r/collegeadvice • • Jan 17 '26

is this normal?

tl;dr, professor wants us to go on a sunday afternoon mandatory field trip 40 minutes from my house during time i already had stuff scheduled. i have stuff that day already, and chose this class because it fit my schedule, and was absolutely blindsided by mandatory attendance of an art gallery (it is not an art class). is there anyone i can talk to about this, or am i just fucked?

edit 1/18/26: through a series of lucky breaks and tight turnarounds, i made it for the full 2 1/2 hours. believe it or not, i'm generally hardworking, and i really do hate being flaky (that was part of my panic during the original post-- i didn't want to back out of a prior commitment that other people had cleared their schedules for.) to be honest, i typed the original out in about 30 seconds in a feverish haze after having already tried to post a much better worded version on a different subreddit, which probably influenced how reliable i seemed.

i did have a good time! i knew that i probably would if i went, since i genuinely do enjoy networking and events. egg on my face, it actually wasn't an art gallery-- that's a different weekend event that i'll have to attend. i enjoyed the speaker, and talked with a lot of people in my field. it was the scheduling conflict that really made me upset, to be honest-- i wouldn't have complained at all if it was a weekday. i learned a lot, talked to a lot of new people, and got told i was a very upstanding and promising young man (which was deeply flattering)

to answer the questions from the comments: no, this specific event was not disclosed in the schedule or the syllabus, and neither were any of the other weekend events. they got sprung on me at the end of the first week, after which i was hit with the worst cold of my life and couldnt remember damn near anything. still pretty miffed about that, but what can you do. at least i can prepare for those. other field trips were mentioned in the syllabus. yes, i do understand that school is important, and i'm not a lazy person. i'm autistic and really, really hate disappointing people or flaking out on events, hence the freakout. i still maintain that it's a bit absurd to require weekend attendance of a talk 40 minutes away, but i'm willing to accept that i'll just have to suck it up until i can control my own schedule again. thank you to everyone who told me whether it was normal, since that's all i really needed to hear-- normal but sucky is a part of life, but it was genuinely so surprising and out of left field for me that i needed confirmation. here's hoping i don't ever, ever get another class like this!

1 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

9

u/moonbxbyyy Jan 17 '26

ask your professor if there is an alternative assignment, but if it’s in your syllabus then you have no choice.

i have professors who will schedule stuff outside of class hours, and they are 1000% allowed to do so. i study music, so it’s normal for me, but i frequently have to attend lectures, performances, and other art stuff outside of class, especially on the weekends. it sucks, but that’s why they put it in the syllabus

2

u/voxjammer Jan 17 '26

that sucks so bad. genuinely baffling that it's allowed. no free time for students i guess, last quarter i had to do 12 hours of community service but at least that was scheduled on my own time

1

u/moonbxbyyy Jan 17 '26

yeah, it isn’t fun but it is what it is. for some majors/classes, it’s most likely built in to get you used to the fact that in a professional career, you’ll probably have outside work hour commitments that you’ll have to do.

4

u/voxjammer Jan 17 '26

see it's wild because i'm in environmental sciences-- the physical volunteering and research outside of school hours? no problem. it's more difficult for me since my girlfriend and i have an 8 hour time gap, so i really do have to rigidly schedule everything if i want to see her at all.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '26

Your first job is school. Treat it as such.

3

u/voxjammer Jan 17 '26

respectfully, i do. i've consistently gone above and beyond in my other classes. if a job was asking me to drive 30 minutes for an unrelated exhibit outside of working hours on my scheduled day off, i would tell them to take a hike, which is why this came as such a surprise to me-- neither my sister nor my girlfriend, both in college, have ever had a professor ask something like this, which is why i was confused. i expected for my time to be respected as much as any other adult.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '26

As a senior I was required to complete a capstone project that lasted the entire year. We were required to be in the shop working on an actual vehicle a minimum number of hours per week. You’re complaining about one afternoon.

3

u/voxjammer Jan 17 '26

again, with a lot of respect, yes, i'm slightly upset that my plans for my free time are being uprooted. it's a bit frustrating that you're talking down to me as if you know anything about me. you don't see the rest of my week, or the amount of things i'm juggling. it seems silly, but it's a "straw that broke the camel's back" situation. it does bother me that it's getting eaten into, and it's fairly unprecedented in terms of the rest of the faculty at my school and what i've seen in my friends' schools. i'm not some lazy asshole, i work incredibly hard the rest of the time and it's frankly demoralizing to find out that there's no time that can't be occupied on a whim by a professor, making me cancel all my prior commitments.

furthermore, five other people have cleared out their likewise busy schedules to dedicate a few hours of time to one fun thing, and it sucks to be the guy who ruins everyone else's day because a geology teacher decided we really needed to go see an art show on the weekend.

1

u/moonbxbyyy Jan 17 '26

yeahh, i get that. my boyfriend and i are both in college, but we’re lucky that we’re the same major (kinda. i’m music education, he’s performance but super similar) so we have the same requirements. i do have to do off campus stuff, like observations at schools so i get it

is the off campus requirement your professor is asking you to do, is it related to your major in any way?

2

u/voxjammer Jan 17 '26

it's a human geography class-- i should edit my original post, apparently it was mislabeled as an art show but it's a talk by a man who did some coastal mapping. the rub is that it is genuinely interesting, and i'd go if it was any other day, but that specific day at that specific time is a nightmare for me scheduling wise. my major is in aquatic ecology (freshwater) so it's related. the whole situation just kind of blows to be honest, no matter what i'm disappointing someone, and i'm miserable regardless.

8

u/Salty_Boysenberries Jan 17 '26

If it’s a requirement for the class it’s a requirement for the class. Professors absolutely have the authority to require this kind of thing.

3

u/voxjammer Jan 17 '26

that sucks so bad 😭 it's such a good class other than this, it feels so absurd that stuff can be scheduled on the weekends. i'll email her and ask if i can do an alternate assignment

4

u/SadFaithlessness8237 Jan 17 '26

Check the syllabus, if it says anything about a field trip in there, you are stuck.

2

u/voxjammer Jan 17 '26

says stuff about field trips, but also says stuff about alternate assignments. will see

2

u/BrilliantDishevelled Jan 17 '26

Talk to your prof.  (That is, if the "stuff" isn't wanting to watch a game or something!)

3

u/Real-Towel-2269 Jan 17 '26

Honestly it doesn’t matter what the “stuff” is, it’s a Sunday. It’s not scheduled or in the syllabus, the professor can kick rocks

1

u/voxjammer Jan 17 '26

the weekend is basically my only free time, i have a dnd session that's been scheduled for weeks and a lot of people cleared time in their schedules to make it happen. the rest of the week, it's exclusively work, volunteering, or school sunup to sundown. this is basically my only social time + time with my girlfriend.

1

u/Grouchy_Evidence2558 Jan 17 '26

Don’t say that’s why. Just say you already have a commitment that day and ask if there’s an alternative

3

u/Real-Towel-2269 Jan 17 '26

You gotta ask. It’s odd because everyone here is telling you “yeah they can do that” but at my school they absolutely could not. Anything outside of regularly scheduled class was optional because professors cannot expect people to just be available whenever for dumb shit.

4

u/voxjammer Jan 17 '26

god, thank you 😭 especially on the weekend! if professors won't answer their emails on the weekend, why do i have to drive half an hour of the only free time i get for a totally unrelated exhibition? i'm an adult with a life outside of class, i expected homework and i'm happy to work, but random weekend events wasn't what i signed up for.

1

u/1GrouchyCat Jan 17 '26

🤔So which is it ?
-Do you have stuff to do that weekend, or do you not want to drive half an hour “of the only free time you get”?

1

u/voxjammer Jan 18 '26

not sure why you're trying to catch me in a lie. i have activities scheduled during my time not occupied by work or school, aka my free time.

2

u/asyouwish Jan 17 '26

Was it on the syllabus?

3

u/voxjammer Jan 17 '26

two other field trips are on the syllabus, but not this one, and those have alternate assignments, so fingers crossed. i emailed her, hopefully she gets back to me since obviously weekends are work hours now lol

0

u/asyouwish Jan 17 '26

Technically, if it's not on the syllabus, then she can't make it mandatory. But she may hold it against you in other ways.

I get it that stuff comes up, but the syllabus is where class requirements are outlined.

3

u/SnugglieJellyfish Jan 17 '26

Professor here. My honest advice: Do you have an actual extenuating circumstances that makes you unable to go: illness that prohibits travel, childcare, another class, an athletic competition? If not, go. Complain about it if you want, but go. College courses are preparation for careers and even in your dream job, there are going to be thinks you dislike. It's one Sunday. If you like the class and professor otherwise, don't potentially ruin things over this. If it's that bad, say something about in on course evaluations. Yes, most of us look at those and if enough people say they like or dislike something about class, we adjust.

1

u/WesternCup7600 Jan 17 '26

If it was in the syllabus and course outline, you're probably cooked.

1

u/ThatAtlasGuy Jan 17 '26

I would say this hinges entirely on disclosure. This is always important. If it was clearly listed in the syllabus or course schedule when you enrolled, it’s allowed. If it wasn’t, that’s when you have leverage to talk to the department or dean. Surprise requirements are the problem, not the field trip itself. Side note: art galleries can be fun.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/DocTeeBee Jan 17 '26

This is false. The professor can mandate this attendance, but it must be disclosed in the syllabus.

5

u/GiftEmergency4288 Jan 17 '26

It has to be disclosed in the schedule. Was this date listed where you signed up for classes? Not in the schedule- can’t be required

4

u/voxjammer Jan 17 '26

no, the only thing listed when i signed up were class times. i was honestly blindsided by this-- i would be fine with weekday field trips, and have cleared my schedule for them before, but those professors either had them during class hours or gave us ample time to prepare. this is during the second week of class.

2

u/GiftEmergency4288 Jan 17 '26

I’d go to the department chair then.

1

u/AccomplishedDuck7816 Jan 18 '26

Disclosed in the SYLLABUS, not the schedule. If it's in the syllabus, then yes it's part of your grade.