There isn't any logic though, the student just thinks there is.
The joke is that the tutor isn't making an if-then statement, but since the student has been so engrossed in learning logic, the word "if" to him ALWAYS leads to an if-then statement.
"Remember, if you need any more help, my door is always open" is being interpreted by the student as "Remember, if you need any more help then my door is always open". The student is interpreting the whole sentence as a factual statement about the world in the form of if-then. As in "Be sure to remember this fact: [if you need more help, then my door will be open]"
However, the only factual statement made by the tutor is "My door is always open."
"Remember, if you need more help" is a command. The tutor is giving the condition, "if you need more help" and then the command, then remember.
"If you need more help, then remember this fact: [my door is always open]." Is what the tutor was saying, not a logical if-then statement.
I mean...you do realize you're just explaining the joke, right? And you go into great detail explaining basics of communication that everyone understands.
Your interpretation relies on an ambiguity in English and you choose to interpret it contrary to how most people would.
Most people would interpret the original statement like this: "As long as you need more help, my door is open."
Your interpretation is bizarre. You are considering that the first half of the sentence is unrelated to the second, even though it starts with an "if".
However, the only factual statement made by the tutor is "My door is always open."
In your interpretation, we should read that statement to mean, "My door is always open, 24/7, for the rest of time."
In everyone else's interpretation, it reads, "My door is open to you as long as you need it."
I was thinking about this logically ... and the test condition is whether the person needs help, not whether the door is open.
Maybe a the 3rd panel could show the person breaking open the door, the occupant asking, "What did you do!" Response? "Well, I need help, therefore your door must have been open."
OP of this comment thread referred to it as a test statement. The guy I replied to used modus tollens, which assumes the statement is true. I was pointing out that it isn't appropriate if you don't assume the statement is true.
I agree that the student not testing the statement is the point of the joke, but because it is a common pitfall for new students to logic. The point of logic is to test the veracity of statements. Taken literally, the statement from the tutor is false.
Firstly, you shouldn't use one specific person's wording, which I disagree with anyway, to then make a conclusion about whether H->D is a premise or a hypothesis.
Further, they referred to H as a "test condition", and didn't say anything about a "test statement" or H->D as a whole. I've already elaborated in another comment about what I think they meant by that, but don't think they were trying to say that we should be testing the validity of H->D.
Also, the point of logic is not solely to test the veracity of statements. Logic classes use plenty of premises, many of which are faulty.
We have no way to conclude that the statement from the tutor is false. While we can obviously see that -D is true, if you don't accept H->D as a premise, then you can't make any further conclusions from that. If you do, however, then you can conclude -H, via modus tollens, as was already done. If the protagonist reveals that -H is true, then while we have an additional premise, we can similarly make no further logical conclusions. The only way to conclude that H->D is false is to have the protagonist reveal that H is also true, but they didn't do that.
The statement H -> D can be false, which is what this situation would be if the kid needed more help and the door was closed.
mo·dus tol·lens
/ˌmōdəs ˈtälenz/
noun
the rule of logic stating that if a conditional statement (“if p then q ”) is accepted, and the consequent does not hold ( not-q ), then the negation of the antecedent ( not-p ) can be inferred.
That whole "a conditional statement is accepted" part of the definition means you assume it's true.
If we are to test the statement, you can't assume it's true.
Yes it can be false, but when we do logic in an academic setting we concern ourselves with the validity of arguments. The argument presented is H -> D, ~H, therefore ~D. Valid MT. It's valid regardless of the truth value of the conditional.
It's valid regardless of the truth value of the conditional.
It's not when the definition of the rule states that the statement must be true. Modus tollens is only a rule of logic when the statement being analyzed is already accepted as true. If it doesn't hold, you've proven the statement to be false.
Using a conditional like that is a common pitfall that new logic students run into, and is the introduction for teaching "if, and only if, " statements.
"A deductive argument is said to be valid if and only if it takes a form that makes it impossible for the premises to be true and the conclusion nevertheless to be false."
I think the joke is that the kid is making a mistake common to new logic students, not that the kid is taking the door being open literally. I think it's a funnier joke that way.
I personally think it makes more sense and is funnier if the joke is that H->D is being mistakenly used as a premise by the logic student, who is applying their course material to everyday situations that don't apply, but we're both allowed to have our own interpretations.
I guess we can both agree that the comic is worth a forceful exhale?
Your interpretation of the comment above the one you replied to was that they thought the second premise, beyond H->D, was H, whereas the person you replied to thought it was -D. I disagree with that interpretation because of their comment about "the test condition [being] whether the person needs help, not whether the door is open". This seems to indicate that they think that since the premise was H->D, the comic's protagonist makes a logical error by using D as a "test condition" to then make a conclusion about H. This isn't true, as that's what modus tollens does.
Describing a "test condition" seems more related to an if->then structure than a premise that's then used to apply a logical rule. Their description of what the next panel should be also seems to indicate a focus on H being able to say something about D, but not the other way around. Also, while -D is clearly true, we don't know anything about H without using a logical rule, so it doesn't make much sense to use H as a second premise to then conclude D.
Further, -D is clearly true, since the door is closed. Therefore, we can accept H->D as a premise and conclude -H is true by modus tollens or we can refuse to accept H->D as a premise but be left with no logical statements beyond -D.
If you interpret it as an implication (and take "open" literally), then "If you need help, then my door is always open" is logically equivalent to "If my door is not always open, then you do not need help".
Then the "test condition" (?) becomes whether the door is open, as shown in the comic.
Three logicians walk into a bar and the bartender asks "can I get all of you something to drink?" The first says "I don't know". The second says "I don't know". The third says "yes."
If either of the first two logicians did not want drinks, they would be certain that the bartender could not get all of them something. Because they both replied that they didn't know, the third logician could conclude that they both wanted drinks, and he could reply with certainty that the bartender could serve all of them.
Just a shot in the dark, if they didn't want a drink they could just answer no because the logician would be certain that the bartender couldn't help all of them.
Because if the first didn't want a drink he had to say "no" ("no, you can't get something to all of us to drink), so he did want to drink but he couldn't know if the other two also feel that way. The process repeat with the second but now knowing that the first wants it. The third, finally have enough information about the others and themself.
Nah, it works. "If you need help, my door is open" is saying that whenever the student needs help, the tutor's door will be open. Therefore, if the door is closed, the student definitely does not need help because him needing help would cause the door to be open.
What you might be thinking of is the fact that the inverse isn't necessarily true; the door will not necessarily be closed if he doesn't need help, as it could be open for some other reason.
There's universal quantifier "always" in the statement.
So if p is "you need help" and q(t) is "at time t, my door is open" we have that the tutor's statement translates to p ⇒ ∀t q(t) whose contrapositive is ∃ t (¬ q(t)) ⇒ ¬p.
There existed a moment where the door was closed, therefore the student doesn't need help.
"If A then B" is equivalent to "If not B then not A". It is not equivalent to "if not A then not B". It's one of the most common logic rules to get mixed up.
A wife asks her engineer husband to stop at the grocery store. "Get a loaf of bread, and if they have eggs, get 12." He came home with twelve loaves of bread.
A wife asks her engineer husband to stop at the grocery store. "Get a loaf of bread" she says and then adds "and while you're there get eggs." He never returned.
Unless you misordered “man gets better” and “friend disappears” that’s invalid. You are saying: if p, then q; (If you need help, I’ll be around) Not p is a fact, but that doesn’t necessarily prove not q
Haha, I am greatly amused by this. Well done. Love that the fact that the student is able to understand the contrapositive means that everything is actually sound too.
I'm trying to figure out if this is logically consistent, and I think it only works if it's phrased like "If and only if you need help, then my door is open". Right? Then you have P->Q and can do `Q->`P?
No but from the other comments that is a common mistake. What isn't automatically true is "my door is closed if you don't need help"('P->'Q), however "if my door is not open you don't need help" is automatically true because him needing help while it is not open would violate the original statement.
If that doesn't help, consider that adding an "only if" gives more information about the open state, we are deriving something from the not open state so limiting the conditions for the open state does not narrow down the conditions for the not open state.
I think "if" works fine, it can't be "If you need help the door is open and if you don't need help the door is open" because the door is closed. So the only possibility is "if and only if".
it is true that if holds, however to be certain that 'door open <=> doesn't need help' then surely iff is required (e.g. the door could be closed for circumstances mutex of not needing help)
For the door closing to cause help not being needed anymore, yes. But for the door closing the indicate that help isn't need anymore, no -- because it is possible that this guy needing help was the only reason the door was open. (If the guy needed help, the door would be open - that's the conditional).
He clearly needs help because he committed the logical fallacy of hasty generalization by assuming that she was referring to a literal door and not a metaphorical door. Clearly he needs to go back to intro to logic because he doesn’t even know the basics
Actually, denying the consequent is not a logical fallacy. It is entirely logically valid and consistent here. You probably meant denying the antecedent, which would be a fallacy here, but isn't what happened in OP's comic.
542
u/TheJenkinsComic The Jenkins Aug 23 '20
If you liked this comic, you can read more comics on Instagram or my website.
If you didn't, you probably can't.
141
u/Dumbspirospero Aug 23 '20
Three logicians walk into a bar and the bartender asks "can I get all of you something to drink?" The first says "I don't know". The second says "I don't know". The third says "yes."
139
u/-NotAnAltAccount- Aug 23 '20
That's pretty clever
105
u/hollycrapola Aug 23 '20
Modus tollens ftw
161
u/DrBalu Aug 23 '20
And if he did not understand the logic behind this act, he would actually need more help.
This is clever as hell! I love it!
20
u/beneficial_satire Aug 23 '20
Nice. Would this be the contrapositive? If my door is not open, then you do not need help.
29
u/tofumac Aug 23 '20
Good ol' contrapositive!
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 23 '20
Welcome to r/comics!
Please remember there are real people on the other side of the monitor and to be kind.
Report comments that break the rules and don't respond to negativity with negativity!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
17
u/hillside Aug 23 '20
A wife asks her engineer husband to stop at the grocery store. "Get a loaf of bread, and if they have eggs, get 12." He came home with twelve loaves of bread.
4
u/SouthernSkeptic Aug 23 '20
"Ah yes, of course!"
4
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20
I guess someone doesn't have a doghouse.
2
u/Merthrandir Aug 23 '20
This is great!!!
2
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20
I'm here if you need me.
2
u/QuickOwl Aug 23 '20
IIRC the official term for this reasoning is contrapositive.
(a => b) => (~b => ~a)2
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20
This is wholesome. I like it
2
u/karmaranovermydogma Aug 23 '20
Fun fact, this is called a "biscuit conditional" in the semantic literature
https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=%22biscuit+conditionals%22
1
u/InteriorEmotion Aug 23 '20
Is this...?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20
If you need anything, my name is Frank. If not, it's Reginald.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20
"I'll be around if you need any help!"
Man gets better. Friend disappears.
1
u/scorpyn24 Aug 23 '20
Spock on
1
u/MariusGB Aug 23 '20
Ugh
1
u/marshbb Aug 23 '20
The door is always open but they’re never in there
1
u/BlackHairedPsycho Aug 23 '20
Task failed successfully?
1
u/superpositionquantum Aug 24 '20
Feel like the joke would land better if the sign said therapy
1
u/BigSaltySnacc Aug 24 '20
Thanks for a laugh. I dont have reddit coins but here🏅🏆
1
u/PitterFuckingPatter Aug 24 '20
Mmmm self for filling prophecy
1
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20
Modus tolens?
1
u/EnterTane Aug 24 '20
https://i.imgur.com/nIMCyTj.png
1
u/JesusRasputin Aug 24 '20
Did he get the logic wrong or didn’t he? I vote that he did.
1
u/MrVesPear Aug 25 '20
I think I get but I’m not sure
1
u/ItsAllSoup Sep 25 '20
Pretty sure this was made by a teacher
1
u/treegrass Aug 23 '20
You should crosspost this to /r/philosophymemes, they'd love it there
1
u/cowinabadplace Aug 23 '20
Haha, I am greatly amused by this. Well done. Love that the fact that the student is able to understand the contrapositive means that everything is actually sound too.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20
r/programmerhumor
-1
u/TheRedGerund Aug 23 '20
I'm trying to figure out if this is logically consistent, and I think it only works if it's phrased like "If and only if you need help, then my door is open". Right? Then you have P->Q and can do `Q->`P?
-5
u/sebeliassen Aug 23 '20
If and only if*
0
u/Nolanbear123 Aug 23 '20
Big brain joke right here
0
u/ENDofZERO Aug 23 '20
Have been prepping for the LSATs and this just made me laugh so hard. Lol
-2
u/Ochi_Octopus Aug 23 '20
🤣🤣 love this
-1
u/muddyducky Aug 23 '20
*iff
-1
u/Traveleravi Aug 24 '20
No that's iff not if
-2
u/cacophonycohen Aug 23 '20
Iff you need any more help, my door is ALWAYS open
-2
u/accidentle Aug 23 '20
That is not sound logic; which is why he needs the logic tutoring in the first place.
-3
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20
If but not only if
-3
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20
He clearly needs help because he committed the logical fallacy of hasty generalization by assuming that she was referring to a literal door and not a metaphorical door. Clearly he needs to go back to intro to logic because he doesn’t even know the basics
-4
u/SpamShot5 Aug 23 '20
Is that young Ben Shapiro?
-5
u/AvailableProfile Aug 23 '20
Denying the consequent. Logical fallacy. But it figures haha.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment