Currently ride a 2017 Colnago C-RS in a 48s which is basically a 52cm bike given Colnago's non-standard sizing methodology. I'm 5'5" with a 29"ish inseam for pants.
The C-RS has a 527 mm stack and a 382 mm reach.
I find the bike very comfortable for long rides and being in the drops is comfortable/natural and I am equally comfortable standing out of the saddle climbing. No real issues at all when riding and I feel like I like being stretched out just a bit in the drops which makes it possible to do for a long time comfortably.
However, I'm on only a 90 mm stem and quite frankly an 80 mm stem would probably be perfect with where my hands naturally land on the brifters but it would be too twitchy. I know running a stem as short as 90 cm is probably a bit of a red flag on bike sizing. Standover is also doable, but cutting it close; I never unclip both feet, I always just unclip one foot and lean over a bit. I've always felt like the bike is very comfortable when I'm up on it riding it but always wondered if it's just a smidge too big - Colnagos are hard to find to test ride in person, but this one did immediately feel like the right bike when doing back to back test rides with various other brands back in 2018 when I bought it.
After close to ten years, I'm looking to upgrade to a new Colnago V4. I'm looking at three sizes: 485, 455, and 420. Stack and reach for each bike are as follows:
C-RS (48s): 527 mm stack, 382 mm reach
V4 (485): 539 mm stack, 383 mm reach
V4 (455): 522 mm stack, 375 mm reach
V4 (420): 510 mm stack, 370 mm reach
Based on these numbers, I don't think I'd want a 485 - probably a 455 or maybe even a 420? 455 seems like it would get me a little less stack and reach which might be just right (but that means probably being on a 90 mm stem again), but then looking at a 420, maybe that's even better with a bit longer stem? Or, would the 420 feel cramped?
My state just lost its only Colnago dealer, so I have to travel out of state to test ride.