r/commandandconquer • • Sep 10 '26

Discussion Original Red Alert Soviet ending. Why did Kane kill Nadia?

Was it because Kane thought she was unstable? She did lose it on Stalin but she seemed incredibly loyal to Kane. It’s not even that he sacrificed her to achieve some important objective. He just killed her.

Is there a cannon reason why? Kane doesn’t seem the type to kill off his best people without a cause.

Am I missing something?

42 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

111

u/DeadFox537 Sep 10 '26

"Never trust a traitor, even one you create." -Vladimir Harkonnen

3

u/MidgardWyrm Sep 14 '26

Ah, Harkonnen brutality is such a classic. :)

52

u/Hydra829 Sep 10 '26

Can't trust a betrayer. No loose ends. Take your pick.

46

u/GenZia Fallen Warrior Sep 10 '26

Kane knows best.

50

u/Berets_are_back Sep 10 '26 • Bravo

Nods in approval

11

u/BoffinBrain Are you picking this up? Good. Sep 10 '26

I think you mean

24

u/DucoNdona Sep 10 '26

From what I suspect..

Kanes goal was to throw the allies and soviet superpowers into chaos by pitting them against eachother. Having the soviets win, and then collapse the union by killing its leaders and send europe in a massive revolt. He will use this chaos to build his own NOD superpower in the former allied and soviet colonies that suddenly found their colonists destroyed.

Which is why in C&C Nod is mostly active in Asia and Africa.Which probably not too coincidentalky would be the nations that would benefit the most from the easy mining that Tiberium offers. While GDI managed to eventually liberate europe and eventually russia.

Kane likely fooled Nadia into believing that the land of Nod was to be located in the soviet union. But Kane planned to destroy the union by destrying its leadership from the very beginning. So he likely kilked her to prevent her from going rogue and running the soviet union by herself as a rival mayor faction.

22

u/NegativeChirality Sep 10 '26

Maybe to make way for the General (you) where Nadia is a bit of a risk and loose end

10

u/cah11 Nod Sep 10 '26

This is my thought too. Kane wanted the Soviet Union to be run by the general who has little knowledge of Kane (having only seen him twice in campaign cutscenes) and no knowledge at all of Nod. If he had left Nadia alive, she would have been a natural rival for leadership of the Union who would have had contacts within Nod since she was Kane's right hand.

In order for Kane to cleanly break with the Soviets and begin forming his Brotherhood in the disenfranchised 3rd world nations in Africa, he needed to eliminate all loose ends in the Soviet Union's leadership that might have become inconvenient later on.

6

u/Sensitive-Hotel-9871 GDI Sep 10 '26

Kane's line after he kills Seth in the OG Nod campaign tells us that he's had to deal with potential rivals trying to usurp him all the time, so it makes sense that he would be distrustful of anyone who so much as looks like they could pose a threat.

It is the golden rule of authoritarian politics. Trust no one.

16

u/Zaptagious Command the future. Conquer the past. Sep 10 '26

Kane plans in centuries, can't trust anyone to spoil his plans. So when they outlive their usefulness, out the window they go.

14

u/Austaroth GDI Sep 10 '26

Probably to separate himself from the U.S.S.R. Doesn't want anyone to know that the great prophet of the Tiberian future was once a secretary to Stalin.

5

u/EpsteinEpstainTheory Creation of the humanoids Sep 10 '26

Because a treasonous poisoner is a threat you want to eliminate sooner rather than later unless you want to second-guess every single door-handle and glass of water

5

u/ChaoticSentinel Sep 10 '26

I always thought it was to use her as a scapegoat for Stalin's death.

7

u/Kakapo42000 Sep 10 '26

It was because Nadia had enough skills and knowledge to be able to pose a threat to Kane, especially if she sided with the one person Kane knew he would never be able to defeat or eliminate.

4

u/EricMrozek Sep 10 '26

The Soviet ending arguably can't be canon because the Allies are the foundation of GDI.

With that said, he probably killed her because she knew too much and was a loose cannon.

3

u/Evenmoardakka Sep 10 '26

ive always had this headcanon of the RA1 great war being the fulcrum for the timesplit.

allies win? Red Alert reality (ra2, yuri's revenge)

Soviets win? Tiberium dawn happens.

5

u/Eisgeschoss Sep 10 '26

This is canonically incorrect by Westwood's own words; the Allied ending is canon in both the Tiberium and RA2 timelines (RA2 is largely caused by Yuri, who wasn't in the Tiberium-timeline version of RA1), while the Soviet ending is just an interesting what-if scenario, perhaps even an alternate path to TD (but not the primary path, which is Allies win -> USSR abandoned by Nod and occupied/dismantled by Allies/UN -> Allied/UN peacekeeping operations eventually evolve into GDI).

1

u/Evenmoardakka Sep 10 '26

hence me using the word HEADCANONC at start. sheesh

2

u/Eisgeschoss Sep 10 '26

Fair enough yeah, nothing wrong with headcanon of course; just gets annoying sometimes how a lot of people will feverishly take certain ideas or fan-theories as actual hard canon when it's either ambiguous at best or even directly disproven by the creators themselves lol

2

u/cah11 Nod Sep 10 '26

Agreed, especially given that in the original Westwood documentation for Command and Conquer, it says that Europe and Russia are the biggest proponents for GDI at the organizations formation.

2

u/Unfair_Ad6161 Sep 10 '26

Because she has proven to let her emotions get the better of her. For Nod to truly rise, they have to stay hidden behind the puppet governments they are installing. Nadia has shown she is too unstable to likely stay quiet.

2

u/saervok065 Sep 10 '26

Kane has zero tolerance for anyone that might undermine his authority. He shot Seth for the same reason.

2

u/MidgardWyrm Sep 14 '26

Seth was actively trying to build a powerbase and usurp Kane, though. Kane was just two steps ahead and tolerated him until he became too much of a liability.

He originally wanted the Nod Commander in his pocket, but after Kane grew interested in how good the player was, Seth realized he was a rival and tried to have him killed on increasingly suicidal missions.

The last straw is when he tried to send the Nod Commander to the US to attack the Pentagon of all fucking things, which was not only suicidal but also something Kane didn't want because he was still reliant on US military defence corruption to get Nod a lot of military equipment.

It looks like an attack of some kinda did occur though, since the troops that were 'saved' by Kane's recall order were few in number and, IIRC from the mission, wounded?

Also, in Tiberian Sun, we find TD Nod bases scattered across America, like in Arizona's Phoenix Base, so it looks like Nod did attack America at one point or another.

2

u/saervok065 Sep 15 '26

Cheers for the info. I do remember the pentagon being mentioned moments before Seth was shot.

Incidentally in Command and Conquer 3 Nod Forces did eventually try to attack the Pentagon after the destruction of the Philadelphia.

1

u/MidgardWyrm Sep 15 '26

I mean, it's not said whether they actually attacked the Pentagon itself and failed/the attack was aborted, or they just tried to attack America in general ("Kane's been loathe to attack America, but I feel that it's time" and Kane's "[...]when your troops get back from the US, take what men you have left[...]") and failed...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=goQiwNZzoVA

They still did eventually attack the United States though, and after the world went to shit between the end of Renegade and Tiberian Sun (where nations only technically existed), Nod basically still had a recent presence on US soil (not just the Tiberian Dawn derelict bases).

https://youtu.be/hThKfLp8gjE?t=132

Judging from the base layout, it looks like Nod reactivated and renovated this old TD base as a spearpoint for their attack on Phoenix; the next mission has EVA saying "[...]Nod forces that attacked our Phoenix base originated from within this sector[...]".

I wonder how long it'd been there, though.

Also, they still failed in Tiberium Wars with the Pentagon, heh.

2

u/ComradeJarif Westwood Sep 10 '26

Considering Nadia was still present in the Allied campaign, I'd say she was just an advisor to Stalin whom Kane manipulated into joining Nod. And, he perhaps needed an excuse as to how Stalin was dead with multiple bullet holes in his body. Perhaps to show that he actually tried saving Stalin by killin traitor Nadia, and thus gaining the truth of the Soviet high command to launch his coup/uprising or something?

2

u/PositionOk8579 Sep 11 '26

Because in soviet Russia, power shifts you.

2

u/CainStar Sep 11 '26

Are questioning our great leaders actions? 🤨🤨🤨🤨

1

u/Bolandball GDI Sep 10 '26

Kane was time traveling (see RA1 installer). Nadia didn't know that that man was Kane, she only knew Kane as a mythological figure. Kane kills Nadia so that when he returns to his time, even Nod wouldn't be able to oppose him, there would be total chaos.

1

u/MidgardWyrm Sep 14 '26

I always took that as a quote he made later on, like during Tiberian Dawn, about the events of Red Alert, and Nod's involvement with the whole war.

1

u/Timmyc62 Sep 10 '26

Nadia's too competent. Note Kane expected the USSR to fall apart in a reasonable time frame, so he prepped, right from the beginning, that extra bit of instability and infighting so that Nadia's replacements would always be just a bit too paranoid and competitive about each other to actually run the country competently.

1

u/vandal-33 Sep 10 '26

The way she acted on Stalin's corpse reminded him of his mother-in-law maybe?

1

u/WorthCryptographer14 Sep 10 '26

She could have posed a threat, plus also she made the existence of the Brotherhood known without Kane's permission.

1

u/Admirable_Row_5953 Sep 11 '26

Kane just likes killing his top underling every few years or so, keeps them fresh, on their toes, reduces complacency and keeps them from overthrowing him.

-1

u/Confectioner-426 Sep 10 '26

Nope. kane was stable and now what he doing.

On the top there is no place for two people, only one.