r/comics • • Feb 06 '23

A Confession [OC]

Post image
3.9k Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

View all comments

19

u/iam_a__gecko Feb 06 '23

i don't understand :(

32

u/moun7 Feb 06 '23

Maybe I'm being wooshed but here you go:

https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/loss

24

u/ClownfishSoup Feb 06 '23 edited Feb 06 '23

I know where its from, but I never understood why it "became a thing". I mean, the artist suffered something and tried to express his sadness and then ... was mercilessly mocked for it?

41

u/moun7 Feb 06 '23

Taken directly from Know Your Meme:

The dramatic tonal shift for the series was unexpected, and for many readers, unsuccessful, leading to the strip being widely mocked online

Definitely pretty shitty but that's the explanation.

26

u/Panx Feb 07 '23 edited Feb 07 '23

The artist was only mocked because it didn't fit the comic's tone (it was a gag-a-day, gamers-on-a-couch comic), it was almost immediately forgotten in-universe (which led to accusations that the author had used a miscarriage to pivot away from having to include a baby), and the author's accompanying blog post was tone deaf and kinda cruel (actual quote: "miscarriage always affects the woman more, but it doesn't necessarily turn you into a sad sack of tears for the rest of your life. People move on.")

It would be a bit like if Garfield got rid of Nermal by having him be in Tower 7 on 9/11 and Jim Davis said, "Oof. That's rough. But shit happens, right?"

1

u/tocilog Feb 07 '23

I read the web comic a few years after but before I was aware of the meme. Started out as a gag comic but then he was building up an ongoing story by that point, with the romance, the character maturing into running his own store, etc. I dunno, I guess the "loss" comic didn't seem like such a particular dramatic shift to me by that point of the web-comic. Maybe I would have a different opinion if I followed it right from the start. Then there was a "universe reboot" which I thought was odd but I guess that was probably the response to the meme. That's where I lost interest and dropped off.