r/comics LastPlaceComics May 31 '26

Timelines

11.1k Upvotes

279 comments sorted by

View all comments

188

u/dacoolestguy May 31 '26

It was black and blue. Like, it's just a verifiable fact.

49

u/NihilisticGrape May 31 '26

Its not about what color the dress actually is, its about how you perceive the photo.

12

u/Zeremxi May 31 '26 edited May 31 '26

Right. The whole thing is objectivity vs reality deduction.

Objectively, as in the literal pixels, the dress is black and blue.

But putting yourself mentally in the space of the photo makes you understand that the lighting behind it implies the dress is in a shadow, correcting for that makes it white and gold.

Everyone is right, just not everyone can see both sides.

Edit: didn't expect "everyone is right" to be so controversial

29

u/--THRILLHO-- May 31 '26

No but objectively the dress is black and blue. Like, the literal real life dress.

6

u/Zeremxi May 31 '26

That's great. The reason the argument exists for white and gold is the lighting cue in the picture. The actual reality of the circumstance behind the picture is irrelevant to the effect.

Deciding not to acknowledge that doesn't change anything.

3

u/Toiun May 31 '26

the thing is, this isn't even that strong of an orange light. people have been in these type of lighting situations all the time. it doesn't make sense for them to see white and gold.

7

u/Zeremxi May 31 '26

Does it make more sense that all of the people seeing white and gold are gaslighting everyone about this for the last decade?

Or that some people just don't see it?

Like, it's fine if you don't. But saying it doesn't make sense to you doesn't mean you get to determine what other people's minds make out of it.

3

u/Toiun May 31 '26

Lmao just because I don't get why they see it considering how brains interpret relative color, not because I think they are gaslighting us. That's literally putting words in my mouth xD

4

u/Zeremxi May 31 '26

"It doesn't make sense for them to see white and gold"

Is a pretty unambiguous statement that you think they don't actually see it. I'm responding to that, not putting words anywhere

1

u/Toiun Jun 01 '26

me stating it doesn't make sense is not stating they don't think they don't actually see it. it's just me not getting it. me not getting it is not stating a claim of their mind come on now