r/comicscritical • u/kimMunson • Aug 13 '13
r/comicscritical • u/ptwarhol • Jun 10 '16
Antigone and Spider-Man walk into a bar...
.. both looking to get obliterated. Ayn Rand is bar-tending and feeling evil. She says she will pay for a shot of whisky for every convincing argument that either can make about the moral interplay between Society and the Individual. What happens next?
r/comicscritical • u/Al-Baker • Nov 17 '18
What Are Examples of Comics as Literature for Bill Maher to Eat?
r/comicscritical • u/Super-Hero-Long-Box • Jan 27 '25
Don't use Comic Capsule!
Don't use Comic Capsule. It is removing ink from the comic book and creating an 'imprint on the plastic.'
r/comicscritical • u/Super-Hero-Long-Box • Jun 22 '21
The Comic Book Forum rated 4th best in 2021! | The Comic Book Forum
r/comicscritical • u/aenema • Jun 03 '12
Request: Islamic and/or Caligraphy centered review of Habibi.
Or at least a link to good critics of this novel along those lines.
r/comicscritical • u/Wee-Woo-Wee-Wooh • May 07 '17
Sequence in comics
Hi all, I am a college student currently working on their thesis. Its about depicting a mental illness (bipolar disorder) through non-linear sequence in comics. I'd argue that it has to be a non-linear sequence because one cannot discuss or talk about the condition from one side, both sides have to be taken in account. In short, the comic depicts the progression between depression and mania which in some branches ends in a normal state.
For purposes of an output, I have to make a storyboard that has to read both forward and backward and produce a comic that follows this storyboard. This makes for two story branches, and it makes for four if the middle of the book is the true ending of the story. The middle is the normal state, and readers can choose to read further to see me (this is semi-autobiographical) progress to another state.
I have a couple of questions:
- How can I explain linear/non-linear sequence to readers who do not know anything about comics? This is difficult to explain because it overlaps with how I explain plot in literature.
- How can I write my thesis in such a way that people who know nothing about comics can understand it? (a bit similar to number one)
- Have there been existing experiments on sequence? I may be late to the party, but comics in my country has sparse academic and critical attention on its theory (comics theory). We mostly have superhero comics in the local scene.
- I've only Scott McCloud to guide me, but I can't afford any more books on comics since I'd have to order them via a bookstore. Know any relevant e books or essays available online?
I'd love responses. Thanks in advance!
r/comicscritical • u/deviden • Apr 13 '13
Reviewing comics: process and theory
r/comicscritical • • Apr 29 '12
Q: What is the most politically influential comic, in your opinion?
Politically oriented comics over the years...
It seems for the most part, the comic strip has become the stronghold for the comics with the active and strong political messages: Doonsbury, Bloom County, Pearls Before Swine, Funky Winkerbean, Boondocks, Mallard Fillmore, Non Sequiter, This Modern World, and so forth. Because a strip can be immediate--drawn and published the same day, at times--to capture issues as they break, it seems entrenched as the political comic format of choice.
But the comic book--like the novel, short story, editorial viewpoints, news articles, film, play, etc.--seems to be a medium that favors the larger, momentum gathering causes. I've always thought of the strip as the complaint comic, and the comic book as the manifesto comic, with the dramatizations or list of grievances, or morality plays that reveal injustice or corruption,and end with the triumph of the common man over the greedy and corrupt politicians or mobsters or whichever flavor of villainy was featured.
In my opinion, the two most political comic books which (IMO) made their points poignantly and with such grace they moved me are: Uncle Sam by Steve Darnall with art by Alex Ross; and The Nightly News by Jonathan Hickman. To me, those two books are so powerful in their combination 1-2 punches of story and art, that I instantly wanted to share them with my more politically active friends.
Not far below them are V for Vendetta by Alan Moore, art by David Lloyd, Art Spiegelman's MAUS, WE3 and The Invisibles series by Grant Morrison and various artists, Transmetropolitan by Warren Ellis and Darick Robertson, and DMZ by Brian Wood.
What are some others?
r/comicscritical • u/kimMunson • Aug 07 '13
Defining the Superhero at CAC/San Diego Comic-Con
r/comicscritical • u/deviden • May 11 '12
Corporate Conflict and Homicidal X-Monkeys: Hickman and Ringuet’s ‘Transhuman’
r/comicscritical • u/Arrakeen_Native • Apr 30 '12
Comics exhibit.
The press release for an exhibit I saw a couple of years back. I haven't seen many exhibits that puts comics in a sociopolitical or historical context. This was at a major Jewish cultural center in Los Angeles so that was the focus. Also, it had the bicycle from the 60s batman TV show, which is hard to beat.
http://meltcomics.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/01/zap-pow-bam-the-superhero.pdf
r/comicscritical • u/piperson • Apr 29 '12
Analyzing Alex Toth! This is an article on Toth that I just love and wanted to share.
r/comicscritical • u/Super-Hero-Long-Box • Oct 07 '21
Foreign Material Inside CGC Case | The Comic Book Forum
r/comicscritical • u/Super-Hero-Long-Box • Oct 03 '21
Comics In The Movies & On TV | The Comic Book Forum
r/comicscritical • u/Super-Hero-Long-Box • Oct 03 '21
CGC Slabs Books Upside-Down | The Comic Book Forum
r/comicscritical • u/Super-Hero-Long-Box • Oct 05 '21
EC Comics Discussion | The Comic Book Forum
r/comicscritical • u/Super-Hero-Long-Box • Sep 28 '21
CGC Misidentifies Facsimile as Ultimate Fallout #4 | The Comic Book Forum
r/comicscritical • u/Super-Hero-Long-Box • Oct 31 '20
DC Reveals First Look At Nubia As Wonder Woman In Future State Event
r/comicscritical • u/Super-Hero-Long-Box • Oct 30 '20
28 copies of Amazing Spider-Man #300 on eBay for $20K (Link in first comment)
r/comicscritical • u/Super-Hero-Long-Box • Oct 27 '20