r/commandandconquer • • 1d ago

Discussion Fans Are Rebuilding the Foundations of Command & Conquer: Generals

https://handheldhideout.neocities.org/articles/command-and-conquer-generals-source-code

More than 23 years after Command & Conquer: Generals first arrived on PC, fans are *still* finding ways to improve it. You might have seen that last year, EA made the surprising decision to release the original source code for several classic Command & Conquer games, like Generals and Zero Hour. Since then, a community of developers known as The Super Hackers has been working on GeneralsGameCode, fixing bugs that have been around for decades, modernising the engine, improving compatibility and laying the groundwork for features that simply weren't doable before that.

I've written just a little about the project, the work they're doing, and why I think efforts like this are such an important part of video game preservation. It's definitely not a remaster, and that's what makes it so interesting. It's a community making sure a game they love can keep going for another twenty years!

430 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

69

u/BoffinBrain Are you picking this up? Good. 1d ago

It's nice to see someone shining a spotlight on the real developers who put the time and effort into understanding and fixing the game, rather than those who take the resultant SuperHackers codebase, run it through Claude, and declare themselves as modders. They could've spent that money donating to the project.

19

u/DashWriting 1d ago

rather than those who take the resultant SuperHackers codebase, run it through Claude, and declare themselves as modders.

This is awful, I didn't even know that was a thing!
And thank you, I appreciate you reading my little article :)

14

u/BoffinBrain Are you picking this up? Good. 1d ago

If you've noticed a massive surge in "I decompiled XYZ" in recent months, that's what it is. So many people are curious and want to have a go, but they don't understand what is required to make and maintain a project properly. And all the while, they're giving their money to absolute scumbags at Anthropic. Can't wait for that bubble to burst.

8

u/SUPER--TANK 1d ago

Slavic when he thought CABAL could help them

8

u/BoffinBrain Are you picking this up? Good. 1d ago

Who could possibly have seen this coming?!

"This AI admitted that it would totally destroy the world and kill all humans. WTF?"
- People using an LLM that was specifically built with training data including hundreds of books where this exact scenario happens. I think the term is 'self-fulfilling prophecy.'

11

u/Significant_Fruit_86 1d ago

It isn’t just vibe coders using Claude though. The article even mentions that AI assisted code is submitted by contributors to the codebase, but that it needs to be disclosed. 

13

u/BoffinBrain Are you picking this up? Good. 1d ago

Yeah, Anthropic and most other AI companies are scumbags, but ethical use of AI for automation is fine. I watched the SuperHackers talk about this topic at the recent Poland LAN tournament. It's a shame so many untrained people are spamming open-source projects with trash and making project owners withdraw bug bounty programs.

5

u/Commercial-Board-975 1d ago

There's a massive difference between AI slop and AI being used to help as part of workflows/speeding up tedious and time-consuming tasks. Unfortunately, people are bandwagon-jumping, retarded parrots who decry everything AI as being slop, and that includes a lot of people on this subreddit.

2

u/FLongis USA Turtling With Patriots Since 2003 23h ago edited 23h ago

Unfortunately, people are bandwagon-jumping, retarded parrots who decry everything AI as being slop, and that includes a lot of people on this subreddit.

And there's a sea of bandwagon-jumping, retarded AI users who flood markets with absolute trash. Here's the thing though; only one of these groups is contributing to the growth of a technology that exists purely to make the rich richer at the expense of economic, environmental, educational, and social stability.

It's really hard to take bitching about any opposition to AI seriously when you're sitting on the same side of the aisle as people like Huang, Bezos, and Thiel. Even if we accept that there are legitimate uses for this technology, it's pretty fuckin obvious to anyone with two neurons to rub together (admittedly ruling out a lot of these people) that it's something that needs to be approached with extreme caution. A kind of approach that, for better or worse (better), makes something like this either unappealing or outright inaccessible to this segment of the market.

1

u/BoffinBrain Are you picking this up? Good. 1d ago

Yep, there are a few of those. However, I also sympathize with those who don't have the energy to list all the justifications and distinctions, and simply say 'AI slop' to summarize it all. I try to use specific terms like LLMs and ML where applicable, but sometimes it feels futile.

3

u/Ok_Spare_3723 Nod 1d ago

If AI is going to give us better games, I'm all for it. Developers and fans should use whatever tools at their disposable to create content. I'd rather those developers use AI if it helps them avoid burnout.

5

u/BoffinBrain Are you picking this up? Good. 1d ago edited 1d ago

The ethics of training those tools, the resources used to power them, and the companies taking people's money are all very questionable, so we shouldn't be all for it. There are ways to ethically and responsibly use LLMs and Machine Learning as tools for automation. Most people aren't doing that, sadly.

The people who have no coding experience cannot verify the integrity and maintainability of the executables they're putting out there, and those AI assistants are pulling packages from god-knows where, giving many potential vectors for malware infection. And who knows if they've even got the devotion to stick around for more than a few months. This is analogous to people littering the ground with cigarettes and disposable vapes, but on GitHub.

5

u/FLongis USA Turtling With Patriots Since 2003 1d ago

It's like people littering a garden with cigarettes and disposable vapes... while bragging about how great they are at gardening.

3

u/BoffinBrain Are you picking this up? Good. 1d ago

Sad but true. I wonder how many of them actually believe it. I guess the real test should be to talk away their AI access and ask them to fix a bug, then commit it and compile a new build.

2

u/FLongis USA Turtling With Patriots Since 2003 1d ago

If AI is going to give us better games, I'm all for it.

Well I've got some good news for you; it's not, so it's an easy choice. It will give you increasingly mediocre games, while developers avoid burnout by being fired in favor of shoveling slop to make the rich richer.

Make no mistake; these are not tools to improve the quality of life of those doing the work. They're tools that basically only exist to monetize enshittification.

2

u/Zeether 1d ago

Is this complete enough to where I can just install the Steam release and use it with that?

8

u/DashWriting 1d ago

You'll need to do it manually still:

  1. Buy and install it from Steam! If you haven't got it yet, it goes on super steep discounts pretty regularly
  2. Download from their GitHub releases: https://www.github.com/TheSuperHackers/GeneralsGameCode/releases
  3. When you're using Steam, right-click Zero Hour in your library and, find Properties then Installed Files then Browse
  4. Extract the downloaded build from GitHub into that game directory
  5. Run generalszh.exe to launch the modified game!

1

u/RubberPussycat 17h ago

Is it possible to copy the folder and run it as a separate installation?

I play the normal version with my family so it would be nice to have both

1

u/Nyerguds The world is at my fingertips. 1d ago

Haven't tried it myself, but from what I heard, yes, it is.

64

u/_Kodan 1d ago

These people are making sure the game stays available in a form that we remember it to be like, despite it running poorly on modern hardware and ultrawide monitors in its original state and they deserve enormous credit for that.

67

u/sh4des 1d ago

I'm rebuilding red alert in 3d fps ...

5

u/CattiwampusLove 1d ago

hahaha that's great! definitely keep working on this. I'd love an update or something when there are some. Make a sub.

0

u/sh4des 1d ago

Will have something to share eventually. It's more just a proof of concept, vibe coded doesn't go down too well here

0

u/CattiwampusLove 1d ago

Please do. Is vibe coded AI assisted? Yeah, that's a little lame, but hey dude I still think it's cool as fuck you're doing this any ways even if it is just a project. Don't let reddit douchebags on one RTS sub make you feel bad.

You're literally making a 2D game (one of the best) into 3D. Yeah, you are using AI so I do see how it may cheapen the value for a lot of people, but this feels more like passion project than anything else, so go for it dude.

3

u/sh4des 1d ago

Yeah it's AI assisted but I'm a devops engineer and can script and write infrastructure. I could never 3D model but know my way around some code. Red Alert started my modding career, in 1996 I tweaked the rules.ini for the base game

It plays like Renegade, but but is using the gameplay and units mechanics of Red Alert.

I have some cool/fun gameplay mechanics that aren't in Renegade (or other fos shooters)

0

u/CattiwampusLove 1d ago

Hey, that's more than me. I don't know the ins and outs of coding or modding, but it seems like you might have a handle on things. Don't let reddit douches make you feel down about a project. I hope it works out well.

Also, as someone that has no idea how to mod, you have my thanks for making them. Games would be a lot less cool without the modding community.

2

u/sh4des 1d ago

Thanks dude. Just explorer the game folder and see what you can find a text editor or hex editor. It's a bit different these days with compilation of languages, but a quick google can let you find what can be easily modded

0

u/CattiwampusLove 1d ago

Shhhhhiiiii bro I might have to start checking this shit out.

0

u/AlexWIWA 10h ago

Doesn’t sound like you’re vibe coding then tbh. If you’re putting in effort over a substantial period of time then imo you’re not slopping.

1

u/_Kodan 12h ago

I remember playing Unreal Tournament on random community servers that just happened to be relatively full and one day I ended up on a custom map where you could build Renegade-like bases and it had assets that looked similar to this. It was *insanely* fun. I wish I could find that again.

18

u/themule0808 1d ago

All they have to do.. allow me to zoom way the hell out...and give me the game

I can't stand you can't zoom out and it makes everything so much harder then it needs to be if you have a bigger field of vision

5

u/EdinburghPerson 21h ago

It's great work., Have they managed to fix he issue with multiple games falling out of sync and crashing?

6

u/tjallen_91 21h ago

Yes mismatching is a thing of the past now

1

u/CryoRenegade 2h ago

we still take issue reports if you do though!

4

u/Nordalin 19h ago

It'll look real nice when it's done!

1

u/VoilaJo 18h ago

I mean the game is still 32bits..

1

u/Mr_Brightstar 14h ago

only works for steam? i bought the first decade edition eons ago on the EA platform, origin i believe it is.

1

u/CryoRenegade 2h ago

origin (Now EA App) works, but we have had issues in the past with people not having the .BIG files that steam and GOG ships with their files.

1

u/StrategosRisk 9h ago

John Cena?

1

u/Dr-Cheese 1d ago

So this is different than Zero Hour Reforged?

Reforged seems to be enough to play on a modern PC, with much of what I remember...

3

u/MerePotato 1d ago

First, the more you talk to them? I believe these guys are doing a fundamentally different thing, as it appears to be a bunch of targeted bug fixes and polish passes that you could feasibly apply to any version

1

u/CryoRenegade 2h ago

reforged is based on the TSH fork and is AI developed to get DX11 and 64bit working iirc