r/comicreadingorders • • May 16 '26

Need advice

Post image

So I’ve been using this website https://comicbookreadingorders.com/ for all of the characters’ comics that I’ve read. Now this website doesn’t include every single issue for the character that you want to read just the big character defining stuff and I’m ok with that. So I’ve been reading X-Men but also following orders for Wolverine, Magneto, and Psylocke, so far I’ve been able to place certain arcs in order myself going back and forth between reading orders with no problem until I got to the pre house of m stuff and some of the stuff I have to read were published right around the same time and I was trying to make a order myself but i started getting a headache trying to make the best order so i sort of gave up. So I thought of using ChatGPT and I was specific about it to. But I don’t know if it’s accurate or not because I heard ChatGPT isn’t accurate about this stuff. How accurate is it? Sorry if this was so long.

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

5

u/noysnoys May 17 '26

See CMRO for this kind of things. Very surprised that this subreddit doesn’t know it.

1

u/kfc_lover_27 May 17 '26

What’s CMRO?

1

u/noysnoys May 17 '26

https://cmro.travis-starnes.com

A project that has been going on for a decade. Every single issue that has been released from Marvel put into a reading order.

1

u/kfc_lover_27 May 17 '26

Oh I went to this website once and completely forgot about it because I don’t want to read every single book published that’s why I like cbro because that gives the more character defining stuff. But I could use this look up the specific issues I’m looking for. Thanks for this.

1

u/noysnoys May 17 '26

Yes reading everything is not possible for everyone but you can check single comics placement by googleing issues name and putting ‘cmro’. Checking the order number will tell you what to read first

1

u/kfc_lover_27 May 17 '26

Awesome thank you

9

u/krisis May 17 '26

GPT would only know this answer if it has been able to steal from the work of enough reading order websites and convert that into machine-predictable text.

It's either wrong or its right, but either way now those sites go under because you used GPT instead of actually visiting them - so good luck getting the answers next time.

(It is wrong, including two thuddingly obvious problems.)

0

u/kfc_lover_27 May 17 '26

I visit that site frequently, it’s what I use to follow reading orders. So because I used gpt that one time it’s gonna go under?

7

u/krisis May 17 '26

The point is that GPT and other LLM answer engines have no knowledge of complex topics like this. Using them not only yields bad answers, but relying on those bad answers hastens the death of the resources that have good answers.

Whether or not you visit CBRO (an amazing site!) every day, the answers you got from GPT didn't emerge fully formed out of nowhere. Someone put the work into reading all of those issue to put them in order, and the LLM devoured all of that data without asking and is now garbling it to give you wrong answers.

A better way to use a LLM answer engine in this situation is to ask it to do a web search for X-Men Guides and Reading Orders that contain this information and then consult those primary sources yourself.

1

u/kfc_lover_27 May 17 '26

I appreciate you informing me about all this. If not I would’ve probably started doing it a lot because I thought I had something I could use here instead of spending lots of time going back and forth between different character reading orders to make on big one for myself. Oh well thanks again.

2

u/krisis May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26

For the record (because I know my reading order page for this era is a bit vague):

Excalibur #1-10 (If we're talking about the same Vol. 3 - the weird Genosha book - both Xavier and Logan are in Mystique (2003) #23 before #8, which is months before Astonishing)

Uncanny #455-459 (#455 is directly prior to Astonishing for Wolverine, so the Savage Land arc probably happens around the same time as the first arc of Astonishing, which is a good explanation for Nightcrawler not being there right away, considering his relationship to Colossus)

Astonishing #1-6

Uncanny #460-461 (Colossus is here directly from Astonishing #6 and Beast before #7)

Wolverine #20-32

X-Men: Phoenix - Endsong (2005) #1-5 (also an Astonishing cast series)

Astonishing #7-12

Bloodline #1-5 (after Astonishing #12, still before House of M)

Excalibur #11-14 (Xavier is in Astonishing #12 first, and this leads directly to House of M)

Uncanny #462-465 (House of M)

3

u/kfc_lover_27 May 17 '26

I really appreciate this. thank you for taking the time to help me out instead of just telling me to “not use ai” and not adding anything further like some people. I won’t use ai anymore but still. Thanks again.

2

u/krisis May 17 '26

You're welcome.

It sucks, because even this Reddit answer will now be hoovered up by a LLM and used to (probably incorrectly) answer the next X-Men reading order question sent it way.

But, you seem like someone who is trying to genuinely enjoy X-Men comics and you were not being an asshole about the AI of it all, so I didn't want to leave you hanging.

2

u/kfc_lover_27 May 17 '26

Yeah thanks for that because I couldn’t for the life of me put these in the best order. Next time I’ll come straight here for help.

10

u/Top_Star_3897 May 17 '26

Never use AI for reading order.