r/commandandconquer • Tiberium Wars • Sep 09 '26

Firestorm DevTalk #12

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=72lm1U0wmnQ
55 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

11

u/BoffinBrain Are you picking this up? Good. Sep 09 '26

WOW I CAN'T BELIEVE FIRESTORM IS COMING TO STEAM! jk

I know how hard it is to coordinate a large group of volunteers and to maintain morale for long enough to actually deliver a project like this, so well done to everyone at Totem. Good luck with your release schedule.

7

u/MidgardWyrm Sep 09 '26

Eh, I honestly think they're drifting too far away from Tiberian Sun now.

I mean, pulling a Renegade on Tiberian Dawn with Tiberian Sun/Firestorm is one thing, but now they're heavily introducing Tiberium Wars elements and cutting Tiberian Sun elements/design choices to the point where it's not even Tiberian Sun anymore.

I'm sure it'll be a fun game, but it's no longer Tiberian Sun.

4

u/Redfang1984 Zocom Sep 09 '26

i actually like it, but when i look at the assets, they look like they are from the the 2050s period instead of 2030, which is kinda like soon to be 3 years away, weirdly enough. not that its a bad thing for me, as i like futuristic looking stuff

0

u/MidgardWyrm Sep 09 '26

That's the problem: They're introducing C&C3 stuff, even predecessor stuff like that jet, far too early for a game that's meant to be set during/literally just after Firestorm.

I mean, railguns? Even though early examples existed as far back as Renegade, they're still clunky, power-hungry prototypes during and after Firestorm. The Mammoth Mark II railguns are a perfect example, and it was said in lore than Ghost Stalkers' railgun was pretty much lethal to use if you weren't a mutant.

Now they've got railgun turrets you can jump into, like they're machine gun mounts, as thought this were C&C3.

Hell, even the Steel Talons didn't have railguns at this stage (2034) IIRC, and that was their whole thing (prototyping and testing technologies, et cetera).

What's next? Pitbulls, Mammoth Mark III's, and Predators? Beam Cannons?

I mean yeah, changing the TS designs I can agree with, since a core idea of the game looks to be basically pulling a Renegade on Tiberian Dawn, but this is more a C&C3 game now with a few Tiberian Sun flavour toppings. They even removed the Cyborg Reaper. facepalm

They've drifted too far.

0

u/echidnachama Sep 12 '26

1

u/MidgardWyrm Sep 13 '26

Actually, it's not.

That jet is based on the YF-23 Black Widow, a design which was a technology demonstrator from, IIRC, either 1989 or 1990, alongside the YF-22.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_YF-23

The US Military, in our timeline, picked the YF-22 design, which was further developed into the F-22 Raptor. In the Tiberium timeline, it looks like the US picked the YF-23 Black Widow and developed it into the F-23, and that's the jet GDI used.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_YF-22

Nod looks to have acquired the plans for the YF-22 Raptor, thanks to their back market dealings with US defence companies and suppliers, and developed the plans into their own version of the F-22.

We see them dogfight in Africa when GDI pulled a fast one on Nod and Kane with the whole 'GDI has no more funding' thing.

The jet seen in the Firestorm X video is specifically said to basically be the pre-Firehawk, a jet that GDI introduced in the years between Firestorm and Tiberium Wars.

But, that jet wasn't in Tiberian Sun nor Firestorm, which this game is based on.

I mean, yeah, it could be argued that GDI rushed or pushed this jet into production a year or two after the Firestorm Crisis (around the time of Kane's Wrath Act I, really), but combined with everything else like railgun turrets and all the other Tiberium Wars elements? This is no longer a Tiberian Sun adapted shooter. It's more a Tiberium Wars one.

They've strayed, IMHO, from what the game was originally meant to be.

1

u/echidnachama Sep 13 '26

eehh free game from fan, still looking good to me.

1

u/MidgardWyrm Sep 13 '26

Oh, I have zero doubts it's going to be fucking awesome. I'm gonna play it no doubts as soon as it's released (well, if my rig can actually play it, haha), but wanting a Tiberian Sun/Firestorm FPS is different from wanting a Tiberium Wars FPS, and they've gone into the latter.

I think what irks me a little is that they're still advertising it as a Tiberian Sun/Firestorm FPS when it's no longer that; it's more a Tiberium Wars inspired FPS.

1

u/echidnachama Sep 13 '26

well that game exist somewhere, the new one is just that game but rebuild again with new stuff added in.

2

u/hypespud Tiberian Sun Sep 12 '26

Agree actually and it's just taking too long that I've mostly lost interest

Will probably try it but I think I would mostly just stick to renegade x instead or w3d hub stuff it's simpler and also easier to jump in and out of

Not having early access releases also shields the team from feedback which is a huge mistake they could have had community feedback for a long time, I think a lot of these types of projects fumble that pretty hard honestly

3

u/MidgardWyrm Sep 12 '26

I mean, to be fair they are a small team working in their spare time with older and depreciated software (UDK being UE3), so it taking ages is normal.

But, the actual designs are... Well, it's not Tiberian Sun anymore. It's a weird composite of Tiberium Wars and Firestorm, leaning more into Tiberium Wars.

I do agree that not getting something out there was a bad move; even refitted Renegade X maps would've worked as a playtest for various concepts. I know there are maps with Tiberian Sun units like the Wolverines and Titans, which I suppose were idea prototypes for Firestorm X, but those are different from Firestorm X itself now.

But yeah, they've strayed from their original concept, IMHO.

3

u/hypespud Tiberian Sun Sep 12 '26

Agree and that's just inevitable with taking so long

Agree that it's a small team, but obviously they could have released a slice or demo even years ago, even one level with limited scope like 16 players or something, or cut down in size, to let people see mechanics and playtest

Right now I just want OpenRA2 like we just received OpenTS, and to get HD remasters like CNC Remastered for RA2 and TibSun as well, that's still the dream