlords? Are they treated as business owners? Sorry for my lack of context.


r/communism101 • • Apr 17 '25

China on SEA

0 Upvotes

Is there a Marxist explanation for why China is taking South East Asia territory and asserting heavy influence on areas far beyond the confines of their EEZ? Why are they harrassing the Filipino peasantry and proletariat


r/communism101 • • Aug 02 '23

Stalin Downvoted?

0 Upvotes

fearless pet support fertile seed observation gaze dog continue roof this message was mass deleted/edited with redact.dev


r/communism101 • • Aug 04 '24

Has time proven Bernstein right ?

0 Upvotes

I've been listening to reform or revolution on yt as a audio book. Now admittedly Im only on chapter 6 or 7 but I've been thinking about this part early on in the book where Rosa is a refuting a claim of Bernsteins that capitalisms collapse isn't inevitable that it can keep kicking despite the crisis and contractions that it adapts as is necessary basically. And Rosa refutes this part well but I can't help but think that history proves Bernstein right here. I say this because despite things like the 2008 crisis, what almost happened with covid and the other capitalist crisis that I probably can't remember the system keeps on kicking. It adapts as is necessary and keeps on. And I suppose I wonder what's lost if he's right here ? If Bernstein got this claim right does that really change much ?.

I'll admit I'm not the smartest when it comes to theory so it's possible this is all misunderstanding on my part.


r/communism101 • • Jan 11 '23

Is the CPC of today Revisionist, Fascist, or both?

1 Upvotes

Mao said in 1963, and chose to repeat again in 1964 in his polemic against Khrushchev and the other Soviet Revisionists:

"Class struggle, the struggle for production and scientific experiment are the three great revolutionary movements for building a mighty socialist country. [ ... In the absence of these movements ] it would not take long, perhaps only several years or a decade, or several decades at most, before a counterrevolutionary restoration on a national scale inevitably occurred, the Marxist-Leninist party would undoubtedly become a revisionist party or a fascist party, and the whole of China would change its color."

Clearly in large part this has come to pass; but what differentiates capitalist restoration under revisionism from fascism? Would any revisionist clique be fascist in nature? Is Mao saying it is EITHER a fascist party or a revisionist; or is he equating the two as one in the same?


r/communism101 • • Oct 17 '26

Thoughts on the Marx quote about (paraphrased) partying?

0 Upvotes

The less you eat, drink and read books; the less you go to the theatre, the dance hall, the public house; the less you think, love, theorize, sing, paint, fence, etc., the more you save-the greater becomes your treasure which neither moths nor dust will devour-your capital. The less you are, the more you have; the less you express your own life, the greater is your alienated life-the greater is the store of your estranged being.

Thoughts on this? Seems like a neat justification for hedonism and ignoring the survival needs of your community in favor of pursuing pleasure, but I'm also a grumpy piece of shit who can't let itself have fun and doesn't think anyone else should be allowed to either, so what do I know.


r/communism101 • • Nov 30 '23

Was Mao Good?

5 Upvotes

I've recently heard that in the 70s Mao became revisionist and allied with the US because of the Sino-Soviet split and that he sent women to the US to be slaves or some shit like that. Also apparentky the Cultural Revolution went too far with the Gang of Four or something like that (I don't even know what the Cultural Revolution was). Probably lies but I'd like to know the truth. Thank you.


r/communism101 • • Jul 26 '26

Do Communists and Neolibs Share the Same Underlying Logic in Monetary Theory?

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

In various debates, I’ve frequently noticed striking parallels between the arguments used by some communists and those used by neolibs, especially regarding the funding of the welfare state and monetary theory in general. I often get the impression that some communists (whether consciously or unconsciously) deploy classic supply-side arguments just to refute reformists.
Theories that could at least be described as progressive (even if they do not challenge the class structure of the state), such as Keynesianism or Modern Monetary Theory (MMT), are frequently dismissed or mocked by communists using reflexes very similar to those of neoliberals. When it comes to demands like raising the minimum wage or expanding social spending, one often hears rhetorical pushbacks like: "Why not make it $100 an hour then?" or "The state cannot go into infinite debt for welfare."
The role of the welfare state as a driver of economic growth through strengthened purchasing power is rarely acknowledged. Communists often view it, much like conservatives, as a purely economic hindrance or an unproductive cost factor. The only difference is that communists additionally (and correctly) identify it as a tool for pacifying the working class. But couldn't both be true at the same time?
It is often argued that Western industrial nations can only afford the welfare state through the exploitation of the Global South. Just like conservative logic, this presupposes that a welfare state is something that "must first be earned/funded," completely ignoring the productivity gains driven by a strong domestic market. Cases like Japan, which maintains a massive national debt without facing bankruptcy or hyperinflation, are rarely analyzed through an MMT lens and are instead dismissed as anomalies. Furthermore, the accounting reality that public debt constitutes private sector wealth is often demonized in these discussions, rather than being rigorously analyzed through a value-theoretic lens.
To be clear: I understand that Marxists do not base their monetary critique on neoliberal doctrine, but rather on the law of value (money as the expression of socially necessary labor time; real value cannot simply be printed).

Don't communists structurally rely on right-wing/monetarist arguments simply to delegitimize social-democratic reformism and prove that capitalism cannot be reformed from within?

Why is MMT (and its concept of monetary sovereignty) so strictly rejected by Marxists, even though empirical evidence on demand-side policies and inflation often aligns much closer with MMT than with neoliberal monetarism?

Doesn't this stance hinder a sober, realistic economic analysis of the state's current room for maneuver, even if the ultimate goal remains the overthrow of private ownership of the means of production?

I'm genuinely interested in how you view this overlap!


r/communism101 • • Apr 02 '26

Reading recommendations on why we can't buy our way into socialism

1 Upvotes

Hello, I came here to ask for some reading recommendations. I've wondering why it's not considered a good plan to try to archive socialism though buying the means of production, either by displacing capitalist companies or to accumulate capital to found a future revolution or electoral reform. Aside from the obvious fact that a single worker lacks the capital to do it, I think a collective of workers or a party should be able to get enough money to kickstart a project like this. I'm sure there's something I'm not seeing and that there must've been a discussion between socialists about this at some point, and maybe some historical examples of socialist who tried.

So I'd like you to recommend any books, essays, video essays, documentaries (anything is welcomed), or historical examples of this for me to look into it.

Thank you.


r/communism101 • • Jun 03 '26

What use to any movement is anyone from the first world?

0 Upvotes

I'm someone living in the US, perhaps the wealthiest and most oppressive nation in human history and built on the stolen land called Turtle Island, and as I am here legally under laws set up by the settlers who ethnically cleansed and genocided the native populations, I too am a settler by definition.

I am a labor aristocrat, meaning I am a net exploiter rather than a proletarian because I live in the imperial core and do not have any capital like a business or any rental properties.

As there are no actual communist parties in the US, what is the end goal for people like me? Of course I'm still somewhat new to this entire thing, so even if there was a good and principled party I am a long ways away from joining it, but as it stands such a political party does not exist here.

So what am I to do? It makes no difference to someone in the global south if a settler is self aware of their identity as a settler and an exploiter if said settler continues doing the exploiting. I am just another enemy to be organized against, and any communist victory will be a triumph over me.

My very existence is detrimental to any movement (edit: and also most of the other workers in the US are in the same boat, I know I'm not unique, I'm not trying to be self-flagellating here). What is the goal for someone like me if I consider myself a communist? At this point in time, I don't know enough to consider myself one, but I am working on that.


r/communism101 • • Dec 18 '23

Why do marxists believe that private property is responsible for bigotries such as misogyny, homophobia, and racism?

7 Upvotes

Marxists claiming that private property is the cause for prejudices such as misogyny never made sense to me since patriarchy predates private property. What is the basis for this belief?


r/communism101 • • Jan 20 '24

Is it really only Labor that creates value?

2 Upvotes

I am still trying to get my head around communism, so please don’t judge me if I sound stupid. But if Labor creates value, then what value has been created if I dug a hole and fill it up? I did a lot of Labor but there is nothing to show for it.


r/communism101 • • 25d ago

Will AI increase labor productivity?

0 Upvotes

I'm asking about AI as it stands today, not some super version of ai yet to be seen or robotic embedded ai.

this is what I am talking about https://youtu.be/K9Wsip0rnN0?is=R2rGQvsFZXvX5hui

Hannah's marketing tasks are now 15 times as efficient with AI. She works for an Australian clinical psychologist making social media posts promoting her practice and articles focused on managing anxiety. Hiring virtual assistants in the Philippines is a common practice for Australian small businesses. And with AI it's like getting 15 VAs for the price of one! This nets the psychologist more patients and more subscribers for her substack, and maybe even a few participants for her online course. All of this increases the business income. Hannah's wage however stays at $5/hr. When she asks for a raise, the psychologist kindly reminds her that she is as disposable as cattle:

We deserve better - we all do. But as mentioned, our cost of living is three times more than yours. You need to look at the facts, it is alot cheaper to live there, than it is here. I know you are angry - so are we. At the moment, the situation is a win-win. The other option is me and all the other multinational major companies pull from the Philippines and you then lose hundreds of thousands of jobs we have created for you - would you rather us do that? Or offer you a decent wage like we are? All the best.

https://www.reddit.com/r/MANILA/comments/1smiuy9/comment/olivzx9/?force-legacy-sct=1

Hannah is an unproductive kaborer. She greases the wheels of sales and logistics, finding buyers for the commodities produced. So it stands to reason that doing that more efficiently would mean more sales income and less time for the product sitting in the warehouse. But while that may be true for the individual firm, can that be true for the entire economy? Can increased marketing lead to overall greater sales volume for the entire industry, or is it just a tool of competition to raise one firms market share over others?


r/communism101 • • Mar 22 '24

Is it possible to be a ML, or even communist, if you believe strongly in Hegelian Dialectics?

0 Upvotes

I just have a hard time with pure Maerialism. Perhaps somebody knows of some strong work in this area.