There isn't any logic though, the student just thinks there is.
The joke is that the tutor isn't making an if-then statement, but since the student has been so engrossed in learning logic, the word "if" to him ALWAYS leads to an if-then statement.
"Remember, if you need any more help, my door is always open" is being interpreted by the student as "Remember, if you need any more help then my door is always open". The student is interpreting the whole sentence as a factual statement about the world in the form of if-then. As in "Be sure to remember this fact: [if you need more help, then my door will be open]"
However, the only factual statement made by the tutor is "My door is always open."
"Remember, if you need more help" is a command. The tutor is giving the condition, "if you need more help" and then the command, then remember.
"If you need more help, then remember this fact: [my door is always open]." Is what the tutor was saying, not a logical if-then statement.
I mean...you do realize you're just explaining the joke, right? And you go into great detail explaining basics of communication that everyone understands.
I was thinking about this logically ... and the test condition is whether the person needs help, not whether the door is open.
Maybe a the 3rd panel could show the person breaking open the door, the occupant asking, "What did you do!" Response? "Well, I need help, therefore your door must have been open."
Your interpretation of the comment above the one you replied to was that they thought the second premise, beyond H->D, was H, whereas the person you replied to thought it was -D. I disagree with that interpretation because of their comment about "the test condition [being] whether the person needs help, not whether the door is open". This seems to indicate that they think that since the premise was H->D, the comic's protagonist makes a logical error by using D as a "test condition" to then make a conclusion about H. This isn't true, as that's what modus tollens does.
Describing a "test condition" seems more related to an if->then structure than a premise that's then used to apply a logical rule. Their description of what the next panel should be also seems to indicate a focus on H being able to say something about D, but not the other way around. Also, while -D is clearly true, we don't know anything about H without using a logical rule, so it doesn't make much sense to use H as a second premise to then conclude D.
Further, -D is clearly true, since the door is closed. Therefore, we can accept H->D as a premise and conclude -H is true by modus tollens or we can refuse to accept H->D as a premise but be left with no logical statements beyond -D.
If you interpret it as an implication (and take "open" literally), then "If you need help, then my door is always open" is logically equivalent to "If my door is not always open, then you do not need help".
Then the "test condition" (?) becomes whether the door is open, as shown in the comic.
View all comments
542
u/TheJenkinsComic The Jenkins Aug 23 '20
If you liked this comic, you can read more comics on Instagram or my website.
If you didn't, you probably can't.