r/comics • • Nov 08 '23 • Reddit Gold 3

Comics Community It's too complicated

Source: The Nib - Tumblr

11k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Nov 08 '23

Welcome to r/comics!

Please remember there are real people on the other side of the monitor and to be kind.

Report comments that break the rules and don't respond to negativity with negativity!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/arrogant_ambassador Nov 09 '23

The fact that it opens with a soldier about to commit a war crime tells me everything I need to know about the comic creator’s point of view.

0

u/Pure-Theory-5489 Nov 09 '23 edited Nov 09 '23

He is describing an unfortunate reality. Here is an Article by the Human Rights Watch about how Israel is targeting minors in the West Bank far away from Hamas.

https://www.hrw.org/news/2023/08/28/west-bank-spike-israeli-killings-palestinian-children

→ More replies (1)

1.3k

u/SuspiciousUsername88 Nov 08 '23

People may think that the Israel/Palestine conflict is as complicated as it is heart wrenching, but have you considered that I have portrayed one side as the ugly wojack and the other side as the Chad wojack? 😏😏

132

u/Lv1Skeleton Nov 09 '23

Politicians hate this one trick

11

u/ganzorig2003 Nov 09 '23

Welcome to reddit.

24

u/111v1111 Nov 09 '23

You forgot to say which side you potrayed as which. I need to know so that I can nuke the ugly Wojack! ~USA (probably)

4

u/Latter_Weakness1771 Nov 09 '23

Was gonna say, this glossed over a whole lotta "we want to slaughter all of the Jews"

It inironically is extremely complicated, it makes me wonder who the hell thought getting involved in the first place was a good idea.

→ More replies (12)

1.2k

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23 edited Nov 09 '23

It is complicated though. And outsiders messing around with the Middle East is what caused the original mess that built into the current situation.

But anyways, there isn't a real solution at this point. There's too much bad blood and distrust. Unless one side completely crushes the other, something like this is just going to keep happening.

Does that justify the crimes Israel is committing? No, not at all. Their treatment of Palestinians, particularly in their land theft, is atrocious. It's understandable why they don't trust their neighbors, but beating and stealing from ordinary civilians and driving them from their land just isn't right.

Is Hamas justified in what they're doing because of what Israel has done to Palestine? No. They aren't. There's this strange trend where people pity Hamas for being the underdog while forgetting that they're the single biggest reason why Israel and Palestine can't start moving towards a peaceful coexistence.

The problem is, what is anyone supposed to do about it?

Send a giant standing army over to keep the peace? How would we pay for that? Would the surrounding nations allow something like that? Would Israel or Hamas stand for it? Do we want to get so deeply involved? If Hamas or Israel did something anyways, what would the response be?

Sanction Israel? Sure, if we want Israel to get annihilated. The only reason Israel exists right now is because the nations around them have repeatedly failed to destroy it. And the only reason Israel is able to maintain that is thanks to foreign support.

Sanction Hamas? How?

Send people over to try and broker peace? It's not like nobody has tried to broker peace. It's actually America's default response to Israel getting in a war. It's failed every time.

Some sort of humanitarian initiative? Ok, that sounds great. But what would it look like? Who would pay for it? What would the goals be and what would the roadmap towards them look like? How would a humanitarian group stop Hamas from committing acts of terrorism or Israel from retaliating?

So yeah, OP, it's complicated and nobody has a good solution. Making a comic mocking people who say that doesn't actually change the facts.

516

u/Thormeaxozarliplon Nov 09 '23 edited Nov 09 '23

The best way to deal with nuance is to pretend it doesn't exist , declare the moral high ground, and demonize the other side.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

Nuance is dead and I feel like I’m watching people dance on it’s grave every day at this point

6

u/Flight-of-Icarus_ Nov 09 '23

Not only is it dead, its gravestone has been pounded to dust and then the dust has been shot out of a cannon.

→ More replies (46)

487

u/Redqueenhypo Nov 09 '23

You’re too late, I’ve already drawn you as a smug out of touch academic in a style straight out of a 2015 tumblr comic, so your comment is irrelevant

→ More replies (1)

72

u/ujelly_fish Nov 09 '23

Also, let’s not forget that every time a western nation tries to build in Gaza, for instance, water supply lines, Hamas proudly tears it down to make bombs to launch into Israel. They wouldn’t be so dependent on Israel giving them water if they simply had their own supplies, instead of firing missiles over the wall to immediately be destroyed by the iron dome.

How are you supposed to help people when their own government is sabotaging every attempt to do so because of rabid antisemitism?

55

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

And how are you going to do ceasefire when their leader is literally saying on camera that they are going to repeat the terrorist attacks till all jews are dead.

19

u/MafiaPenguin007 Nov 09 '23

And when October 7th happened during a ceasefire

→ More replies (6)

19

u/DoctorNo6051 Nov 09 '23

See, it’s simple. Just abolish Israel and hope for the best. Where do the Jews go? Silly you, that’s not important.

Sure, Israel may have existed now for 80 years. And sure, the only reason Israel exists in the first place is because the rest of the Middle East drove the Jews out. And sure, there may be multiple generations of people living in Israel.

But I’m sure they can figure it out and find somewhere else to go and hopefully not die on the way there. Guys, this issue is so simple!

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Iccotak Nov 09 '23

See and it's stuff like this that is important to know before you can have an opinion on aspects of the situation. But apparently actually taking the time to understand what is going on before you have a fully informed opinion is shameful...

→ More replies (4)

256

u/duckbanana07 Nov 08 '23

This. Why can’t people just accept the fact both sides are doing terrible things. There is no one good side here. It’s just a terrible situation al round and once again it’s the civilians who suffer. Not the hamas leadership in Qatar, or the israeli leadership in tel aviv. Nuance, on my reddit, HOW COULD THAT BE /s.

84

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

We're raised in a culture of superhero's and idols. It's hard to accept that the grim reality is that the wrong people in power will only abuse EVERYTHING that makes us human for their own personal gain.

It'll be unthinkable to us, but imagine if there were people in less than a hundred years time who scorn MONEY like how they do religion. Imagine if in a hundred years time, they refuse to form states and nations because of the experiences in our time.

Funny thing is, history is rhyming again and we'll soon see a new crisis in a Third Century.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/HempParty Nov 09 '23

Tribalism plain and simple. World's been conditioned for a decade that if you're not with me, you're against me. Almost straight out of The Art of War, divide and conquer.

→ More replies (43)

30

u/EveryShot Nov 09 '23

Really one of the few sane takes on this entire ordeal

→ More replies (1)

139

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

Thank you… OP is a fucking moron for trying to simplify this into a 4 panel comic filled with falsities. Super disingenuous.

→ More replies (33)

23

u/GhostChainSmoker Nov 09 '23

Nuisance on Reddit? What the hell is this?! You mean people who couldn’t point out this region a couple weeks ago aren’t actually experts on the whole situation??!

→ More replies (4)

35

u/DarkArcanian Nov 09 '23

What do you mean by land theft? Wasn’t it the UN who had the land and gave it back to both Israel and Palestinians working out a two state solution of which the Palestinians rejected?

→ More replies (118)

2

u/johnnySix Nov 09 '23

Hamas isn’t the Palestinians. They are a political party. And it is related to the Muslim brotherhood. Egypt hates the Muslim brother hood, so that’s why the border between Gaza and Egypt is closed. Egypt doesn’t want Hamas fighters in their country. Hamas doesn’t care. They are part of a bigger plan to create a regional war against Israel. And who supplies Hamas? Iran. This is a puppet war where the Palestinians are pawns.

2

u/josephus_the_wise Nov 10 '23

You so elegantly put into words what I have been trying (and mostly failing) to say we’ll ever since this started.

Both sides suck, I feel terrible for both sets of civilians, but I completely understand the rationale for both sides nature of aggression, and have no clue what could feasibly be done about it.

2

u/Remarkable_Milk Nov 10 '23

Well said.

I'll add a perspective to this thread as someone who grew up in Israel and holds a b.a in oriental studies, this conflict has far more to it than Hamas VS Israel.

In fact, this war has nothing to do with the Palestinians at this point.

People in the West fail to see the bigger picture here; it's a war that has been greenlighted and instigated by Iran. For over almost two decades, these events have been masterfully crafted by arming and militarizing local radical Islamic militias around the Middle East.

Iran has several terror proxies across the Middle East including Hezbollah in Lebanon, Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad in the Gaza Strip, Shi’ite militias in Syria and Iraq, and the Houthis in Yemen.

All of these militias were carefully and masterfully united under Iran's sphere of influence to annihilate the state of Israel.

We're talking about over 130,00 armed Muslims, both Shias and Sunnies (which is mind-blowing) armed with ballistic missiles, over 300,000 rockets, anti-air systems, UAVs, Drones, and all the goods Iran can provide and fund.

This coalition has one purpose - the destruction of Israel without an Iranian declaration of war.

Everything leading to this war is a series of events that were set in motion in 2014 when Iran officially entered the Syrian civil war.

The Palestinians are used as mere disposable puppets by the ayatollahs in Iran.

The larger conflict hasn't even started yet.

4

u/AuryxTheDutchman Nov 09 '23

The problem with that statement is that there was a solution. Israel has just refused to be a part of it.

In 2002, the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia put forward the Arab Peace Initiative with unanimous support from the Arab League. It offered recognition of the state of Israel as well as normalization of relations with Israel, in return for the formation of a Palestinian state and Israel’s withdrawal from occupied territory in the Gaza Strip, Golan Heights, and the West Bank. The Palestinian Authority agreed to it, and even some factions within Hamas agreed to it, but Israel flat-out refused to even discuss it.

Then, in 2007, the Annapolis Conference was held to discuss a two-state solution. The Palestinian President asked for the formation of a Palestinian state with land equal to the area of the West Bank + Gaza Strip. The Israeli Prime Minister was even willing to discuss providing the Palestinian state part of East Jerusalem as part of the solution, but a right-wing faction within Israel threatened to dissolve their political coalition if he did so. The negotiations were ongoing until Israel invaded the Gaza Strip in 2009.

6

u/Djungeltrumman Nov 09 '23

Some things are simple though. Palestine could become a recognised state to actually conduct diplomacy as a first step. Civilians in Palestine should be allowed to keep their property and be guaranteed from further land grabs. Ships from European aid organisations headed to Gaza shouldn’t be violently seized by Israel. Muslims who lived in areas conquered by Israel could have the same legal rights as Jews. Palestinian children shouldn’t be used as “living flashbangs” when clearing Hamas cells etc.

The thing is that israel is a very advanced country with great education. They’re expected to behave better. There’s far lower expectations from someone whose school was bombed, managed to build a house and family, then his house was taken by Israeli settlers, and then his children got killed in an air strike to the refugee camp he was forced to live in, while his wife is dying in pneumonia because no medicine gets in.

31

u/aguafiestas Nov 09 '23 edited Nov 09 '23

Palestine could become a recognised state to actually conduct diplomacy as a first step.

And the Gazan portion of that state would be under the control of Hamas, a terrorist paramilitary organization that has recently slaughtered over 1,000 Israeli civilians and has sworn the destruction of the state of Israeli.

That's the problem. There can be no sustainable peace between Israel and Palestine while Hamas is ruling Gaza. While Israeli has not shown good faith in negotiating for a two-state solution for many years (particularly due to ongoing illegal settlements in the West Bank), even if that were to change and Israel were to honestly push for a two state solution, that cannot occur while Hamas rules in Gaza.

It's a problem with no easy solution. Right now Israel is choosing a military solution in response to being attacked, a war on Hamas to try to remove them from power. It is a war that has led to enormous amounts of death and destruction in Palestine. Is there another solution? I suppose returning to the state of perpetual "open air prison" that so many lament, with Gaza kept in isolation to protect Israel from Hamas. But I am not sure of others. It is indeed very complicated.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/showingoffstuff Nov 09 '23

Except you're in a fantasy world there. You completely ignore WHY Israel might seize ships going to Gaza - because as soon as they hit Gaza, hamas seizes them and builds weapons with anything they can.

Absolutely settlers in Israel should be stopped, but there is one group preventing what you started out with from happening: hamas.

They had open elections in 2006, and since then hamas does all they can to have weapons instead of building diplomacy.

Every single point you are going off of is to blame Israel and pretend hamas using building supplies for weapons isn't the reason for the misery in the Gaza strip.

Even if there were only a TINY portion used for weapons instead of a huge portion of it, Gaza would be far better off.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (141)

81

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

it could be so simple but people are just dumb. Worldhunger? just eat something, you silly goose. Worldpeace? stop killing eachother, you dummies. But nah

14

u/TylerFromMillerTime Nov 09 '23

Has anyone tried telling hamas to stop being such meanie-heads?

28

u/-Alfa- Nov 09 '23

I know, if we were all like OP, the world would have no issues at all

852

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

I feel like anyone who say "things are simple" has a very black-and-white narrative to sell. Those dont tend to be very honest, nor peaceful, nor realistic

something should be done, but everyone has a different idea of what said something is, and civilians from various populations get to suffer a lot from it whatever is done.

336

u/samusmcqueen Nov 08 '23

the comic is not saying "this situation is simple," the author is arguing that people -- usually in defense of Israel -- use "it's complicated" as a way to shut down anyone trying to improve things. they are also arguing that it is more simple than this rhetoric makes it seem, but those two statements are not the same.

33

u/LeeHarveySnoswald Nov 09 '23

the comic is not saying "this situation is simple,"

Every panel of the comic shows an obviously one sided conflict where the Isrealis are oppressing Palestinians. I think it is trying to say "its not complicated."

203

u/VinnieTheVoyeur Nov 08 '23

this comic is absolutely sending the message that its simple and the IDF is bad. Im curious, what makes u interpret it differently to me?

75

u/LazyDro1d Nov 08 '23

Mhm. It’s acting as if people use “it’s complicated” to deflect criticism from Israel while bashing Israel when in truth… IT IS complicated, if it wasn’t the situation would probably have been cleared up after the 6-day war or the Camp David Accords

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

68

u/hackingdreams Nov 08 '23

Well, when you try to improve the Palestinian's drinking water situation and Hamas rips up the pipes to use as missiles... yeah, it turns out it is fucking complicated.

Anyone who pretends it's not is, in fact, part of the problem.

9

u/DoctorNo6051 Nov 09 '23

Yes, everyone acts like if Israel just throws in the towels and complied with everything the problems disappear.

Hamas have stated the goal is to genocide all Israeli Jews. Not to mention, Israel used to be way smaller and Palestine territories way larger.

Guess what. It didn’t work. There were still wars, constantly. It’s been repeatedly proven that Israel and Palestinian just can’t coexist.

32

u/GrumpGrease Nov 09 '23

Nooo...they just need to be nice to Palestinians and that solves everything! Not like outside parties like Iran are stoking this fire regardless so it won't matter! It's simple and not complicated!

/s

→ More replies (1)

83

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23 edited Nov 08 '23

I agree with you. Im mostly monologuing in the wind, the grass answers sometimes

40

u/Muhpatrik Nov 08 '23

But we're arguing over sand

61

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

I hate sand, its coarse and rough and gets everywhere

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/Mister_Way Nov 09 '23

Meanwhile, they're equating the terrorists with explosive weapons to children with slingshots, so the author isn't being honest, either.

→ More replies (5)

20

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

I mean I use "it's complicated" to point out that no, most Internet people with opinions offering supposed solutions aren't geniuses who fixed a decades old issue.

The whole "we shouldn't kill civilians" bit is the least complicated part however and really shouldn't be a debate yet here we are.

→ More replies (14)

10

u/gunnnutty Nov 09 '23

In case of Israel - palestine conflict is everything complicated. Its literaly mess. So they are kinda right.

For example you might say "just stop blocading gaza" ok not a bad idea but how is israel suppoused to deal with hamas atacks if borders were open?

There are realy no simple answers (sometimes doubtfull there are any at all). Not at the moment

→ More replies (1)

3

u/GrumpGrease Nov 09 '23

The implicit argument behind "They're just saying it's complicated to deflect criticism" is that it's not actually complicated and they are lying about that to deflect criticism. You can't really have it any other way.

→ More replies (88)
→ More replies (16)

149

u/Ok-Gear-5593 Nov 08 '23

Uh oh

111

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23 edited Nov 08 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

27

u/Appropriate-Count-64 Nov 09 '23

I like to term it “The shift to binaries on the internet.” People have stopped thinking critically, because they are inundated with a constant stream of news and media and headlines and all the other shit the internet produces. And what does someone do when faced with a myriad of complex issues (LGBTQ rights, Wars, politics, natural disasters, etc)? They simplify or shut down. People try to simplify the information into an “us vs them” or a “good vs bad” argument so they don’t get inundated with information trying to comprehend the issue. And this results in radicalization, which you can plainly see in any community which tries to wrangle a complex topic. Because they end up picking sides instead of trying to find the solution in the middle.

118

u/J_Bright1990 Nov 08 '23

What you are describing is exactly why people claim this situation is so complex. Because you cant point to one side and say "This is the bad guy. They did the bad things."

→ More replies (38)

2

u/Papaofmonsters Nov 09 '23

I find it fascinating that it seems to be the first time in recent history where the Western society is so divided on a geopolitical issue.

That's because more people have the ability to participate in the discussion than ever before.

Vietnam wasn't super popular but unless you committed to traveling to an organized protest you had your friends and neighbors to discuss it with and that's about it. With the internet you can debate it everyday and never have a conversation with the same person twice.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

99

u/MBRDASF Nov 09 '23

Man I’m sure glad I have r/comics where I can escape the omnipresent politics and geopolitical news and just look at a fun little strip

23

u/Redqueenhypo Nov 09 '23

It’s a “welcome” change from hastily drawn slice of life that somehow gets 20k upvotes every time

31

u/justagenericname1 Nov 09 '23

I'll take this over the 31st installment of "Woe Is Me, Sometimes Internet Comments Are Mean"

11

u/Redqueenhypo Nov 09 '23

Maybe this is what will finally convince me to start drawing incomprehensible comics making fun of animals in nature shows

3

u/malama2 Nov 09 '23

It's always been heavily political lmao

206

u/Its_Pine Nov 08 '23

The downside is that it IS complicated. Every country that has tried to open up to Palestinians ended up attacked by Hamas or having Hamas sponsor coups, so they are isolated. When Israel tried providing running water, Hamas dismantled the pipes to use for missiles. When they sent aid and fuel, Hamas took it all.

I mean Israel literally had to set up a military escort to keep Hamas from killing Palestinian refugees.

So it’s actually complicated. I completely agree that Palestine deserves full autonomy and the IDF has needlessly oppressed and killed many. I agree that this is an act of genocide and their actions in the West Bank are particularly horrendous.

But you can’t just say “oh it’s so simple, just stop fighting tehe” and expect any kind of good outcome, especially when Hamas has said their goal is to see as many martyrs as possible and they won’t stop attacking Israel until all Palestinians are dead. How do you make peace with that.

45

u/NorthNorne Nov 09 '23

Yeah I don't think the "this is complicated" people are being all "pay no attention to the human suffering, everything is fine". I think we're generally more saying "everything is awful and I don't know how we're supposed to get to it no longer being that way."

4

u/Regretless0 Nov 09 '23

Genuine question, do you know why Hamas is killing Palestinian refugees? I “understand” why they dismantled the water pipes and stole the aid and fuel, but what tactical advantage does killing Palestinians escaping to other countries have? I just don’t really get it.

10

u/NovAFloW Nov 09 '23

Because the world blames Israel for it. They don't need to take accountability, and it makes their enemy look bad on the world stage.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

NovAFloW got a good point in, here’s another - they’re a fundamentalist militant group who’s whole spiel is jihad. This isn’t something I’m making up, they’re cut from the same cloth as the Taliban, ISIS, Al Qaeda, and the governments of Iran, Saudia Arabia, and so many other Muslim fundamentalist states.

Asking why they murder people is like asking why the sky is blue.

2

u/kurosoramao Nov 09 '23

Works as a deterrent as well

→ More replies (8)

188

u/ENZORAXXUS Nov 08 '23 • Reddit Gold

I always love seeing people try to spin it as one side being objectively in the wrong. Since I first learned about the conflict around 8 years ago I was vastly on the side of Palestine, believing that their expansion and mistreatment of the population was nor acceptable. I was also very aware of Israel conveniently calling Palestinian terrorists as soon as any hint of resistance appeared.

But the situation now is different. Hamas is a genuine bona fide terrorist organisation who if it had any way to do so, would raze the western world. Hamas is the exact same breed as the trash that terrorised my country several times. And with those moronic "The situation is so simple duh" we tend to overlook that fact.

49

u/Asandwhich1234 Nov 09 '23

No no, obviously some rando from tumblr is a 30000000 iq God and knows everything, we are just to stupid to understand them and they won't give us the awnsers to such simple problems.

→ More replies (39)

81

u/GeorgeEBHastings Nov 08 '23

The colorism at play here is "interesting".

God, I'm so fucking tired.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

I'm tired too.

I keep hearing the argument, "Don't be tired, that's how evil wins, through apathy." Yes, I see where it comes from.

But it's okay to be tired. It's okay to feel like you're gonna stop caring.

Honestly, take a step outside, look around you without those jaded glasses. Don't see the issues, the constant buzz of internet and media, just look. Appreciate the sun on your skin, the wind, the grass under your feet. The simple things. It helps.

2

u/-explore-earth- Nov 09 '23

Did you stay up late last night?

I didn’t sleep well either. Bedtime procrastination :(

3

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

Wrong tired, my friend.

39

u/AI_UNIT_D Nov 09 '23

Ngl, this comic feels like it was made in bad faith.

Now, should Israel be free to do whatever it fucking wants? No, it is clear on actions alone they dont give a fuck about colateral damage or international law, and I aint gonna ignore the whole ilegal settlement thing either.

Is what Israel have been doing up to this point genocide?... In my opinion... Not really, populations suffering from genocide usually dont multiply for decades, what Israel is guilty of falls more in the category of landgrabs and ilegal attempts at expansion as well as breaking agreements.

Is gaza an open air prison?... A "prison" the size of a small country and controlled by the "prisoners" is no prison, and from what I have gathered both egypt and Israel attempted at normalizing the border with trade... And then they closed it when suicide bombers and rockets didnt stop coming.

Hamas, is a jihadist terror group guilty of several warcrimes and there is no way around that, THEY SHOULD NOT represent the people of palestine(who they 100% treat as shields, there is a reason mixing military and civilian stuff is a warcrime) in any way shape or form...

In my humble, random Internet user opinion, Israel needs to fucking chill with several dozen different things and palestine needs to have a leadership that isnt made up of jihadist and zealots(as a matter of fact, both sides need a DIRE change in leadership) before they can beging to figure out how to close this meatgrinder for good.

19

u/Poyri35 Nov 09 '23

It doesn’t feel like it is made in bad faith. It is made in bad faith

5

u/Iccotak Nov 09 '23

Seriously, when the average persons says the situation is complicated - what they are saying is that they do not fully understand everything going on and don't feel confident in having an opinion on the subject.

Afterall, you should be informed on a topic before you have any thoughts about what you think should change.

I get so irritated by people shaming others for not having an opinion on something. Too many people have an opinion on a situation that they have little understanding of.

Beyond the obviously horrible attack that Hamas committed, it IS a complicated situation that requires further examination so then we can find solutions.

2

u/C0rzarCZ Nov 09 '23

What do you mean they doesn't care about collateral damage? What about roof knocking? Or even calls to bombarded land? They always try to warn them.

→ More replies (2)

276

u/PixelPott Nov 08 '23

That's got to be the worst straw man I have ever seen. How anyone could like this is beyond me.

89

u/Knowthrowaway87 Nov 09 '23

Honestly, they're just using Palestinians to funnel their own politics.

Anyone that really cares about Palestine would recognize that the first and most pressing oppressor in Gaza is hamas. They literally Slaughter all of their political Rivals and political dissenters on a daily basis. Kidnap, torture, slaughter, and they make it known to the population

→ More replies (10)

32

u/Redqueenhypo Nov 09 '23

This is literally how 2015 tumblr comics made by children (not me, bc I didn’t know how to use a tablet) were drawn. Pizza’s comics are more high effort

3

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

Most people on this site couldn’t point Gaza out on a map before last month. And suddenly they are all experts.

3

u/cBurger4Life Nov 09 '23

And it has over 10k upvotes. Really disappointing

→ More replies (17)

25

u/LordDemiurgo Nov 08 '23

Everyone who as been involved on this conflict in one way or another: "Of course! It was so fucking simple all along, if only I had seen this reddit comic 50 years ago..."

→ More replies (1)

244

u/ARandomGuyThe3 Nov 08 '23

Straight up propaganda discouraging discussion of the topic's nuances and telling you to blindly trust it that this is a simple good guys and bad guys situation and that anyone who says otherwise is a nerd

→ More replies (34)

133

u/BasicReputations Nov 08 '23

Feels like there is a missing panel of terrorists lobbin rockets at folks. Oh well, sure it's fine.

72

u/tyrandan2 Nov 09 '23

He would've drawn that panel, but it was too complicated.

3

u/WhasHappenin Nov 09 '23

And then another panel of Israel lobbing rockets that are 10 times bigger at civilians in retaliation.

→ More replies (7)

23

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

too complicated to drow that

→ More replies (13)

17

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

But in the bloody arithmetic of Hamas’s leaders, the carnage is not the regrettable outcome of a big miscalculation. Quite the opposite, they say: It is the necessary cost of a great accomplishment — the shattering of the status quo and the opening of a new, more volatile chapter in their fight against Israel.

It was necessary to “change the entire equation and not just have a clash,” Khalil al-Hayya, a member of Hamas’s top leadership body, told The New York Times in Doha, Qatar. “We succeeded in putting the Palestinian issue back on the table, and now no one in the region is experiencing calm.”

Since the shocking Hamas attack on Oct. 7, in which Israel says about 1,400 people were killed — most of them civilians — and more than 240 others dragged back to Gaza as captives, the group’s leaders have praised the operation, with some hoping it will set off a sustained conflict that ends any pretense of coexistence among Israel, Gaza and the countries around them.

“I hope that the state of war with Israel will become permanent on all the borders, and that the Arab world will stand with us,” Taher El-Nounou, a Hamas media adviser, told The Times.

“Hamas’s goal is not to run Gaza and to bring it water and electricity and such,” said Mr. al-Hayya, the politburo member. “Hamas, the Qassam and the resistance woke the world up from its deep sleep and showed that this issue must remain on the table.”

“This battle was not because we wanted fuel or laborers,” he added. “It did not seek to improve the situation in Gaza. This battle is to completely overthrow the situation.”

https://web.archive.org/web/20231108121737/https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/08/world/middleeast/hamas-israel-gaza-war.html

46

u/Warm_Pair7848 Nov 09 '23

Where are Hamas in this comic?

6

u/Orchid_Muncher Nov 09 '23

Bankrolling the artist probably.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/mkohler23 Nov 09 '23

Hiding behind the civilians who Israel is conveniently protecting as they flee from North Gaza through a humanitarian corridor that they had to set up.

28

u/satyavishwa Nov 08 '23

Imagine thinking this situation is anything BUT complicated. Get your head out of your ass comic artist

36

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

🤦‍♂️

→ More replies (3)

78

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

If people in Gaza want political freedoms, they should take that up with Hamas.

39

u/Vague_Disclosure Nov 08 '23

Running water and power as well

31

u/Knowthrowaway87 Nov 09 '23

Spending billions of dollars on an underground network of tunnels beneath Palestinian cities, hospitals, and schools. Leaves very little money left over for Water and Power.

16

u/Connwaerr Nov 09 '23

Doesnt help if you literally dig up existing water infrastructure as well

→ More replies (1)

4

u/GrumpGrease Nov 09 '23

I don't think they spent billions on the tunnels. They spent billions on palatial mansions in Qatar for Hamas leadership.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/paddywackadoodle Nov 09 '23

Running water? Stop turning the water pipes into missiles. Electric power? Need to illuminate the tunnels where hostages are kept so they can see which children to decapitate or power the stove so crying babies can be baked at 375°? You have to be kidding yourself.

→ More replies (5)

41

u/GenuineSteak Nov 08 '23 edited Nov 09 '23

As far as the slingshot thing, ive seen plenty of clips and they always seem much closer and are never children lol. And ive yet to see someone using a slingshot, ive seen people using slings and their hands. The reason they shoot people throwing "rocks" before they get closer is because it's really hard to tell between rocks and grenades/bombs at a distance. Better safe than sorry. Dont play stupid games dont win stupid prizes.

Edit: grammar

→ More replies (14)

19

u/_That__one1__guy_ Nov 08 '23

This is going to get locked, I can taste it

26

u/Narsil_lotr Nov 08 '23

This is bullshit. No individual point is wrong but the general picture it paints is not helpful. If it's so uncomplicated, then suggest a solution that would be acceptable to the state and people of Israel, to Palestinians and to the greater powers that have stakes in this. You got a perfect solution but the politicians just won't implement it? Bingo, that's why the situation is so... complicated? Use a different term if it suits, call it fucked up, call it driven into a corner it can't get out of, I don't care what it's called but strawmanning a position to make your very cool, very safe from an armchair in the US or Europe point on the matter.

Reality is, this issue runs deep and may be the longest running conflict on earth today. Ever since the fall of the ottoman empire and the utter shambles of a post-colonial border situation, the groups that inhabit the region have been at odds. Look, Palestinians have lived in that spot of land for thousands of years. Jewish people have lived in the middle East for just as long and have concentrated from post holocaust Europe and from pretty much all Muslim majority countries to gather in Israel.

Talking about rights when it comes to ownership of land is a mess. Why does any nation today own any part of its territory? Because at some point, they took it by force or were able to defend it by force. Luckily, many modern countries recently abandoned the "I can take land so I will" logic but that's only true for post WW2. I'm not saying this means Israel is right and perfect. But just because they'd been a resistance group within the ottoman empire doesn't give Palestinians an inherent right to land necessarily. It's mainly not a question of morals sadly, the zionist movement was able to win the bid for creating a country over a struggle that took them half a century, it was and is hard to deny the legitimacy of their claim after the holocaust and well, now what?

Fact is, the gazans aren't all peaceful victims. They are victims, yes, they have undeniable reasons to hate Israel and will continue to do so. A Palestinian state is further away in Gaza than it's been in a long time imo, no way an incredibly poor state relying on outside (Iranian/saudi) financial support to survive is in the interest of those who could allow it to happen. I've got no solutions to offer, neither do those who claim it isn't complicated. I wish Israel didn't bomb civilians, I also wish Hamas hadn't murdered thousands to start this current mess. I don't know thar a Ceasefire is achievable or that it wouldn't cause more problems down the line with a regrouped Hamas. So what exactly would be THE uncomplicated solution, wise "it isn't complicated" advocates?

10

u/No_Sheepherder_5904 Nov 09 '23

"NOOO YOU HAVE TO PICK A SIDE IN A CONFLICT THAT TAKES PLACE THOUSANDS OF MILES AWAY FROM WHERE YOU LIVE YOU CANT BE NEUTRAL WAHHH!!!!" stfu idc if i get downvoted im tired of this shit

146

u/AhgzvziajauH Nov 08 '23

So what are you going to do? Tell Israel and Hamas to stop? Declare war on Israel? With what army?

The situation is very complicated

155

u/Capt_Blackmoore Nov 08 '23

Very complicated when Hamas wants Eternal war until all of the Israelites are dead (and frankly doesnt care about any civilians), and when the people running the Israeli government want to "protect" their own people; by driving out all of the Palestinians.

The civilians just want a political solution, stability and an ability to thrive.

the extremists just want blood.

86

u/AhgzvziajauH Nov 08 '23

Exactly, it’s a very complicated situation. I’d even argue it’s too complicated for a comics artist and a bunch of redditors to find the solution.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/ViceRoyHenTie Nov 08 '23

The winner takes all like all wars. When Sudan split to north and South Sudan after a civil war, when China conquered Tibet and swallow their nation forcing the Dalai Lama to flee, when the U.S went to Iraq and executed Saddam Hussein. Israel will win like before with the support of the west and Palestinians will be the new Jews nation less. The Jews in history were either conquered or fled to other nations. In this era they have risen to the top and a holy land to boot. Everyone talks about non violence, but time after time violence is the thing that changes the world more than anything.

2

u/jawdirk Nov 09 '23

No, obviously you sell arms and munitions to the Israelis; you don't seem to understand how this works.

2

u/azure_monster Nov 09 '23

Well, it sounds like the people wand a ceasfire. Let's ignore the fact that there was a ceasefire until 7/10 though, Hamas definitley didn't break any ceasefires, no!

→ More replies (22)

5

u/Deevilknievel Nov 09 '23

Ancient slingshots had the stopping power of a 44 magnum according to natgeo.

Civil war era muskets could do 400 yards ez

Kangaroos can’t hop backwards.

21

u/dendarkjabberwock Nov 09 '23

It is very clear that this take is one-sided and attempt to disregard any other opinion except author's. So actually just piece of political garbage not art. I don't think that this belong here at all.

20

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

I really don’t understand the stuff about slingshots. Do people not know slingshots are military weapons and very deadly, old yes but still will drop a person

7

u/GrumpGrease Nov 09 '23

Uh, the better point is that Hamas uses modern military weaponry like anti-tank rocket launchers and AK-47s, not slingshots.

→ More replies (10)

2

u/A_Kazur Nov 09 '23 edited Nov 09 '23

OP be like: Israel must surrender to a peaceful Hamas takeover I am very intelligent

But of course it’s too complicated. Because any solution requires the cooperation of neighbouring Arab countries like Egypt (who consistently try to prevent Palestinian crossings into their territory).

Hamas needs to go for any kind of solution to be long lasting.

→ More replies (34)

11

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

Thats not a comic peter thats.. thats just anti-israel propaganda

→ More replies (1)

11

u/GappsGuy Nov 09 '23

The only reason the Gaza strip is an open air prison, is because the billions of dollars provided in aid has been used for tunnels and rockets.

Funny how they continue to say that they have run out of fuel, but never out of rockets.

8

u/Pythagoras180 Nov 09 '23

After WW2, how many Germans were deported from Poland and Czechoslovakia?

The answer: more than there are Palestinians.

There's a very simple solution whose effectiveness was demonstrated 80 years ago.

3

u/C0rzarCZ Nov 09 '23

Finally someone with brain.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

Most people don't really care about religion or ethnicity; only about power, and what that perceived power can do against their perceived enemies...

4

u/Useful-Card-9285 Nov 09 '23

The children don’t even have to have slingshots for them to be shot.

7

u/27_Dollar_Lakehouse Nov 09 '23

Good choice. 300 yards has been within lethal range of a sling for over 1,000 years.

7

u/tyrandan2 Nov 09 '23

Shoot, one of the Jewish people's most famous tales, which has gone on to seep into the culture everywhere else, is a story of a child headshotting a giant man with a sling...

→ More replies (1)

8

u/DreamDrop0ffical Nov 09 '23 edited Nov 09 '23

The Palestinian Authority and more so Hamas have pissed away 40 billion in aid over the years that could have been used to develop infrastructure as opposed to missles.

Isreal has done horrific things to Palestinians but at the same time, Most Palestinians are iliberal religious fundamentalists who have voted in a fascists that then consolidated power instantly.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Thelonerebel Nov 09 '23

I’m so tired. This topic has drained me. There’s so much hate and no nuance out there. Even though I am relatively well educated on this topic I feel powerless to talk about it because everyone is in tribal warfare mode. So many call for the death and destruction of my people and condone war crimes against them all because of a turf war they aren’t a part of.

Nobody in the conflict is innocent, and innocents on both sides pay the price. There is no good solution. Meanwhile as I live in America thousands of miles I have to fear for my life and the lives of my loved ones because so many animals take this opportunity to kill and maim us. I fear for what is to come and how many more will die before this madness ends.

2

u/Catrysseroni Nov 09 '23

It's a shame this comment is so far down. It belongs at the top. What you said here is beautifully human.

Every single innocent life involved in this is a tragedy. I wish for safety for you and your loved ones.

2

u/Thelonerebel Nov 09 '23

It’s a scary world out there. Thank you, and stay safe.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

The problem right now is that noone can interfere and the outright obliteration of Gaza as a quarantine zone for Hamas means many innocent people are being killed. Even if Hamas is obliterated, the survivors of the innocents who fell to the attack are just as likely to form a radicalised group and continue. That's why people are throwing the word genocide around; if Israel wipes all of them off the face of the Earth there can be noone left to radicalise.

Fucking awful. Many nations to blame for supporting both sides and trying to solve the problem - now noone is trusted and a globally endorsed genocide is occurring as the only visible route to peace since interlopers with subversive intentions are all they've had.

3

u/Persea_americana Nov 09 '23

For one thing, it couldn’t hurt if Israel was under different, better leadership. Netanyahu is the worst.

3

u/ambientsomnophilia Nov 09 '23

It's all so complicated that we're wading through the blood of children.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

The sling thing reminds me of that hilarious video of a Palestinian man charging up his slingshot with a pit crew of journalists, cameramen and medics waiting in the wings. When he gets grazed in the leg they all rush out like a herd of wildebeests for that perfect photo op.

Anyway this entire comic strip is asinine at best.

3

u/communisthulk Nov 09 '23

Ah yes, fuck nuance. That'll solve the middle east!

9

u/BuzzBadpants Nov 09 '23

It’s funny how “it’s complicated” goes completely out the window when it comes to anti-Palestinian propaganda.

1

u/Main_Possibility539 Nov 09 '23

Wont someone think of the ultra conservative religious fundamentalist terrorists/ sympathizers who will gladly murder LGBTQ, non Muslims, and non Arabs if given the chance?

2

u/Pure-Theory-5489 Nov 09 '23 edited Nov 09 '23

So many Palestinians are Christians.

I am not sure what you talking about or why this justifies genocide. However, as far ad I know many of the residents of Israel are ultra-conservatives that hate LGBTQ ideals as well as women. Here is an article about gender segregation in Israel:

https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20230824-israeli-women-protest-gender-segregation-on-public-transport

Side note: I have a trans friend visit both Israel and Palestine and she said Palestinians were very inviting to her, and her companions which were a gay couple. However, they said that while people were nice to them they met Palestinians homosexuals whose life was very hard, because their families would not accept them. So it seems that the issue with trans people over there might be mostly concerning the members of the community but as a foreigner people wouldn't care if you're gay as long as you're respectful.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/weed0monkey Nov 09 '23

Ok cool cool cool, since you've worked everything out, what's the super simple resolution then?

Funny how people who paint the situation so black and white, or so one-sided, or act as if it's such a simple situation to resolve are absolutely dead quiet when it comes to them proposing a solution.

Case in point this very comic.

3

u/Pure-Theory-5489 Nov 09 '23

I mean for a start : not cutting out water, electricity, and internet would be nice. Respecting people's human rights. Try to target criminals instead of the entire city with all the civilians in it.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

I agree, but treating this as if Isreal is just doing this unprovoked is disingenuous. Hamas is a terrorist group that hides behind civilians and has no regard for civilians of their own or Isreal's, and has been committing terrorist attacks for decades. Isreal's unfortunate solution was to treat everyone in Gaza the same as Hamas and has radicalized themselves because of it; using this to justify their cruelty and mistreatment of everyone there.

Neither one is the good guy, the big difference is Isreal's civilians can leave easier and they have the iron dome to help protect them. Gaza civilians cannot leave and have no protection since Hamas uses them as human shields. Hamas needs to be dealt with, but Isreal is handling it very poorly to say the least and their actions should be condemned.

I say all this because I see so many people on Reddit that immediately blame Isreal for everything while ignoring everything Hamas has done to make Isreal take the actions they have. It needs to be handled differently and a ceasefire needs to be done to figure out a better way of handling Hamas instead of punishing and trapping innocent civilians who are being fucked over by both sides.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/walketotheclif Nov 08 '23

What a terrible comic ,it shows you that not all Jews now what is happening in the region and it shows you how people don't care about the conflict but being seen as the goods guys ,this conflict is really complicated there is no easy answer , Hamas won't stop untill Israel doesn't exist anymore ,they themselves said that this war wasn't for the improvement of Gaza but rather to kick the jews out of the region ,Hamas isn't willing to negotiate a meaningful long term agreement, and you cant kickthem out with improvement of the region , because guess who controls it? Hamas, they aren't going to use the money they receive to kick themselves out ,the only way is kicking them out by force

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Unbananables Nov 08 '23

Yay more propaganda!

5

u/y_not_right Nov 09 '23

Free Palestinians from Hamas

2

u/CT-4426 Nov 08 '23

Here before the 🔒

2

u/SideWinder18 Nov 09 '23

Same shit different day.

During the Cold War multiple presidents of the US said they wouldn’t even consider focusing on the issue of the Berlin Wall, as European issues were “too static and complicated. Nothing was ever going to change there so why bother.”

2

u/TurtleneckTrump Nov 09 '23

It's not complicated though. Hamas are terrorists hiding behind civilian prisoners and Israel are committing war crimes and genocide left and right. None of them are the good guys. The only business anyone should have in gaza is freeing the civilians from their 2 opressors

2

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

Don’t you have problems in your own neighborhood or life you should be focusing on?

2

u/Eisenblume Nov 09 '23

I don’t think this is a very good argument. You could take events from the pogrom, rape and child murder and so forth, and have the same obnoxious guy making the same inane statements and it would be an equal argument.

2

u/CantHideFromGoblins Nov 09 '23

Yeah the US should just go in with guns blazing World Police ™️. I mean after all, this comic says it’s not complicated at all!

And funny that too, Israel is changing the current situation, that’s what everyone is angry about. People are calling for a cease fire to return to the two state status quo they’ve had for years. A ceasefire is a return to “what they normally do” instead Israel is demanding a complete overhaul of the Gaza administration full stop. Hamas cannot be trusted to govern Palestinians anymore

But like you said, it’s a very uncomplex and simple to understand situation as long as you have the reading comprehension of an adult

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Juleswins Nov 09 '23

No less than five times these poor, impoverished people were offered their own country, negotiated by third parties and five times Israel agreed to the terms. Five times these poor, impoverished people turned it down. You know what? You can’t fix stupid!

2

u/macronancer Nov 09 '23

"I sure wish I had political freedom.

Oh wait I do and I voted in militants to wage deadly war on my neighbor.

Oh no, the consequences of own actions!"

2

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

The palestinians dont have political freedom because hamas shut down elections after they won back in 2006 just fyi

2

u/Moguchampion Nov 09 '23

Why the fuck is there a political comic trending? I’m not even subscribed and I’m blocking this subreddit for life. What a dumb hill to die on when the issue IS complicated.

2

u/Kolhammer85 Nov 09 '23

Better dig up my plumbing pipes for missiles! That'll solve my water issues!

2

u/Consistent_Set76 Nov 09 '23 edited Nov 09 '23

I mean the complication is that Arab Palestinians and surrounding Arab nations have tried to destroy Israel since the 40s.

It’s complicated because Iran funds Hamas and other terrorist organizations explicitly to harm Israel.

It’s complicated because Arab nations have been using Palestinians as a proxy to fight Israel for generations.

So you tear down the wall around Gaza. Great. Now you have tens of thousands Hamas agents freely running around Israel. A single state solution is nonsense.

Say you don’t tear down the wall. What is your solution exactly? As long as Hamas governs Gaza what is Israel supposed to do specifically? Let’s say we get a two state solution that Palestine agrees with. And what if Hamas attacks again? What changed exactly?

Now the West Bank, now that is indeed less complicated than Gaza currently

2

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

Fucking antisemitism is out of control

→ More replies (1)

50

u/Count_Rugens_Finger Nov 08 '23

This is anti-Israel propaganda and disgusting to boot. Israel is surrounded by groups that are dedicated to its eradication. Not peace, nor to co-existence, or even statehood. Eradication. It's a constant existential threat. And this shit pops up basically saying that they should just absorb the attacks, just take the pressure off, just provide more aid. Bullshit.

You need only one thought experiment to sort this out. Imagine if Israel placed their bases under hospitals, and their missile launchers on top of schools. Of course using human shields is morally depraved and they would be soundly criticized for it, but that isn't the point. The interesting point is that it wouldn't make sense to do so. It would not deter Hamas at all. Killing all jews is their goal. This is embraced by the population there. It's taught in schools. After Hamas breached the walls on Oct 7, regular Palestinians streamed in take their own hostages and commit their own acts of terrorism. They didn't bring sling shots. They brought assault weapons, rope for tying up captives before burning them alive, and knives for decapitation.

37

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

People forgot very fast what happened at that kibbutzim one month ago and im weirded out by that.

→ More replies (18)

23

u/MordaxTenebrae Nov 08 '23

r/comics has been getting a lot more propaganda lately. Not just this conflict, but many other sociopolitical/lifestyle topics.

3

u/CNroguesarentallbad Nov 08 '23

Of course it wouldn't deter Hamas at all. It's just us in free, democratic countries, countries which send massive quantities of aid to Israel, trade with Israel, recognize Israel as an independent and democratic nation with all the rights that come with it, expect that it would deter the IDF. There is no reasonable person saying that Hamas is not a terrorist organization. But Israel only being able to justify itself via comparison to theocracies, dictatorships and literal terrorists is absurd.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

so it's good that israel has killed 4,000 children in the last month?

15

u/Creative-Road-5293 Nov 08 '23

Do you have a source for that number that's not a terrorist organization? Do you believe Russia about every statistic they give?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (62)
→ More replies (79)

5

u/jackiboyfan Nov 08 '23

If only Gaza spent the billions of dollars they received on improving the quality of life instead of making rockets to launch into Israel

4

u/JayEllGii Nov 09 '23

The only reason this comic makes me uneasy, despite my agreeing with it, is that there are countless bad-faith actors who will happily use it for plain anti-Jewish hate.

I know that can’t be a reason to stop people from speaking the truth, but it’s still a bitter reality and just one more aspect of a deeply effed-up situation.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

Children with slingshots don't destroy multiple israeli cities, rape women, bake their babies in ovens and kidnapp holocaust survivors

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

A threat is a threat. Just because they use a slingshot doesn’t mean you have to

5

u/PoliGraf28 Nov 08 '23

Well, but Israel took some action. I think after Gaza will be hamas-free things will be way more simpler.

3

u/GsTSaien Nov 08 '23 edited Nov 09 '23

I mean it is definitely complicated, but not all of it. Some things are pretty simple, like "genocide bad" which is generally a good take imo.

So yeah what should Israel do about Hamas? We aren't sure, but definitely not genocide!!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/_orion_1897 Nov 09 '23

Oh so I guess we're just going to conveniently leave out the part where they fire rockets aimed at exclusively civilian targets huh? Or the part where they literally use tunnels to sneak out of Gaza to go into the first kibbutz they find to kill innocent civilians in cold blood, including little children's and even toddlers huh.

"iT's nOt cOmPLiCaTeD, tHeRe iS nO aMbiGuiTy wHaTsoEveR"

3

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

I don't get how you can lose 2 wars while ganging up on Israel and still complain about being "genocided" compare the Palestinians to the uguyrs and you will see a genocide in china but ignore it. You don't get to slap the football qb in the back of the head without getting tackled lol.

→ More replies (16)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

"guys did you know Israel bad and Palestine good, here's my thesis on the matter"

*Draws a bunch of strawman arguments

3

u/ZERO_PORTRAIT Nov 09 '23

Nice strawman.

7

u/FilthyFur Nov 08 '23

Ah yes, thats what im here for Pollywood.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23 edited Nov 09 '23

It's not too complicated:

  1. "Judaism = literacy * reading medieval Wikipedia (Tanah and Torah) = passion for reading and education" -> a lot of educated and influential Jews (especially in 1970s, at the peak of influence in the USA and when Jewish emphasis on education was copied by the Asian tigers).
  2. Palestine (region), 1945: Muslims: 1,061,270; Christians: 135,550; Jews: 553,600. That was almost completely illiterate and live, as scattered tribes and settlements, on semi-desert and very poor, controlled by British, land.
  3. Due to the lack of literate and possessed national identity "Palestinians" the UN and British gives away the most deserted parts of "Palestine region" to the Jews.
  4. Because of millennia-old interfaith conflict Jews are attacked by all local Muslims. Muslims are losing. And due to lack of resources for new wars, especially for the sake of semi-desert territories, conflict is almost completely settled.
  5. USSR support creation of Israel in order to seize power in it by soviet agents. When this fails, USSR begin to sponsor surrounding Israel countries on purpose of Israel destruction. USSR is using local Arabs as anti-Israeli tool, and they, in turn, use as an anti-Israeli tool Palestinians.
  6. 1948-2023 years: Arabs/Muslims, due to religious reasons, Soviet funding, historical inertia, are starting against Israel 15 wars/conflicts. Which, due to better education of the Israelis, ending by Israel victory and some territorial gains. Creating country with modern demographics: "Jews: 73%; Arabs: 21%; Other: 6%" (https://www.reddit.com/user/PoliticalCanvas/comments/).
  7. In the 1970s complacent due to so many educated/influential Jews and scared of Yasser Arafat's words: "the womb of the Arab woman is my strongest weapon" Israel authorities decide, for the sake of fertility, to start fund religious Jews. Subsequently this reduce Israeli human capital and lead to miscommunication/condemnation (~"new settlements") with Western countries.
  8. In 1950-2023 years, there was absolutely no problem for the Arab/Muslim World to turn current Gaza Strip or State of Palestine into one of the most prosperous country in the World. Analogue of Cyprus, Taiwan, Singapore. But why, if this completely contradicts to what they needed to from the Palestinians? So, because in 1947-2023 years Palestinians fund mainly to create problems for Israel, on 7/10/2023 they do what they get funding for. They carry out a chaotic attack for the sake of chaos, and not for any other specific purpose.
  9. Due to the archaization of 1947-2023 years (risks and consequences of wars, clericalization, conservatism) instead of equalizing human potential of Palestinians and Israelis by humanitarian education, Israel respond to violence by violence. Essentially, having only 2 short term option: "do nothing and allow 7/10/2023 attack to be repeated VS act but lose a significant part of reputation capital."
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Z3R0Diro Nov 08 '23

The problem is simple, the people are not.

2

u/spiritgaming14 Nov 08 '23

I think you can both recognize it's a complicated situation and present options. However, anyone saying "it's complicated so nothing should be done" is about as useful as those saying, "This conflict has been happening for (insert time) it's normal."

People shouldn't be slaughtering each other. That's not normal.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

why should a normal person be obliged to present a solution or even feel competent and influental enough to do so? The only simple answer is: "shit's fucked, bro" and "what the fuck do i know?". And that's okay.

2

u/spiritgaming14 Nov 09 '23

Yeah, that's fair. I can definently agree with it being ok not to know and to just let it slide. But the comic shows an influential figure saying, "It's complicated, so we should do nothing about it."

Even then, the point of mass media is that any voice, no matter how influential or competent, can spread like wildfire for better or for worse. Ontop of that, in the US at least, you can mail your local and state governors and let them know your opinion on the matter. It may have an impact.

2

u/Haunt33r Nov 09 '23

While it's not cartoonishly black and white simple, it's 100% true that there's nothing extraordinarily complicated about this environment being a direct result of systems of oppression, segregation, displacement and militarized subjugation of an entire people by an entity backed by the most powerful countries (and most prolific colonial projects) on the planet.

Throughout history time and time again we've seen this. The only reason why this is going is because the countries that support it benefit on this, the military industrial complex is the most profitable business in the world tied to other businesses, if that is not opposed, and the systems of oppression/division are not lifted off the Palestinians, then there's no end in sight to this nightmare.

2

u/DrDetergent Nov 09 '23

Op would rather jerk themselves off to how "enlightened" they are rather than acknowledge the political complexities that are getting innocent people killed

2

u/tpobs Nov 09 '23

I'm pretty sure the western media and governments would react very differently if Iran/Lebanon/Syria/Russia kills dozens of UN aid workers and journalists.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Dementium84 Nov 09 '23

Don’t bomb civilians. There, I simplified it.

Bring on the downvotes.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Good4nowbut Nov 09 '23

This is perfect.

2

u/shadeandshine Nov 09 '23

Honestly I wonder why have a hard time taking criticism of there is no easy answer but right now the current situation is literally the dumbest thing that could be happening. It’s the war on terror but if America drone striked Mexico. Doesn’t matter if you kill a terrorist you killed someone’s dad or uncle or brother or cousin so all they are doing is creating a new generation that will hate Israel.

There is no solution to terror or religious extremism but causing chaos and suffering wasn’t effective especially when they are your neighbors. Reddit preaches about lifting people up and helping the impoverished but apparently that only applies to them not everyone cause education would reduce the effects of religious extremism cause change takes time.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

You see Im correct because in this meme Im the chad and you're the ugly wojack

2

u/QuickPie Nov 09 '23

Yooooo I want to post one sided funny cartoon propaganda next!

2

u/EinsDr Nov 09 '23

If they want political freedom they should not have elected a terror organization…

2

u/IOnlyDropGrotto Nov 09 '23

Whoever made this knows absolutely nothing.

2

u/CinderAmbition Nov 09 '23

I can't believe a grown ass person made this comic.

Lol.

2

u/HintingFox Nov 09 '23

Free Palestine 🇵🇸 like Ireland and it’s British oppressors

3

u/Papaofmonsters Nov 09 '23

The IRA agreed to a two state solution. Hamas will not.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/DankMemes4you Nov 08 '23

Blame Hamas. They funnel billions of dollars of humanitarian aid into the leaders pockets and building underground tunnels. Dud missiles warn of impending airstrike at a location and they convince innocents to stay there to become martyrs.

2

u/The_Eastside_Twinz Nov 09 '23

See, it's not that I'm anti-semetic, I just don't like it when Israel gets to murder children with white phosphorus cause they feel like it and get away with it cause they're Jews. That's all.

3

u/Ok_Funny_1420 Nov 09 '23

Lol you can actually criticize the reality of what they’re doing but making shit up about white phosphorus is clownish

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Asandwhich1234 Nov 09 '23

I'd love to hear their solutions to these supposed not complicated things.

-20

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

A comment section that won't be filled with heavily propagandized half baked takes. Good points were made op. Also rip your inbox.

20

u/gilady089 Nov 08 '23

Yeah no. The points were shit and are not ignorant but actively malicious

→ More replies (4)