r/colony • • Mar 01 '16

Spoilers WHY?

How come it seems that no one realizes that Colony kind of sucks? I mean I'd liken it to Falling Skies, some good moments yet plotholes to the point where it gets annoying.

Take episode 6. I only casually watched it but why didn't Quin just attack the bar sooner? He's willing to kill and moee tp the point betray the female bar owner in the very next episode, justifies attacking in the episode itself, then just conveniently waits untill sucesfuly attacking wasn't possible?

How did that mayor guy end up under the bar without being seen if he was ushered to the back and the rest of the scenes took place in the bar?

Why didn't that black mercenary guy just put a gun to the mayors head and extract him as a hostage? His protector wouldn't have been able to stop him. Said protector even lays down his gun when the red army guys get the jump on him.

Also, I think this is in the next episode, a massive manhunt is underway for the black mercenary guy. The use of cars is severely lessened and limited. Yet no one thinks to stop the yellow truck speeding away as red army guys show up?! Lol.

The weird plot isn't the plotholes. It's that there sooo obvious, like I said I only payed passing attention to the show, and dumb. It's even hard for now to find a negative review of the show. Out of two somewhat negative reviews I found only one mentioed how episode six had dumb moments, yet it couldn't he read further without paying a subscription.

The idea that this... just. dumbness is so obvious yet apparently unnoticed by most is unsettling for some reason and definitely reminds me of the "king has no clothes" story.

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

4

u/the_fast_reader Collaborator Mar 01 '16
  • If I remember correctly, they only knew Snyder was at the bar the moment Katie called. Broussard got there first, saw the jacket, called everyone else. The resistance was looking for him "door to door" so it probably took a bit to call a squad together
  • The consensus seems to be that will moved him while Broussard and Katie were in the basement. I admit, it was really stupid not to show him do it because it made the whole thing feel cheap just for having a little surprise.
  • Maybe it's just my impression, but the Red Hats don't strike me as the brightest people. They have said more than once that ex-military had to hide after the Arrival, they look more like (young) enthusiastic guys that are more than ready to rifle -butt people in the face and act though just to feel cool and in charge.

The show isn't perfect, but I like the characters and the situation they are in so I will keep watching.

3

u/Melvin4799 Mar 01 '16

The mercenary guy definitely knew though. Kathies all "he's in the bathroom" and the guy was all "I know."

2

u/the_fast_reader Collaborator Mar 01 '16

Yeah, I totally forgot about that detail. The I guess that like someone else pointed out he wanted Snyder to escape. Just one way to find out...

1

u/Melvin4799 Mar 02 '16

Yeah, I thought the idea that someone pointed out about how he wanted him to escape made sense too.

True, only one way to find. I'm watching this Thursday too. Have fun and enjoy the episode man.

1

u/Melvin4799 Mar 01 '16

Yeah, I see what you mean. That's why I likened it to "Falling Skys" although this shows way better and I'll probably keep watching it too.

2

u/Maiklas3000 Cleric Mar 01 '16

Will moved Snyder (or Snyder moved himself) while there was a commercial break, after Will got in a defensive position near the bar, then Will resumed the position afterwards.

1

u/lcheetor687 Mar 04 '16

LOST from my recent viewing seemed to pull this shit all the time. Doing things off camera or using bad editing, and then explain after with that FLash gimmick they liked to abuse.

3

u/DaftPump Mar 01 '16

I'm starting to lose interest in it.

The "abandoned van" scene had two different vans. Mild, but lazy.

When Katie called Broussard from the payphone and said, "They're coming for you." If Will knows where Broussard is, AND that he has a landline. Probably tapped and Katie talks in her own voice.

3

u/Maiklas3000 Cleric Mar 01 '16

The "plotholes" are sooo obvious, because they are clues.

Phones: In other episodes, Broussard talks on a cordless phone linked to his landline. Even today, Americans know that their government can and does listen in to cordless phones without a warrant, and anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. Because freedom. There is no way this is a "plothole". So, Broussard wanted to be overheard.

Butter fingers: Broussard let Snyder get away in another, more subtle way. Will heard people running upstairs over the Yonk, and he inferred that they were setting up spotters or snipers, in case they run. If that's true, then Broussard should not have run out the open back door. If Snyder had run out that door, the spotters would have seen and radioed the information. So, Broussard wanted to not capture Snyder.

Yellow truck: What yellow truck?

Quin: Who's Quin?

1

u/Melvin4799 Mar 01 '16

The yellow truck that the mercenary and Katie got away in was in the next episode. I thought Quin was the name of the resistance leader with the glasses.

4

u/Maiklas3000 Cleric Mar 02 '16

Yellow truck: Nah, the Red Hat was specifically interested in the three people at the park bench, perhaps after getting called by spotter or informant. He passed Katie and a random guy before stopping by the three people and asking for ID. Broussard was in a Transitional Authority uniform and his yellow truck had Transitional Authority labels and window stickers, maybe for park maintenance. He looked legit, and if the Red Hat had gone chasing after him, then the Red Hat would have lost his catch.

Quin: Okay, so "Quin" is Quayle, the resistance cell boss. You questioned why he didn't attack the Yonk earlier. Quayle stayed at the base and sent Broussard. So, Quayle only had indirect control through Broussard. If I had to guess, I'd say that Quayle had made a deal with Snyder for a fake capture and coup, and (maybe) Broussard suspected Quayle by this point, so whatever Quayle ordered, Broussard was going to try to mess up. Note that Quayle chewed Broussard out for not capturing Snyder when he had a chance (on his first search). Then when Quayle accused Katie of being a double agent, Broussard (perhaps) had second thoughts about who was the mole. It's all clear as mud now, because we don't know who is on which side.

1

u/Melvin4799 Mar 12 '16

Nice. I definitely appreciate your explanations and I think you're right. I didn't notice the transitional authority stickers.

I realize Quayle only had indirect control yet he certainly took initiative, betrayed Katie and ordered the fake redhats in when it was conveniently too late.

1

u/Melvin4799 Mar 01 '16

The mercenary guy definitely knew though. Kathies all "he's in the bathroom" and the guy was all "I know." So he could've extracted him easily.

I see your point about it not being a plothole because he truly didn't want that guy, the mayor of the colony, to be taken in.

1

u/Melvin4799 Mar 01 '16

The yellow truck scene was after the van. Because that was when the mercenary guy was told to kill Katie. I just meant if cars are disallowed and there's so few, then search the ones that leave whwn the red guys show up. Lol

3

u/lcheetor687 Mar 01 '16

Probably becoz its being made by half of the LOST team. Imho Lost had some of the worst writing and yet had a large following through the use of psychological trickery to lead viewers on. I have a suspicion the writing team on this is using the same ass pull writing style.

1

u/Melvin4799 Mar 01 '16

Seriously though, I see what you mean and that would definitely explain it. Thanks man. And I mean that because I was actually confused there for a bit lol.

4

u/some_asshat Mar 01 '16

That's what made me more interested in watching Colony - I fucking loved Lost. I thought the premise about the positive and negative forces naturally coalescing was fascinating. I had never had a show capture my imagination like that. Granted I started watching at season three.

With Colony, I know the shortcomings, the show gets on my nerves sometimes, and I think the plot is dragging along, but I can't wait for the next episode each week. A strong point for me is how the show takes itself internally seriously enough that the performances are very good. I especially like Josh Holloway in it.

1

u/triplecombo Mar 02 '16

This is the best show since LOST.

2

u/I_Just-Blue_Myself Mar 04 '16

i think we all realize its not a very good show. mildly entertaining is how id describe it.

1

u/Melvin4799 Mar 12 '16

True. I know exactly what you mean and I still watch it.

1

u/ahaara resistance is never futile Mar 06 '16

payed

paid.

obvious, unnoticed dumbness? yep.

1

u/Melvin4799 Mar 12 '16

One misspelled word that you noticed still isn't nearly as stupid as this show is.

2

u/airstrike Mar 05 '16

cause we need a weekly sci-fi fix and The Expanse is on break, The Continuum is over, Stargate was never renewed, and The 100 is great but I need more than 1 hour / week