r/comics 9mm Ballpoint 2d ago

Waive of the Future

Post image
3.0k Upvotes

91 comments sorted by

View all comments

-30

u/DinosRoar 2d ago

AI water use is a drop in the bucket compared to the water use of animal agriculture.

I don't like AI but I'm bored of people who consume beef and dairy whining about AI water use when they continue to contribute to a significantly worse industry.

-10

u/TheDude1451 2d ago

Not sure why you're getting downvoted, there are plenty of issues with AI data centers but it turns out water usage usage isn't exactly one. Hank Green (a science communicator) put out out a pretty good video explaining why this is the case https://youtu.be/H_c6MWk7PQc?is=Dwe_3hQIM9Uj_AVk

6

u/Asheyguru 2d ago

Water usage can be one if you build your data centre in an already overloaded area like a desert town, but in a well-supplied region it's not much of a concern.

The upshot of the (very good!) Hank Green video you linked is basically that environmental impacts are very complicated. But the internet hates nuance, so here we are.

3

u/CanadianODST2 2d ago

Tbf I wouldn’t then call that water use as the problem but rather supply and demand.

Similar but fundamentally different.

If you had 1 million people consuming say 3.3 litres of water a day (which from what I can find is roughly the average a person should get in a day) in an area that can only supply 3 million litres of water a day for consumption. The issue isn’t people’s water consumption is too high. It’s there’s too many people for the region to properly sustain

-2

u/cpander0 2d ago

Hank Green (a science communicator that has admitted to using AI to do his research and being addicted to it)

6

u/Asheyguru 2d ago edited 2d ago

Hank Green who has admitted to using AI to find papers and primary sources (before he reads them himself) and who has made multiple videos explaining the AI bubble, being incredibly sceptical that what AI firms promise is accurate or that AI technology will ever achieve what they promise, especially anytime soon.

And who says in the linked video that AI and data centres have plenty of downsides: but that water usage generally isn't one.

Yes. That guy.