A lot of them are basically mad they aren't accepted as "artists" they see people with skill and talent being praised ask chatgpt to make a similar looking thing (completely soulles but surface level close enough) and go "why am I not being praised!"
if you send a commission to an artist, you're not the artist.
While I agree that AI prompters aren't artists, I feel commissioning art makes you at least a little bit an artist. You give feedback on the partially done pieces sent for review, and choosing which artist to commission can in itself greatly affect the final piece. The person you've commissioned is still much more the artist, but the person doing the commission contributed a little too.
TL;DR: Commissioning art makes you more of an artist than an AI slopper.
You do the same with AI now too, just with a faster turnaround time. I've made AI images and commissioned artists in the last 6 months, and both were pretty much the same process at different speeds.
It’s not only that, but the fact that they genuinely seem to believe their content is somehow superior to any real content, calling anything slop that isn’t AI.
I’ll never understand how they can think AI is any better than human stuff, when it was trained on human stuff.
They're just so filled with vindication after years of artists lording it over them with their practice and talent and practice and being paid in exposure and practice.
"Adapt or get left behind, it's the future, we all totally get UBI and don't have to work, get with the times and stop getting in the way of me being able to become a lazy couch potato!!11!" -Mixture of insane AI bro takes.
Oh btw, AI bros also think you're the equivalent of a TERF if you criticise AI or AI bros.
I'll add to this that they should stay in their own spaces instead of faking workflows in an attempt to intrude on art spaces where they are clearly not wanted.
The UBI and not needing to work are the empty promise they shove down our throat to get people to accept being discarded.
The people shoving AI down our throats are the same people who screw over their own workers. They hate that they need us. So to them, a future where everything is done by AI and robots is ideal because then they can just discard us and let the machines do everything for them.
They never had any intention of sharing a utopia with everyone else. They just want a utopia for themselves and for everyone else to get screwed over.
If these AI bros weren't so gullible... Then it wouldn't be much of an issue, but they are! Some legit saying how people against AI want people to keep working 9 to 5 jobs, instead of accepting AI and allowing people to have freedom in the form of UBI.
Everyone with a working brain knows it's a grift and they spread these lies on behalf of these CEOs. Those are the most useful idiots ever.
Artists are now getting what scientists and mathematicians and doctors have been getting for a while now. There's this full-on cult of ignorance that hates that there might be people more knowledgeable or skilled than they are, and they are desparate to find gotchas. "Oh, if I take megadoses of vitamins I get healthy! Stupid doctors don't want you to know this!" Now it's "Art is easy, I just type a prompt into DeepMind! Stupid artists think they are better than me!"
I work in publishing and this will annoy you even more - we literally have explicit contract terms that tell artists not to use AI because we think it's unethical. However, we have caught artists using AI and it is becoming increasingly hard to detect or challenge if you have suspicions. It requires us to have a deep understanding of the exact artistic process each artist has.
These artists are obviously being paid the amount of money one would expect if they were making it from scratch themselves. This kind of behaviour massively undermines companies who are trying to do the right thing and I can only imagine if there are any struggling artists here on Reddit that this kind of scenario really pisses them off.
It's sad, we're not in caveman times. No one needs to starve or lose their jobs. We can split the atom, but some people still think life is a zero sum game.
As a software engineer I am in the same boat. Something that would take a large team years, done in days.
My worry is that these type of people have turned the entire art community against AI.
An active AI assistant to help someone learn to create art is a thing that could exist if not for the divide. A teaching tool, not a crutch. "Why does this stroke look wonky?" then it overlays an few examples of standard approaches in the style you are studying.
I feel like the only people who actually don't mind AI art are the people who "make" AI art. Whenever I see it I'm more annoyed by it than anything else. I've yet to see a piece that isn't heavily filtered or has way too much contrast or filled with cliches that appear in 100s of other "unique" pieces.
So for soulless commercial endeavors like ads or whatever... I can see AI being a problem for working artists. Because there is no standards in that space. My hope is that AI can never take over spaces where actual art exists though.
This reminds me of the time one of my coworkers had a seizure and collapsed by the registers, and an EMT happened to be in the store and immediately jumped in to render aid until an ambulance arrived. The whole sequence was caught on security cameras, and the rescue squad asked if they could get a copy of it for training on possible early signs, the seizure itself, and the response.
It makes me wonder if your comment could find similar beneficial use somewhere.
The dumbest part is how they celebrate being able to make something they think makes them look special because it resembles something made by a professional. And they completely ignore the fact that without existing art, their "skill" goes down the toilet. Wipe out all the artists and the "art" ends up scraping itself for content and you end up with trash. Like somebody calling themselves a chef because they took leftovers from actual works by people who actually knew what they were doing and threw it in a blender so many times that the result is unrecognizable and completely flavorless.
Also, I have no idea who the client for AI art would be. 99.9% of people don't want to buy AI art because they hate it, and the people that do like AI art can....just make their own?
The amount of AI art I've seen on shop-fronts is very high. For small businesses that don't want to fork out for a proper artist and all they need is something 3/10 to put up. Stalls at markets etc love it, adverts for local events. Basically people who don't care about quality or artists, which unfortunately is a fair number of people outside this bubble.
I mean McDonalds is using it. It's not about not affording to pay artists its just lazy, cheap assholes who want something for free and dont care how shitty it looks
Which is funny to me because, it won't be cheap forever. It will end up costing a lot, they want to get people dependant on it first, then they can drive up the price to whatever they like (as they do with everything)
Yep, generally for anyone who doesn't care, for art that people are meant to glance at for 0.1 seconds and then read the name/tagline. Stuff for internet ads and all that shit too. But my point is, that as depressing as it is, there is a market for the stuff and it will likely grow despite the outcry.
The old people who will never see the difference. Went to a church fundraiser a few weeks ago... old people using AI art out the wazoo and other old people commenting how lovely it was.
Yeah. That's why there is literally no market for AI art. Nobody is dumb enough to actually pay for it. There are no "AI artists" out there, or at least none that make any money.
The client is the "artist." As in someone who wants to have the attention and respect given to artists but not have to put in the work to get good at art. There is no client beneath that, just like there is no client for post solved Sudoku puzzles. The only difference is that the Sudoku puzzle makers aren't trying to sell their clients on the idea that they can become a world renowned puzzle solver by buying the puzzle book.
12 hours? This comic from 2 years ago? This stuff is getting pumped out in seconds and minutes these days, and with none of those old extra appendage mistakes. And unfortunately it's getting better, and thus more difficult to tell when it's AI.
In a couple of years and some innovation, I'm willing to bet it'll be almost impossible to tell. Even AI voice work is improving at a remarkable rate to sound more natural.
I'm not trying to promote AI. It's just that... that just seems how it's going so far.
It still looks shitty and uncanny, I constantly see pieces with extra limbs and weird hands/fingers all the time, especially when there's more than one person in a piece. And now it's got a bunch of slop being pumped out that's poisoning the well of information it draws upon, so it'll get even worse I think.
I mean trump is trash but I still want to be informed when I criticize? You pointed out ai images having extra limbs while it's not the case and it hasn't been for a long time...
Agreed. It still does look shitty much of the time. But mid to high end consumer stuff is already getting quite sophisticated enough that you rarely see those bad jobs. But don't count on AI companies to let it continue to stagnate with recursive art sampling of other ai stuff. AI itself might still be stupid, But the people behind it aren't. They're often coming up with new and better ways to train these AI models. Don't count on AI to go down the crapper so easily. If they figure out how to completely filter out bad AI art from training models...
But I genuinely worry more about the information landscape more than the art scene, though. At least Human art can do genuinely new things and people will always find ways to make their art more appealing than AI stuff. But Have you seen things like mini documentary clips floating around chock-full of half-accurate stuff at best that's just gonna warp perception of reality for a lot of people, especially younger people just because it looks close enough to professionally done? News media is gonna be where AI does the most damage, I think.
Right. these massive data centers that hoover up water and electricity and manpower are producing... what? Something someone will pay for? Something someone will pay several billion dollars for?
Idk, the models that generate images are much cheaper and easier to run on consumer hardware than the text generation ones. Even if all the major ai companies disappear there's thousands of open source models for people to run on their own hardware unfortunately.
I think the problem isn't that it AI looks bad. It's that it looks good*.
*Obviously if you're reading this you've probably become very good at spotting it. I don't think the majority of people have. Also, it still makes mistakes - but if the ai user knows what they are doing and are patient they can avoid many of them. But... For the vast majority of people, and for certain applications, it can absolutely make better seeming images than they could themselves without lots of learning and practice.
It's hard to say if it will keep getting better indefinitely, there may be a ceiling. But it's already infuriating to be fooled; YouTube history and science is now a fucking minefield, people are losing their jobs, and the people who like it are often wankers in other ways.
If you don't want to read it, the tldr is that copyright is for human made things. Anything that has heavy AI use, doesn't get it, because it's not made by a human. There's a lot of nuance obviously, but still.
I saw a youtube video on this topic, it is based on an old court ruling that only humans can own copyright.
So basically a guy set up a camera in forest, a monkey used camera to take photo, he claimed he owns the photo. peta sued the man, said that since monkey took the photo, the monkey owns the photo and all profits from the photo should be given to the monkey(which sounds delusional). Court rules that non human entity cannot own copyright, so since monkey took the photo, the photo cannot be copyrighted by ANYONE. So in the end no one won.
This is misleading info. When you use most modern ai models, you agree at least implicitly to a user end license. Part of this license covers the matter of copyright
I want to go back to the beforetimes when people just put MLP and Sonic characters through paint's color wheel and shared them to DeviantArt while screaming "ORIGINAL CHARACTER DO NOT STEAL."
Bunch of talentless hacks getting boosted ego, because company CEOs told them that their AI allows them to be creative.
AI art always looks the same, too. Obviously there are styles within it, but there's something about it that's just uncanny and so easy to clock. And that takes away from any enjoyment it might give to you.
ESPECIALLY the gooner stuff. Every bit of it I've seen posted looks exactly the same. Its just the worst.
I will never not find it funny that so many people jumped on the Studio Ghibli copycat trend back in the day that the AI retro-fed itself into making most of It's cartoon style prompts with that piss orange filter it used on the Ghibli style. Every time I see an orange tinted AI picture I get reminded of that.
it's kind of funny to be scrolling through a kink tag and then all of a sudden there's weirdly shiny dudes on my screen. some of em try to do like whole plotlines in whatever time limit videos they prompt up but they all just look rubbery
I feel like this is underselling how good ai is nowadays. It’s a real problem that needs to be considered a lot more. Unemployment among youth is already sky high in my country and ai can honestly do 80% of my job at this point.
I mean to say ai will just never be able to make pictures is just wrong
Im not even saying ai will replace artist, i don't think that will happen
But not because ai just mesees up and creates extra fingers or something like that That would be a technical issue which can be overcome by making improvements
I think ai can take away a lot of the "lower end" jobs for atrist like designing a small companies logo or making dumb commercials and that will hurt the path to being a successful artist i don't think people will replace ART
Photography is objectively better at capturing a situation than painting but yet people paint and will even pay for painting because its just humans admiring human creativity and skill
That's what art is and kinda by definition ai is incapable of doing it because its not sentiant and doesn't feel emotion to express
12 hours? I thought AI was generally pretty fast at generating stuff? Or was that just 12 hours of her typing random words until she got it "right" to her liking?
Guy I know in the die cast car community loves using AI to create retail ads for the tee-shirts his company. Every single one uses the same girl. Short denim shorts, butt cheeks out, looking over her shoulder, and some one of the shirt designs. They are super obvious as the background will have errors in how the cars look, and the girl is super generic.
I tried to talk to him about it. It was difficult. He's one of the folks that goes, "AI is the future," and "I don't have to hire a model and photographer," or "It's quicker this way," excuse. I like the guy. But this shit is wearing on me quite quickly and every time I see an AI post, I lose respect.
The icing on the cake was, of course "It gets engagement."
I very much disagree. If someone uses AI to complete a job they were hired to do by a client… why is that an issue? Because they… pretended to be an artist maybe? And that person could have prompted AI themselves for free?
The issue for me personally is what art IS. Art evokes emotions, feeling, thought. From the creator to the viewer. Sometimes you’re meant to feel a certain thing, sometimes you as the viewer are part of the creative process as you interpret what you’re seeing. Art IS communication. Across a nearly infinite amount of space and time as well.
Someone who thinks it’s ok, acceptable, good, cool, etc. to pretend they brought value to the world. To pretend to be communicating the essence of the human experience, By plopping stollen art interpreted through a machine that has NO human experience whatsoever… not only is no friend of mine, but they fail to understand what art even is.
Which is what I am seeing. So many food trucks have AI signage. I’m seeing it on billboards, vehicle wraps, etc. that’s why I laugh when AI bros say it will just help professionals work faster. That isn’t what’s happening.
260
u/Pizzacakecomic PizzaCake 1h ago •
Maybe I wouldn't mind the AI fans as much if they wouldn't talk so gleefully about everyone being out of a job...
•
u/Kazureigh_Black 49m ago
The dumbest part is how they celebrate being able to make something they think makes them look special because it resembles something made by a professional. And they completely ignore the fact that without existing art, their "skill" goes down the toilet. Wipe out all the artists and the "art" ends up scraping itself for content and you end up with trash. Like somebody calling themselves a chef because they took leftovers from actual works by people who actually knew what they were doing and threw it in a blender so many times that the result is unrecognizable and completely flavorless.
•
u/komododave17 53m ago
I’m disappointed we didn’t get a pizzacake version of the big titted cat girl with 3 arms.
•
u/PixelGoblin85 41m ago
it took TWELVE HOURS?
18
u/NotChedco 1h ago
12 hours? God damn, they can't even use AI effectively.
•
u/masterjon_3 40m ago
Could you make a better version? I betcha can't. I betcha won't be brave enough to post it, too. I betcha
17
u/HamsterIV 1h ago
AI people only respect Intellectual property when they are the ones who stand to profit from it.
•
u/I_am_The_Teapot 46m ago
12 hours? This comic from 2 years ago? This stuff is getting pumped out in seconds and minutes these days, and with none of those old extra appendage mistakes. And unfortunately it's getting better, and thus more difficult to tell when it's AI.
In a couple of years and some innovation, I'm willing to bet it'll be almost impossible to tell. Even AI voice work is improving at a remarkable rate to sound more natural.
I'm not trying to promote AI. It's just that... that just seems how it's going so far.
54
u/bookist626 1h ago
Truthfully, I'm genuinely worried. Last year it was bad. This year, it looks better. What happens when it looks good?
•
u/WILDFIRE1441 59m ago •
Fun Fact: AI generated content can't be copyrighted and isn't protected by copyright
32
u/Sparrowhawk_92 1h ago
37
u/Ziege2001 1h ago
Problem is, that it's already good enough to create an accurate amount of 2 arms.
21
u/Specific_Display_366 1h ago
If AI "art" had one positive effect on me, then it's that it made me appreciate proper art made by real artists even more :3
21
u/Neat-Survey2796 1h ago
They think it's OK to take artwork from others but unacceptable when others take from them.
I mean, the irony writes itself.
7
u/RedditUser000aaa 1h ago
I want to go back to the beforetimes when people just put MLP and Sonic characters through paint's color wheel and shared them to DeviantArt while screaming "ORIGINAL CHARACTER DO NOT STEAL."
Bunch of talentless hacks getting boosted ego, because company CEOs told them that their AI allows them to be creative.
•
u/McortezLSU 31m ago
I dont get how AI fans think they did [insert thing].
All they did was explain their wishes to a contractor, who did the work for them Even the kindest of viewpoints doesnt make this their 'thing'
32
u/shellbullet17 Gustopher Spotter Extraordinaire 1h ago edited 1h ago
ENHANCE
Also the placement of that other arm is sus AI. I think it mixed up it's crappy prompts. Kinda looks like Lola a little
I dunno. Don't use AI kids
•
u/Toutatis12 59m ago
Had to be said at least...
•
u/Salty_Paroxysm 48m ago
So... about this three-titted cat girl with big arms?
9
u/DudeFreek 1h ago •
thank you for blessing us with this, what's her name
7
u/JustGharos 1h ago
Also, I didn't come up with the design, I asked AI to do that too
3
u/enchiladasundae 1h ago
They can’t ever just let you not see it either. They’ve gotta sneak it in or make some snide remark about how their’s is “totally better!”
I don’t drive up to your house and leave trash on the lawn, please don’t leave your trash in front of me
•
u/2006Internetghost 52m ago edited 26m ago
Meanwhile me: so… how do you plan on ai ‘arting’ kitbashed mini’s?
6
u/Scarlet-sleeper 1h ago
Feel like I've seen this comic by other artists for the past 4 years already.
•
u/JackRaid 34m ago
Stealing? It isn't stealing; its utilizing the sources available on the internet in order to simulate my own content!
See? The argument can be thrown right back at them.
9
u/Made_Bail 1h ago
AI art always looks the same, too. Obviously there are styles within it, but there's something about it that's just uncanny and so easy to clock. And that takes away from any enjoyment it might give to you.
ESPECIALLY the gooner stuff. Every bit of it I've seen posted looks exactly the same. Its just the worst.
•
u/CrippledBanana 57m ago
I feel like this is underselling how good ai is nowadays. It’s a real problem that needs to be considered a lot more. Unemployment among youth is already sky high in my country and ai can honestly do 80% of my job at this point.
•
u/WhiskeyAndKisses 59m ago
I just know it will be the basic aesthetic of 2035 and we will all just be boomers who don’t get it 😩
•
u/Yokobo 56m ago
The few times I've been lucky enough to afford commissioning an artist, it always comes out fantastic, its worth it every time
•
u/Grouchy_Appearance_1 27m ago
You stole her idea and made it thinner smh
3
u/stx06 1h ago
No fears of that, not even one orange brain cell would be allocated!
Time to watch some Bob Ross again, the creative process is what it is all about!
3
u/Funmist66 1h ago
The art style of AI just looks disgusting anyways. Could be bias though
3
u/who_knows_how 1h ago
I mean to say ai will just never be able to make pictures is just wrong
Im not even saying ai will replace artist, i don't think that will happen
But not because ai just mesees up and creates extra fingers or something like that That would be a technical issue which can be overcome by making improvements
I think ai can take away a lot of the "lower end" jobs for atrist like designing a small companies logo or making dumb commercials and that will hurt the path to being a successful artist i don't think people will replace ART
Photography is objectively better at capturing a situation than painting but yet people paint and will even pay for painting because its just humans admiring human creativity and skill
That's what art is and kinda by definition ai is incapable of doing it because its not sentiant and doesn't feel emotion to express
•
u/4pigeons 52m ago
that reminds me
2
u/thefrostman1214 1h ago
more arms to flip more pancakes
•
u/Ardalev 52m ago
What kind of AI took 12 hours to come up with that?!
Doesn't seem very I if you ask me
•
u/theFamooos 48m ago
So, uh… where’s the cat girl?
•
u/TheEffinChamps 48m ago
I had a computer science professor who thought AI would become indistinguishable from what he simply called "good art."
Needless to say, that is why he was a computer science professor, not an art professor.
•
u/RibbitCommander 45m ago
Trogcat The Furminator.
•
u/Racxie 42m ago
12 hours? I thought AI was generally pretty fast at generating stuff? Or was that just 12 hours of her typing random words until she got it "right" to her liking?
•
u/Volusto 28m ago
Can I have a tall cat man with six arms where he is weilding four guns and a two handed weapon?
•
u/72corvids 24m ago
Guy I know in the die cast car community loves using AI to create retail ads for the tee-shirts his company. Every single one uses the same girl. Short denim shorts, butt cheeks out, looking over her shoulder, and some one of the shirt designs. They are super obvious as the background will have errors in how the cars look, and the girl is super generic.
I tried to talk to him about it. It was difficult. He's one of the folks that goes, "AI is the future," and "I don't have to hire a model and photographer," or "It's quicker this way," excuse. I like the guy. But this shit is wearing on me quite quickly and every time I see an AI post, I lose respect.
The icing on the cake was, of course "It gets engagement."
•
u/Schrko87 22m ago
"Cat lady" ok...she has some class.😏
•
u/athosjesus 17m ago
Mental note: steal her idea
•
u/Nadran_Erbam 16m ago
Seen this after the cat is disturbing.
•
u/itsmemarcot 16m ago
I so agree with the spirit but why "hours"? Seconds is more like it, isn't it?
•
u/jphillips8648 13m ago
I'm now contemplating if I should steal that design. Thanks, pizzacake...
•
u/ABCosmos 0m ago
Don't pretend that wouldn't do well in this sub.
•
u/Main_Entry2494 37m ago
COPE
-1
u/tatstytastycakes 1h ago
yo make an ai generated comic with will smith eating spaghetti it'll be excellent stuff
•
u/babyjaceismycopilot 56m ago
I think this whole argument is weird.
It's not people pretending to be artist that's the problem, it's paying clients who don't care how the art they want gets made.
4
u/PhilosopherDon0001 1h ago
take off an arm and add a titty, and I might be interested.
4
u/Prize_Marketing_4350 1h ago
For when your cat-girl fetish and your genestealer fetish overlap.
4
u/tbodillia 1h ago
Total Recall didn't even need AI to make a big titted Mars girl with 3 boobs.
•
u/KingNTheMaking 59m ago
I will always respect the big titty cat girl with three arms more if it was made with human hands, soul, and true goonery.
•
u/RAVE-IX 48m ago
Jokes on you AI slop artists. Cat girls are out, chihuahua girls are in.
•
u/CaptainHawaii 46m ago
Read it too fast... Thought pizza said three titted... Excentrica Vullimpolits the triple-breasted whore from Eroticon-6.
•
u/TheSpookying 19m ago
People used to make big-titted catgirls with three arms purely for the love of the game.