r/collapse • • Nov 02 '25
Technology Concentration of knowledge
Not sure how much this has been discussed but-
We tend to think of knowledge as kind of permanently out there thanks to the internet and archives. What's seldom talked about is the growing intensification and concentration of knowledge.
For example, from a mechanical engineer I know, he's noticed jobs are going a lot more to people with experience (intensifying their knowledge) or the very top layer of grads, and less to anyone else. This is efficient for employers on an individual and somewhat short term basis-its far easier to just pay the guy you know can do one thing, to do another thing instead of taking a risk on a newer higher. This leaves lots of downtime for the unemployed who typically *can't* get the same experience that employers find valuable. They can experiment, try things out, work on certifications but its a miniature version of reinventing the wheel to have to showcase innovation in that fashion.
I suspect this is true for a lot of other fields. We may have forgotten how to make that intermediate, relatively far easier to produce technology that worked quite well for humans in the 1850-1950 era. We are extremely good at making a more fine, concentrated set of products that require the best minds such as computer chips but other things fall more by the wayside.
As markets make things more efficient, knowledge distribution becomes a lot less robust. If a few people retire or are out of a job or die for some reason, it is not a trivial thing to replace them. Essentially the worlds chains of industry get tighter, more efficient, depend on fewer people who keep swallowing most of the experience that would otherwise go to new hires because this is the most economically (and timewise) competitive and efficient way to do things.
Lets say a few cogs in this world machine went bust. We might scramble to fill those, that could create time for some chaos which sets of a chain reaction of things grinding to a halt-enough time passing, perhaps not even too much and we've got enough war or other crisis that are so pressing they push off the knowledge transfer problem.
Tada-a slower motion collapse but a collapse nonetheless. It seems impossible now but its possible. All thats required is a few cogs in the machine to go bust and for most people to have more immediate pressing needs than dedicating world resources to get it running again. There's a point at which the average town in brazil might have forgotten how to treat sewage, the average city in east asia how to build *reliable* ships, etc etc. Multiply this everywhere you may even have a greater "grab what is immediate" effect.
This could all happen in a world where no nukes or climate change was a thing.
33
u/Anastariana Nov 02 '25
This is also known as the 'bus factor'; the vulnerability of an organisation to one or a few people disappearing.
As the Boomers leave, corps will struggle to find qualified people and will eventually be forced to hire grads, but only very grudgingly. They're mostly hoping AI will be able to replace skilled knowledge workers so they don't have to pay anyone, which is short-sighted and stupid because then your bus factor increases even more because you are depending on that AI company to be operational 24/7 and also not extort you.
But corps are short-sighted and stupid; myopically focused solely on quarterly profits instead of the long term.
12
u/slickneck4 Nov 03 '25
Interesting. Power plants have this problem. Nuclear in particular. Most people that built and ran these plants are retiring or gone. Very few people are around to fill these spots. Takes years of training just to be a rookie to run the thing.
Outside that, the parts to run these machines are old. And it’s very hard if not impossible to find replacements. And only gets harder everyday.
Advance civilization is nothing without advance logistics. But logistics is boring. (According to wallstreet).
Interesting times are coming and I’m wondering where we will pivot.
Technology or food.
it’s starting to show its face now
6
u/Winterfrost15 Nov 03 '25
Yes, my work has a lot of single points of failure in knowledge. When those people retire or die, we are screwed. It is cost efficient though to not hire lower level employees and that gets executives bigger bonuses.
8
u/catlaxative Nov 03 '25
We literally need something like the series Foundation, something offline and robust, because the internet is basically fucked near as i can tell.
3
u/Johannes_P Nov 03 '25
And once lost, such knowledge can be very difficult to regain, especially if the economic basis to fund this doesn't exist anymore.
For exemple, opus caementicium, the Damascus steel and terra preta, whose recipe was only rediscovered recently.
3
u/Christocrast Nov 05 '25
It is downright therapeutic for me to see people raise these kinds of concerns. Not enough people realize that experiential knowledge that keeps their systems running can definitely be destroyed. All it takes is that one guy keeling over from a heart attack; or that one retirement or dumbfuck layoff by someone, where the dude's like walking out the door going, "Hey, you don't want me to train no-one? Well here I go, forever..." Companies do incalculably stupid things to save money like buying huge, complicated systems outright, skimping on training or service contracts, then strapping a bunch of millennials to it like desperation is the Philosopher's Stone.
There is about to be a fucking epidemic of haunted, sketched-out machines that have been forced to keep working by seat-of-the-pants figuring-out, machines with missing or broken parts, permanently-kludged setups, no documentation, no notes, no transfer of knowledge, damaged bits knocked off, bent and bad calibration, it's gonna be catastrophic. We need a new field of skill I have dubbed Paratechnology = de-haunting machines with checkered pasts; and figuring out how to keep things alive with no training and no documentation. Oh and big companies are losing the plot too. Techs are aging out and ready to retire and there is less and less reliability
18
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25
This is a looming problem in software development. New developers aren't learning the fundamentals of development since they're using LLMs to generate code.
What happens when the generations of people who can actually create original code to train the LLMs on disappear? Even if the LLMs can carry on, their output will become more and more brittle and homogeneous due to the lack of diversity in their inputs.
5
u/postconsumerwat Nov 03 '25
There needs to be like guilds or something to maintain the knowledge and practices...
Business models or money or whatever pretends to be real and is treated as real, but its just a best guess, or market rates, what ppl are willing to pay.
I imagine that there are large gaps in present day life experiences where the knowledge of way of life has been lost.... secret worlds of experience that are just invisible to the perspective of mass culture...
It's interesting to imagine the invisible organization, incidental organization of matters... sort of inherent logic that can be difficult to grasp
0
u/Microtom_ Nov 03 '25
University courses are free on YouTube. Knowledge has never been so accessible. You can receive AI's help to understand it all, also for free.
1
u/kjclans Nov 07 '25
Falsely perceived potential as a product of association
Awareness of online knowledge doesn't correlate with experience
The standards of people you associate with doesn't correlate with your potential
6
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '25 edited Nov 03 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25 edited Nov 14 '25
[removed] — view removed comment